We all came to campus this year, smacked in the face by an underwhelming construction site that will lead to a massive expansion of Seegers Union– an expensive project, as we’re all constantly reminded by administrative update emails. We also came to the campus of a College with declining enrollment, rising costs, disappearing federal government support for higher education, required leadership nowhere to be found, professors met with offers of severance packages and evaporating support for student activities … you get the idea.
So naturally, I began questioning the wisdom of so much focus being placed on a building project when other, more essential college priorities were being underfunded and unaddressed… then I remembered where I went to school, and all confusion disappeared as I remembered this is aggressively Muhlenberg College-esque behavior.
During my research for this piece, I discovered that the situation is much more complex than one might imagine, and while I have sympathy for those who must make decisions in these challenging times, that sympathy does not change my assessment or excuse what I view as the current administration’s poor decision-making. In my opinion, the financial and societal navigation supplied by our College’s administration in recent months has been embarrassing, unfortunate, and most importantly, delegitimizing for us as a College.
My first point is the matter of the Seegers Union expansion. It’s important to contextualize the expansion with the information that it is being paid for from a $7.5 million donation from Gerald and Cathleen Fahy. However, this has been split across two projects. Additionally, there is little clarity on the origin of the rest of the funds.
But, we know our tuition-based budgets (labs, professors, dining hall budget, etc) are NOT being cut due to the money being spent on the Seegers expansion, but rather due to tuition-centric and societal factors. Due to this reality of separate bank accounts, the action is not to call out the Seegers expansion as the issue, but rather to look at how the expansion seems in a time when the school is experiencing financial constriction in numerous other fields. I believe that it comes across like this– It (expansion) is the literal physical realization of an administration’s misguided priorities. Now, I’m not saying that the expansion from the start was an issue; the planning began years ago, far before any major financial issues were predictable. However, now, it stands as a witness to the capabilities of the administration, showcasing their current phase of poor decisions. While the benefits of the expansion are numerous, I’m sure, the physical reality that stands before the Muhlenberg community is that of an expansion, no more than a quarter city block in length, woefully behind schedule, generally disruptive and is in no way helping to solve the just as disruptive tuition-based cuts. See, the truth is, expansion or not, we’d be in this financial situation regardless, but the optics of a forward-looking expansion project, funded by a donated bank account, just do not look good at a time like this and the students, as well as the faculty, at this school deserve some level of acknowledgement of this reality.
Second, every day now we are noticing the effects of these cuts. Now, any one individual could walk into Generals Quarters (GQ) at around 10 a.m. most days, see that it has yet to open for the day, and think to themselves, “Wow, this school must hate making money!” and they’d be totally right! In the face of all our budget cuts, our General’s Quarters have cut hours of operation in the morning. Sodexo’s managerial staff likely viewed foot traffic data to determine what hours could easily be cut without losing large amounts of money, and that time is assumedly the morning. But for students and professors with 8, 9 and 10 a.m. classes, this is very inconvenient and not a great decision for campus quality of life.
Furthermore, administrative cost-cutting has led to severance packages being offered to countless staff members, with 17 of our professors accepting said package, even at a time when retention of a qualified college staff is paramount. At least two administrative assistants are now working in two separate departments simultaneously after coworker layoffs. Departmental budgets have been declining year after year for at least four consecutive years in some departments. Over the last five years, our school has outsourced two major expenses: all medical facilities and, most recently, the bookstore. Now again, this isn’t the fault of the expansion, but what are we supposed to think when there has been no reassurance and, frankly, little acknowledgement at all from administrators on our current position? Tuition-based budgets are complex and change annually, but knowing this, the administration should be far more prepared to handle times when finances are tight. What makes a school great is its facilities and capabilities, and if you have an underutilized shell of a school that cannot afford to sufficiently finance its programs, why attend?
The reasons Muhlenberg is finding itself in this situation are hilariously predictable and intricate, albeit not really difficult to understand. It’s due to one *major* thing I’ve previously mentioned: tuition-based budgets. Muhlenberg’s general finances are directly variable to class size, i.e, the smaller the class, then… the smaller the budget, cause… yeah, you get it… look at that degree at work. According to Muhlenberg’s public sourcebooks, the student body for 2022 was estimated at around 1,877, down from its behemoth of a peak at 2,206 in 2016. Furthermore, according to U.S. News, Muhlenberg’s 2024 class size had dropped further, down to 1,737, leading to even smaller budgets than before. Since our most recent peak in 2016, we have not had a year with a larger student body since the year prior. The result has been predominantly only budget cuts for departments and programs since the peak in 2016, accelerating after 2020.
Moreover, a truly concerning analysis of Muhlenberg College’s publicly available financial forms paints a grim picture. Muhlenberg’s poor oversight of finances has led to serious budgetary issues that have only compounded. Since 2016 (for all stats), Muhlenberg has had just 37% endowment growth against a 59% average. Our school has had -6%, -5%, -4% and -9% net income over the last four years against an ideal target of +1% per year. Simultaneously, net tuition revenue is -31% since 2016 against a national average of up -1.5%. Finally, Muhlenberg has yet to break its Sodexo contract, even though it is paying $8,579,000 that just four years ago was $4,835,000.
Additionally, it would hardly be fair or pass as real journalism without acknowledging legitimate macro-societal waves that are crashing against our favorite neoliberal ship. Muhlenberg, like every college in America, has been facing a general onslaught of shit in recent years that has had a heavy hand in all of our lives. Being forced to adapt to digital learning due to the pandemic at a time when the school was still financially better off, severely set back plans. As was the case with everyone, Muhlenberg had a difficult time. The challenges from the pandemic directly showed themselves through abnormally high financial strain being placed on small institutions like Muhlenberg, a cultural shift away from higher education stemming from increased lack of access and decreased affordability among colleges and swaths of professors retiring mid/post-pandemic. Immediately following the 2020-2021 school year, colleges had time for soft pandemic recovery and plans to move forward, while facing declining enrollment rates. Then, just three short years later, President Donald Trump got reelected on a platform of prosecuting and dismantling higher education for teaching “anti-American ideology.” And so here we are, private higher education versus the deteriorating and rampaging forty-seventh president backed by the Heritage Foundation. So maintaining a certain level of grace is… required.
These huge societal shifts are not something one lone institution can expect or be completely prepared for, but regardless, leadership is about how you lead through and adapt to things you didn’t prepare for.
Finally, the leadership provided by Muhlenberg College, in the context of addressing the challenges our College faces at this time, is abysmal at best, if calculable. This is an article primarily on Muhlenberg’s financial carelessness, but that is directly related to the navigation provided by the executives of this college. When you couple these looming financial uncertainties with the decision by the American Association of University Professors (AAUP) this past fall to place Muhlenberg College on a list of institutions that violate academic freedom rights, combined with the missing tenacity required to fight the Trump administration, I again state, I believe that this College’s current administration has outstayed its welcome. Just as is the case at all levels in American leadership today, now is not the time for complacency and capitulation; it is time for bold, decisive, quintessentially American action.
Photo by Kira Bretsky ’27.
Seth '28 is a Sustainability Studies and Business Administration major. He is part of the Muhlenberg Weekly, SGA, and Chapel Council. When he isn't writing, he is usually going for a walk, drawing, or doing work.



















