On June 23, the American Association of University Professors (AAUP) announced that they were adding Muhlenberg to their list of censured administrations. Muhlenberg is the most recent of 60 university administrations to be censured, with the decision coming after a vote on June 21 by the AAUP Council. This vote was based on the AAUP’s claim that Muhlenberg was not adhering to standards of academic freedom, supported by an AAUP report published in April that investigated the dismissal of Maura Finkelstein in January 2024.
In this report, the AAUP asserts that Finkelstein’s social media posts that were used as the basis for her dismissal should have been protected under the definition of extramural speech included in their 1940 Statement of Principles on Academic Freedom and Tenure. The statement defines, “When [college and university teachers] speak or write as citizens, they should be free from institutional censorship or discipline.” The AAUP also claims that without “the surveillance of Professor Finkelstein’s social media accounts” and “whipping up of student sentiment on this issue,” the resulting controversy and Finkelstein’s subsequent dismissal likely would not have occurred.
To address concerns regarding how academic freedom operates in college policy, Muhlenberg is reviewing the College’s current Equal Opportunity and Non-Discrimination (EO) Policy. This September, Provost Laura Furge shared in a letter to the editor published to The Weekly that she was working alongside the Faculty Personnel and Policies Committee (FPPC), director of equity and Title IX and college counsel to revise the College’s EO Policy that was designed and approved by faculty in November 2018. This process occurs every summer, in which the College’s EO and Title IX policies are reviewed to ensure they are compliant with federal, state and local laws.
Furge weighed in on this process, stating, “During both the Biden administration and Trump administrations there have been significant changes, particularly around Title IX.” She emphasized, “The members of FPPC were tremendous thought partners and contributors to the review– partnerships like these are essential. We value shared governance at Muhlenberg. Thus, any large-scale changes to our processes, other than those dictated by changes in federal, state [and] local law, involve not just elected faculty committees, but seek to invite faculty involvement more broadly, with the elected faculty committee presenting options for faculty to consider. For that reason, we will spend this academic year reviewing possible changes and seek faculty endorsement at a faculty meeting sometime in spring. Only the Board of Trustees has the authority to approve any final recommendations for changes which would then go into effect for the next academic year.”
Furge also noted that although revisions always occur annually, “there are indeed more changes to propose this year as we look with a new lens at what elected faculty designed and full faculty unanimously endorsed in 2018 and what AAUP has suggested for a long time (not new) for best practices.”
“These recommendations are meant to address concerns that the current process does not include a pre termination hearing or review before a panel of faculty colleagues.” – FPPC
Over the summer, the FPPC recommended changes that primarily focused on the Faculty Equal Opportunity Report and Resolution Procedures, which outlines the process for formal investigation and resolution. The committee stated, “FPPC seeks to better align this EO section with related policies in the Faculty Handbook, particularly regarding the stages at which faculty peers are involved. These recommendations are meant to address concerns that the current process does not include a pre termination hearing or review before a panel of faculty colleagues.”
While the faculty handbook states that the College adheres to the AAUP’s definition of Academic Freedom, the boundary between protected and unprotected speech often depends on context. According to the FPPC, “many faculty may also consider how these policies have been applied in the recent past. Given the events that took place at Muhlenberg last year, this may contribute to an even greater sense of uncertainty about where the boundaries lie.”
Muhlenberg’s chapter of the AAUP is currently not involved in the revision of the College’s EO policy, but their Steering Committee noted the impact the censure has had and will continue to have on Muhlenberg. “The implications may not be obvious to students, but we know that speakers have decided not to visit Muhlenberg because of the censure (or the situation that led to it). There are also significant concerns that people will not apply for faculty positions, which reduces the pool of talent for jobs here. And, though it is difficult to know to what degree, we think it likely that student applications have been impacted. Especially right now, applicants care about reputation. No matter how you state it, this is not good for the College’s reputation. We would be surprised if there was no impact on applications.”
“No matter how you state it, this is not good for the College’s reputation.” – The Muhlenberg chapter of the AAUP
However, President Kathleen Harring maintains that there has been no impact on faculty hiring and that the “volume and quality of applicants for all open positions at the College is consistent with past years, indicating that Muhlenberg remains a highly desirable place of employment.” To address the claim that speakers are refusing invitations to Muhlenberg due to the censure, Harring highlighted how the College has hosted more than 20 featured speakers this semester and elaborated that “[w]e are aware of one individual who decided not to accept an invitation to speak at the College owing to their disagreement on this subject.”
In the June 21 meeting where the national chapter of the AAUP voted to add Muhlenberg to the censure list, the AAUP Council also voted to remove the administration of Albertus Magnus College from censure. This was accomplished after the College incorporated a revised dismissal policy in their faculty handbook and the AAUP conducted faculty interviews. Albertus Magnus was added to the censure list in 2000, and the AAUP decided to revisit their status on the censure list in February 2025.
Harring shared, “It is critical to note that the AAUP is not a governing body, nor does it have any regulatory or legal authority. They are a professional association that advocates for faculty and recommends guidelines for faculty-related policy and practice. We value AAUP’s recommendations and always consider them in the context of our commitments to compliance with the law, the safety of our community and maintaining our accreditation as an institution of higher education.”
Although the AAUP acknowledged in their April report that Muhlenberg had reactivated a local chapter of the AAUP after Finkelstein’s dismissal, it is currently unknown when Muhlenberg will be taken off of the censure list and what specific steps must be taken in order to achieve this.
Alexandra Downey ’27 is an English & Creative Writing and Media & Communication double major. She is incredibly excited to be Editor-in-Chief! She enjoys playing tennis, rereading everything on her bookshelf, and showing off pictures of her dogs.



















