Home Sports Swimming against the tide

Swimming against the tide

The presence of transgender athletes sparks debate over fairness in competition

2508

This article was last edited 4/24/2025 at 1 a.m. to update the piece with more inclusive language and remove its accompanying graphic that misrepresented the Muhlenberg community.

Lia Thomas, a transgender swimmer who competed for the University of Pennsylvania, has become a poster child in the ongoing debate over fairness in women’s sports. Her participation and victory in the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Women’s Swimming Championship in 2022 served as the catalyst for a national debate about equality in competition, biological differences and the participation of transgender athletes. These issues resonate with many students, particularly those involved in athletics or gender studies.

Since 2022, there have been at least ten collegiate cases reported of transgender women competing against biological women. Riley Gaines, a political figure known for her ties with Thomas at the NCAA championships, has since then “lobbied against the inclusion of trans women in the women’s division of sports.” Gaines claims that her goal is to defend Title IX and protect those assigned female at birth, while protestors believe her views are discriminatory and transphobic. 

In 2017, Muhlenberg hosted Susan Stryker for a conversation about gender identity and the unification of transgender individuals at Muhlenberg. In her speech, she questions the “nature of truth and reality across the vastness of gender identity.” To see just how impactful this topic is, we conducted a survey of several Muhlenberg students to see their thoughts on this topic. It was important for us to gauge the opinion of our student athletes to see how they generally sway on this issue. One of the more prominent conversations that this ongoing debate has led to is about student-athlete safety. At Muhlenberg College, we conducted a survey that was sent out to a group of Muhlenberg College athletes and non-athletes. Out of those 32 responses, 28 were athletes and four were non-athletes. 97 percent of the 32 respondents were more concerned about those assigned male at birth (AMAB) competing with female-identifying athletes when asked. Every athlete that responded, regardless of their gender, believed that there is a big advantage for those AMAB. “Men that have transitioned to become women will still have the bone structure, lung capacity and a higher level of testosterone,” says Zach Macey ‘28, a lacrosse player. He adds that this is true even after the transition.

“The biggest concern is [those AMAB] competing in women’s sports,” said Jennifer Ryan ‘27, a member of the Muhlenberg women’s volleyball team. “I think that [those AMAB] competing in women’s sports is probably the biggest issue because men have such a superiority over women when it comes to athletics.”

A BBC article was written in late Nov. 2024 talking about a transgender female athlete competing for the San Jose State University women’s volleyball team. In Oct., four teams forfeited games against San Jose State in a protest of the transgender athlete. One player from the University of Nevada-Reno volleyball team said she will not play “in any match that advances injustice against female athletes.” USA Volleyball says for transgender women, like the player from San Jose State University, testosterone levels “must not exceed the upper limit of the normal female reference range for their age group.”

“Male athletes tend to be stronger and faster due to their naturally higher testosterone levels, but male and female athletes tend to progress at around the same rate in terms of building speed and strength,” explains Garrett Thomas, a strength and conditioning coach at Muhlenberg. “It usually just depends on how good of a base they have in terms of experience.”

Thomas believes that while transgender athletes should be included in sports, the controversy surrounding their participation has been exaggerated. “I think it’s good for college athletics overall, sports should be a welcoming place for everyone. There are also only ten trans athletes in total throughout the NCAA, so I believe it’s a non-issue that’s been blown up into something much bigger than it ever should have been.” He also doesn’t think transgender women have a competitive advantage. “Hormone therapy affects testosterone levels enough to make it a more even playing field,” says Thomas. “Bone and muscular structure are already very similar between male and female athletes, so it’s essentially a non-factor.”

“I firmly believe the Trump administration is unfairly targeting trans athletes with executive orders.” – garrett THomas

Thomas expressed opposition to the Trump administration’s policies targeting transgender athletes. “I believe the current NCAA policies are fair. They are based on each sport’s individual federation, which varies within each sport. I firmly believe the Trump administration is unfairly targeting trans athletes with executive orders. There are only ten trans athletes in total in NCAA competition and only five trans athletes in high school across the country. It is a complete waste of time and resources targeting these fifteen athletes who are just trying to live life.”

Thomas also emphasized that the most misunderstood aspect of the debate is the small number of transgender athletes actually competing. “Most trans athletes wait until they are done playing to begin their transition because it’s a long process that makes permanent changes to their body.” He supports the current NCAA approach of deferring to international sports regulations, as they are developed by experts in each specific sport.

As discussions about transgender inclusion in sports continue, perspectives from both athletes and experts like Thomas highlight the complexity of the issue. While some argue that biological differences provide transgender women with an unfair advantage, others believe that existing policies ensure fairness while maintaining inclusivity. The debate remains a polarizing topic in the world of collegiate athletics, with ongoing discussions shaping the future of sports participation for transgender athletes.

Kelliann Keogh
+ posts
Olivia Maytin