Home Campus Voices Muhlenberg College Republicans, welcome.

Muhlenberg College Republicans, welcome.

2284
Seth Buckwalter '28 comments on the Muhlenberg Republicans club. Logo from @berg.republicans on Instagram.
Seth Buckwalter '28 comments on the Muhlenberg Republicans club. Logo from @berg.republicans on Instagram.

This past weekend I was informed of the re-establishment of the Muhlenberg College

Republicans Club (BergRepublicans). My thoughts on the topic are many, though I remember the wise and fitting words of former Prime Minister of England, Winston Churchill, “Diplomacy is the art of telling plain truths without giving offense.”

My reasons for writing this editorial are many. First, there is the matter of context. Muhlenberg is a liberal arts college. Now, it is important to know that “liberal,” in the context of our great school, does not mean “liberal politics,” but rather, “willing to respect or accept behavior or opinions different from ones own; open to new ideas.” I raise this issue because the new Muhlenberg College Republicans Club Instagram account biography includes the phrase, “promoting conservative values.” I have long associated the word conservative with resistance to the change that comes with being open to new ideas. Isn’t an organization dedicated to promoting a fixed set of beliefs and declarations inherently opposite to the mission of an institution dedicated to new ideas?

Second, I am writing this article as I am unsure if this new Republicans Club understands its own mission. Allow me to explain. At the end of their official mission statement they write, “By embracing diversity within conservatism and encouraging open dialogue, we seek to break stereotypes and build a community where all voices are valued.” Is this statement not very obviously antithetical both to itself and to the ideals of conservatism? How can all voices be valued if the diversity you are embracing is “within conservatism?” Furthermore, how do you value all voices in a club dedicated to a specific set of values? Moreover, conservative comes from the root “conserve,” meaning “to keep something in the same state.” If they are truly a conservative organization, how can they support such ideas as open dialogue or breaking stereotypes? Aren’t stereotypes the very heart of what it means to be conservative? Isn’t conservative politics in the United States divided into the good, conservative, way of looking at the world and the bad, progressive, way of looking at the world? All of which suggest to me that this group is either unintentionally not conservative in nature, or simply does not actually know the values of traditional American “conservatism.” And if I sound like I am the one stereotyping here, please read on before making such a judgment.

My third point is another contextual one: the United States of America in 2025. The argument for the re-creation of a Republicans Club is a logical one: many groups of students have organizations that are centered around beliefs or characteristics, so why not politically right-leaning students? That itself is a perfectly reasonable and realistic statement, and one which I support. However, assuming the new Republicans Club filed its registration paperwork with the Republican National Committee, then, by association, this new club supports President Donald J. Trump and the Republican Party for whom he is the principal spokesperson. (I will work off that assumption until informed otherwise by a credible source). As I said, all people deserve a place to belong and be heard, as acceptance is paramount. But acceptance is a two-way street. How is the Muhlenberg community to hear the word “acceptance” from a club associated with a President who refers to immigrants to the United States as “animals,” “stone-cold killers,” “rapists” and “the worst people?” A President who refers to African Nations en masse as “shithole countries?” A President who refers to those who disagree with him as “the enemy from within?” And, finally, a President who outright and without context or reasoning, banned the entrance of any person who identifies as Muslim into this great and accepting nation? This new Republicans Club is being formed in a context. That context is, primarily, President Donald Trump – the face of the Republican Party in the United States of 2025. His words do not communicate acceptance of all people and all opinions; rather, he is the one who stereotypes large groups of people and casts them as outsiders.

Furthermore, my opinion on the association between President Trump’s words and The Republicans Club on Muhlenberg’s campus is not purely my own. It has been shaped by members of this community. Since the new Muhlenberg Republicans Club was revived I have spoken to numerous students on campus, some belonging to a variety of minority groups, and I have been told the following: “I feel like this is just about sending a message, nothing more. If they were working to make the college better, I would support that. But, I have to ask, ‘What is their goal?’ I just feel like it will make more division. I thought Muhlenberg was a safe space for people like me.” And, “The point of special groups on campus is to share our communities and cultures. I feel like the only community or culture they have is a culture of ‘us versus them’ and I don’t want that.” In the context of USA 2025, a club with the name Republican attached to it has a heavy burden if it intends to convince a college community that they are interested in all voices and welcoming students as they are.

Finally, I will say this. Trust is a two-way street. You cannot expect us as a school and as individuals who wish and yearn for an egalitarian society to trust you as an organization when key tenets of your group include keeping things the same as they are or once were, and excluding the voices of persons who do not fit your accepted way of being. (My inclusion of the word “exclude” is not an analysis of your personal beliefs, but rather of your choice to associate with an organization that has time and time again lived up to the meaning of that word.) How do we go about welcoming those who do not welcome others? The voices of many leading Republicans in our nation use words like patriot, Christian and America first to describe themselves.  Many in the Muhlenberg community are dubious about these claims and therefore about you. I, for one, will find it hard to trust that you want to embrace diversity, encourage open dialogue, break stereotypes and value all voices until I have seen it. I do, however, remain optimistic that this new organization will live up to the words of the founder of their party, Abraham Lincoln, “We’re going to propose solutions that serve both sides’ interests.” On a more personal note, I will say something to the club’s members directly. 

Dear Muhlenberg College Republicans,

I recently noticed that you reposted a meme in which President Trump was holding a fictitious executive order that says, “executive order to bring back the $5 footlong.” I do objectively find that pretty fucking funny and agree with the sentiment; however, we will not get back to our $5-foot-long subs if you insist on supporting a President who implemented a tariff on Canadian grain, beef and pork this past week.

Thank you and sincerely,

–Seth Eric Buckwalter

+ posts

Seth '28 is a Sustainability Studies and Business Administration major. He is part of the Muhlenberg Weekly, SGA, and Chapel Council. When he isn't writing, he is usually going for a walk, drawing, or doing work.