Home News The origins of Muhlenberg fraternities

The origins of Muhlenberg fraternities

Looking at the past and present of Muhlenberg’s brotherhoods.

1713
Fraternities have been present on Muhlenberg's campus since 1881. standing Photo courtesy of Muhlenberg Trexler Library Archives.

Nearly four decades after Muhlenberg College first opened its red doors, Greek life began on campus. Founded in 1881, Alpha Tau Omega (ATO) was Muhlenberg’s first fraternity. Since 1924, the brotherhood has occupied ATO Hillcrest House. In 1998, the release of a documentary called “Frat House” would cause controversy, with the documentary makers filming at Muhlenberg’s chapter of ATO. Fraternity members featured in the documentary claimed that the footage was staged, while the directors maintained that what they had filmed was authentic. Due to this contention, HBO would never distribute the documentary. 

In 2000, ATO’s charter was revoked by the College due to hazing allegations, and after being reinstated in 2009, alcohol violations and more hazing allegations saw the chapter suspended again in 2019. ATO would return to campus shortly thereafter. 

President of ATO Gabriel Seinfeld ‘27 stated, “While the reinstatement of our chapter is before my time, I can speak to the kind of chapter we are today, the brotherhood we have built and where we are headed. My goal for ATO moving forward is to continue raising the bar in every area that matters: leadership, academics, brotherhood and the impact we have on campus. Our chapter is in a very strong place right now. We have built a culture centered on accountability, personal growth and genuine brotherhood, and that is reflected in the success of our members.” Along with this mindset being enmeshed in their undergraduate experiences, Seinfeld also emphasized how Greek life impacts brothers after graduation. “Our brothers continue to pursue impressive paths after graduation, including medical school, law school, military service, finance and other competitive fields. More than anything, I hope we continue to develop men of character who leave college more prepared, more confident and better equipped for life after graduation.”

As Muhlenberg’s first Jewish fraternity, the Alpha Nu chapter of Zeta Beta Tau (ZBT) was chartered in 1970 and remained a presence on campus until 1995 when allegations of drug use shut down the chapter. During this time, members lived in 2308 Chew Street which is currently located in the present-day Village parking lot. 2015 saw the chapter’s reactivation on campus, where they continue to be active today, living on Gordon Street, formerly a house for drama students. 

President of ZBT Zachary Kassebaum ‘26 highlighted ZBT’s work with the community, including their local partners like Gift of Life and Children’s Hospital of the Lehigh Valley. “Aside from the social aspect, ZBT has allowed me to get involved with community service opportunities to give back to the local Allentown community and philanthropy opportunities… Not only do fraternities provide community, but they also help you grow up with a strong understanding of giving back to the surrounding communities.” 

Alpha Epsilon Pi (AEPi) first joined Muhlenberg in November 1984. Two decades later, in 2004, they were suspended after claims of hazing, but sanctions were quickly lifted after an investigation was conducted. After being suspended again, the Alpha Beta chapter was chosen to rejoin Greek life in 2019 alongside Phi Kappa Tau. 

Current AEPi President Connor Michael ‘27 weighed in, “Despite my chapter’s suspension happening before my time at Muhlenberg, it is still an important part of history that I am unable to simply ignore. It has set a clear expectation for the kind of culture we need to build moving forward, and I hope that we are able to continue to learn from the past and create a chapter that reflects the best version of fraternity life. We are focusing on building a chapter that values genuine brotherhood over harmful traditions, and I do not want to be recognized for our past mistakes, but rather the positive impact that we are making on our members and the broader community.”

In 1998 Delta Tau Delta (DTD) received their charter and moved into substance-free housing alongside Phi Kappa Tau. They would later be suspended in 2002 after a hazing incident and a violation of the alcohol policy. After losing college recognition for one academic year, the chapter was reinstated in 2003 and remains active today. 

Current member and former president of DTD, Mason Tompkins ‘26 reflected, “The chapter was suspended in 2003, and in the time since then we have made a very serious effort to come back from that in the 23 years following. DTD now is an incredibly different organization than it was then and the reason for that change is because we make sure we treat our new members with respect and kindness. Our biggest hope for the chapter going forward is that we continue the change for the better and make our new members feel accepted and at home.” 

Intrafraternity Council (IFC) President Joshua Simon ‘27 shared, “At a school the size of Muhlenberg, fraternity life offers something that’s hard to find elsewhere– a tight-knit community where you’re genuinely known and supported. The brotherhood aspect is real: these are relationships that push you academically, hold you accountable personally and prepare you for life after college. We also see our chapters playing a real role in campus leadership– a lot of student government members, orientation leaders and club officers come from Greek life. And on the academic side, having a built-in network of older members who’ve taken your classes, who can mentor you through tough semesters, is something people underestimate until they experience it. Greek life at Muhlenberg, done right, is one of the most formative parts of the college experience.”

+ posts

Alexandra Downey ’27 is an English & Creative Writing and Media & Communication double major. She is incredibly excited to be Editor-in-Chief! She enjoys playing tennis, rereading everything on her bookshelf, and showing off pictures of her dogs.