Alumni Weekend started off with a bang at Scotty Wood Stadium. Coming off their bye week, the Muhlenberg football team took on the Ursinus College Bears in a wild and competitive contest that ended in Muhlenberg’s favor. The Mules came up with a 39-36 victory and now moves to a record of 4-0 on the season. Muhlenberg now stands as one of the only undefeated teams in the Centennial Conference, along with John Hopkins University.
The Mules got off to a slow start in the game, trailing 14-0 early in the second quarter. Matthew Manning ‘26 got the Mules on the board with a 14-yard touchdown run to cap off a seven-play drive for 68 yards. The Mules missed the ensuing extra point try and trailed 14-6 about six minutes into the quarter. On their next drive, Manning recorded his second touchdown of the game on a five-yard touchdown run. In order to try and tie the game, the Mules went for the two-point conversion but weren’t able to convert on the play. With just about thirty seconds left in the half, the Mules found the endzone again, courtesy of Aiden Mack ’26, who caught the three-yard touchdown pass to give Muhlenberg a 19-14 lead going into halftime.
With the performance, Manning became the first Muhlenberg player to rush for three touchdowns in a game since 2017.
On their first possession of the second half, Manning recorded his third rushing touchdown of the game, extending Muhlenberg’s lead to 25-14 after the failed point-after attempt. After Muhlenberg extended their lead, the Bears began to come back and dominated, scoring the next three touchdowns of the contest, opening up a 36-25 lead nearly midway into the fourth quarter. The Mules caught the deficit to five points, with Mahaffey connecting with Caleb Pasos ‘29 for a thirty-nine-yard touchdown. On the next play, Muhlenberg forced a three-and-out before Tommy Donnelly ‘27 returned the ensuing punt 20 yards into Ursinus territory. In their next possession, the offense stalled, turning the ball over on downs with just over three minutes left in the game. Only two plays later, the Mules recovered a fumble and went on to score a touchdown in their next possession, taking a 39-36 lead with just over a minute left in the game. With just under three seconds left, the Bears had the ball in the Mules field goal and were set up for a game-tying 38-yard field goal. Chris Holland ‘28 came up with the biggest play of the game, blocking the field goal to secure the Mules victory. This game marked the first time that the Mules have overcome a 14-point deficit to win against a Centennial Conference opponent since 2011, when they overcame a 26-7 deficit in the fourth quarter and came back to win by a score of 34-26.
Mahaffey played a strong game against Ursinus, rushing for 132 yards and throwing three touchdown passes in the contest. Manning was the other main star of the offense, with 96 total yards of offense and three rushing touchdowns. With the performance, Manning became the first Muhlenberg player to rush for three touchdowns in a game since 2017. On the defensive side of the ball, George Europe ‘26 and Peyton Elliott ‘26 lead the team in tackles. Justin Bernal ‘27 also played a strong game, with a blocked punt and a forced fumble in the contest.
Alumni Weekend brought a new sense of energy to Scotty Wood Stadium. Isaac Schaffer-Neitz ‘27 referenced this when discussing how alumni weekend had an impact on the team’s performance. “The alumni helped bring energy and gave the team a different kind of motivation for the game.” Although Holland’s blocked field goal was the biggest play of the game, there were still many other key plays that helped lead the Mules to a victory. When asked about one of the main turning points in the game, Schaffer-Neitz responded, saying, “George Europe’s forced fumble and our recovery was a big turning point for the momentum and the game.”
This game marked the first time that the Mules have overcome a 14-point deficit to win against a Centennial Conference opponent since 2011, when they overcame a 26-7 deficit in the fourth quarter and came back to win by a score of 34-26.
The Mules will look to stay undefeated as they continue their play against Centennial Conference opponents when they take on Franklin and Marshall College on Oct. 11 in Lancaster, Pa.
Photo by Sierra Addy ’27.
Marc '27 is a psychology major and political science minor at Muhlenberg. When not in the classroom he is normally watching sports, playing video games or watching his favorite show.



















