Home Sports Who are you without the game?

Who are you without the game?

Life beyond college athletics.

88
Ben Cohen '28 discusses the role of identity as a student-athlete. Photo by Kira Bretsky '27.

For most college athletes, the sport they play is not just a hobby; it is an identity. It shapes where they enroll in school and how they spend almost every hour of their day. Practices, lifts, games, travel and recovery fill their schedules. It is why they choose what school to attend and the reason why they sit through early morning classes, running off four hours of sleep. Even their social lives tend to revolve around spending time with their teammates  At schools that emphasize self-discovery, liberal arts colleges in particular, athletes often arrive already feeling like they know exactly who they are. They are a swimmer, a soccer player or a runner. But what happens when that identity suddenly disappears after graduation?

The question becomes unavoidable in senior year. Senior year celebrations are meant to honor athletes’ commitments and accomplishments, but they also quietly mark the end of someone’s athletic career. For many, it is the last time they will compete in an organized version of the sport that has defined them for years. Beneath the surface of celebration, there can be uncertainty, anxiety and even a sense of loss. 

According to the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA), there are over 555,000 student-athletes competing at the collegiate level. An extremely small percentage will go on to play professionally: fewer than two percent. This means that the vast majority will have to walk away from their sport after graduation. Unlike other activities that can continue casually after college, competitive athletics usually end abruptly before most athletes even get the chance to think about it. There is not much of a gradual transition, but rather a final game, final season and then it is over.  

Psychologists have come up with the term “athlete identity foreclosure” to describe when an individual’s sense of self is so strongly connected to being an athlete that losing that role creates a kind of identity crisis. Without the structure, recognition and purpose behind their everyday lives, athletes can feel lost. Research has shown that this can cause feelings of grief, anxiety and depression. To understand this idea more clearly, it makes sense to look at athletes in different stages of this transition. 

Some graduates may eventually find new identities and passions. They might get involved in careers, hobbies or social groups that help fill the gap left by sports. Over time, they begin to see themselves as more than just athletes. However, this process does not happen overnight and it often requires intentional effort to explore new interests and redefine personal goals. Others may struggle more with the transition. Without the built-in community of a team, they may feel isolated. Without the clear goals provided by competition, they may feel unmotivated so for these individuals, the loss of their athletic identity can linger longer and have a deeper emotional impact. 

At a liberal arts school in particular, this issue can be even more complex. Schools like Muhlenberg encourage students to explore different interests and develop a well-rounded sense of self. But for athletes, the demands of their sport can limit the time and energy they have to pursue other activities. As a result, this might raise the concern that they may graduate having invested heavily in one identity without fully exploring others. This is not to say that being deeply committed to a sport is a negative thing. Athletics teach discipline, resilience, teamwork and time management skills that are valuable in almost any area of life. The challenge arises when those skills are not able to be translated into new contexts after the sport ends.

Colleges could do more to support athletes during this transition. This might include career counseling specifically tailored to student-athletes, presentations on identity and personal development, or opportunities to explore interests outside of sports earlier in their college careers. By encouraging athletes to see themselves as more than just competitors, schools can help ease the shift away from athletics. 

Ultimately, the question “who are you without the game?” does not have a simple answer. In fact, for many athletes, the process of finding the answers to these questions can take time. It involves letting go of one identity while building another. It requires reflection, exploration and sometimes discomfort. But it can also be an opportunity. Without the structure of a sport, former athletes have the freedom to define themselves in new ways. They can take the qualities that they have developed through athletics and apply them to different areas of life. In doing so, they may discover that their identity was never just about the game; it was about the mindset and work ethic that the game helped shape.  

In the end, leaving a sport behind is not just an ending. It is also a beginning.

Ben Cohen
+ posts