
For those who don’t know me, I am quite the fan of a popular TV show called “Survivor,” a franchise that has been streaming for over 26 years. The main idea of “Survivor,” for anyone who is uncultured, is that typically 16-24 players are competing on an island in Fiji for a chance to win a million dollars, and now in recent seasons, sometimes more than a million. What makes the show so fascinating is that these people are genuinely doing the best they can to survive in the “wild” while also competing against each other in either tribes or individual challenges to make it through something called tribal council, where each night someone new on the show is voted out of the competition by their fellow contestants. The show is full of drama, backstabbing, physical endurance and very interesting contestants– it’s simply amazing.
But let’s get into why I’m really here, which isn’t to convince you to watch “Survivor,” but to talk about one of my all time favorite seasons, which is season 17, “Survivor: Gabon– Earth’s Last Eden.” Gabon is one of my personal favorites because the cast is genuinely insane, with the most conflicting personalities and messy players bunched together that make every moment during the season captivating and jaw dropping.
Though there is one contestant in particular that I find to be a controversial favorite of mine, and that is Sugar. Throughout the season, Sugar is doubted, hated and talked down upon by many players, but somehow, and spoiler alert, she makes it to the final three players. When there are three players left, the winner is decided by the jury, which is made up of seven to eleven of the most recently voted off players, where at that final tribal council they get to ask the last three players why they deserve to win. Spoiler alert again, Sugar did not get enough votes to win, in fact, she didn’t get any votes at all, which uniquely makes her one of few contestants to make it to the end of a season without any votes casted against her during the games.
In my opinion, Sugar should have won. While the winner of this season is someone who played the game remarkably well and has a great personality, Sugar genuinely played the most compelling and interesting game out of the final three, which is why I think she deserved the win. Let’s get into the why, here.
For starters, early on in the game Sugar was banished to exile island, where she was given the choice to either hunt for a hidden immunity idol, or give up that incredible opportunity and stay the night in a shack full of fruit for her to eat. Sugar made the decision to hunt for the idol, and unlike Dan Kay, who was banished to exile island and could not find the idol, Sugar did find it, and she found it quite fast! She even managed to keep her idol a secret, and a record high of four more times she was sent to exile island because her cast mates thought she would be too dumb to find the idol, but she had already found it, so she got to stay in the fruit shack, on which she called the “Sugar Shack” and relax and fuel herself, because she had already uncovered the hidden immunity idol.
This wasn’t the only huge move made by Sugar that I think makes her qualify to be the winner of this season. She also led in blindsiding a close ally of hers that was manipulating her behind her back, Ace Gordan. Sugar ended up flipping on Gordan secretly, having him believe he was safe at tribal council, and helped get him out during that tribal. This wasn’t the only time Sugar flipped the votes, as she also blindsided players Crystal Cox and Ken Hoang after she heard they wanted to vote out a close ally of hers, Matty Whitmore, and instead joined players Bob Crowley and Susie Smith to help vote out Crystal. In that tribal her idol, which was still a secret, she gave to Whitmore just in case he needed it, as her idol expired that night.
That’s not all though! Sugar also ended up saving player Bob Crowley, who she viewed as a father figure, and ended up being the vote that forced Crowley and Whitman into a tie, where they had to make fire in order to decide who’d qualify for the final three. This move of hers is what helped guarantee her a spot in the final three.
My absolute favorite moment of Sugars though is when she worked with Crowley to make a fake immunity idol and gave it to Randy Bailey, who they had convinced should feel safe at tribal because he can and should play this fake immunity idol. Bailey, not knowing it was fake, played the idol and was successfully duped by Sugar and her alliance, who ended up casting enough votes to vote Bailey out of the game. Bailey was known to be a grumpy and mean contestant who most did not like, especially Sugar, and this moment was very gratifying for her, though some players disapproved of her blatant laughing when Bailey got out. Me personally, I thought it was peak cinema.
So you may be wondering, wow, why did Sugar not win when she made so many huge and impressive moves in the game? Well unfortunately in the final tribal council Sugar let her emotions get the best of her and she did not fight to state her case and instead was bitter and a bit mean in the answers she provided. It tanked her, unfortunately. But, I still think that diva deserved the win. She played an amazingly cunning game, despite her cast mates singling her out as a “dumb blonde” and if she had actually fought her case in the end, I do think she could have at least secured some of the votes, maybe even enough to win.
But alas! My queen lost, and she did appear again in “Survivor: Heroes Versus Villains” and was sadly the first person voted out. They don’t get my girl like I do. But when all is said and done, this woman accomplished what many “Survivor” fans dream of accomplishing on the show, and she deserved the win, despite what her outcome truly was.
Emily Nally ‘27 is an English and Creative Writing major with a Women and Gender Studies minor. She is editor of the Campus Voices section and is so excited to be a part of such an immersive organization on campus. Outside of the Weekly, you can find Emily rereading “Little Women,” binge watching “Gilmore Girls,” or being really cool practicing her flute and guitar.


















