Home Arts & Culture The story of “Scary White”

The story of “Scary White”

Fall 2026’s musical performance was a theatrical triumph.

186
"Carrie: The Musical" was completely sold out on opening night, Oct. 28, with a waitlist exceeding 100 people. Photo by Marco Calderon.

Last weekend, Muhlenberg’s theatre department ran its newest production, “Carrie: The Musical,” from Oct. 28 to Nov. 1. Based on Stephen King’s novel, the show follows Carrie White, a socially awkward high school student who comes to possess the power of telekinesis. Her solitary life is ultra-supervised by her mother, Margaret, who is hyper-religious. White eventually goes to prom, where she is made into a joke by fellow classmates. As a result, she decides to seek retribution against them using her newfound abilities.

Through the portrayal of the White family, themes of girlhood and mother-daughter dynamics are present. Religion is a tool of authority used by Carrie’s mom. The musical itself focuses primarily on the concepts of bullying, popularity and social hierarchy. A production such as this one is especially significant to the college community because it presents a certain message about social settings: the power held in numbers is strong, for better or for worse. In the same sense that a group can speak up and create change, they can also talk down and cause damage.

The show itself completely sold out before opening night, with over 100 people on the waitlist. According to Rowan Panana Mendez ‘30, a theatre marketing student worker, Muhlenberg’s theatre marketing department was “very happy that [they] had completely sold out shows.” As the first official musical production of the year, “Carrie” brought about sales that set a promising premise for the rest of the semester.

A new take was brought to the stage, literally: the audience was seated on the Empie Theatre stage as a means of getting close to the cleverly crafted set of “Carrie.” As a result, the intimate proximity of characters drew audience members in and created a physical connection between the viewers and the cast. Serious scenes became moments in which the audience acted as musical bystanders.

Last weekend’s performances also showcased a brilliant feature of the set: giant windows which slammed shut at Carrie’s cue right before intermission. This detail added to the supernatural aspect of the musical and was a great technical addition. Abby Bera ‘27, starring as Carrie, said “The special effects were a lot of fun, the really cool ones, like the windows closing and the blood, we didn’t work with until we were almost done with tech. The blood was really cool. They had done two blood tests without the actual blood just to see what it would look like, how it would feel, the consistency and where I would stand, then we started using the actual blood during the dress rehearsals.” She shares that the blood felt “very sticky, and it didn’t take me a long time to get it all off, which was good. It was very cool to work with, and it made me feel like I was really Carrie!”

In terms of planning for the show, Choreographer Lyndsey Vader claims one of the most interesting things about her role was working to “find the balance between the real and the surreal.” As someone returning to musical theater production after about ten years, she finds such an approach to be “a really beautiful gift.” The choreographer’s work with Musical Director Julius Sarkozy was considered to be by Vader “not two distinct things, but really … complementary.” 

There is no lack of recognition regarding the talent of Muhlenberg’s theatre department. In fact, audience member Connor Squires ‘30 recalls “seeing theater at Muhlenberg is what made [them] fall in love with the school because of the production value, acting and technical elements.” Bera’s performance as Carrie White was both accurate to the musical character and the impacts of her background in the original novel. To Squires, “the most interesting theme … was faith and how it plays into Carrie’s upbringing and her shy anxious mannerisms.”

As a Muhlenberg box office success, “Carrie” is a musical that highlights the strengths of the College’s theatre department: in cohesive production and technical skill, in talented musical performances and in efficient storytelling. Audience and crew alike had nothing but positive feedback for the Muhlenberg production of the Stephen King musical adaptation. Grateful for the opportunity to have played Miss Gardner, Joi Brown-Harrell ‘28 thanked her “castmates, the crew and everyone involved in making this experience something that I’ll never forget.” Bera has only received good feedback from audience members, sharing “The product we created is probably the thing I’m most proud of [during] my time here at Muhlenberg and it’s a good last show to end my four years.” 

As Vader states, “Carrie” is a “testament to the complexity of the human spirit.” The performance serves as a prime example of why anyone curious about the theatre department here at Muhlenberg should not hesitate to dive in, whether it be through watching or joining a show.

+ posts