Home News Finkelstein update: reinstatement?

Finkelstein update: reinstatement?

3141
Muhlenberg's Anthropology Building on Chew Street. Photo by Kira Bretsky '27.
Muhlenberg's Anthropology Building on Chew Street. Photo by Kira Bretsky '27.

After months of deliberation, on Jan. 22 the College’s Faculty Personnel and Policies Committee (FPPC) issued their report regarding Maura Finkelstein’s, Ph.D. dismissal. The report concluded that the “administration failed to establish that Finkelstein acted with ‘such flagrant disregard of the policies or rules of the College, or the established customs of scholarly communities, as to render the individual unfit to continue as a member of the academic staff.’”

While the FPPC report is private, this information was obtained from a letter sent by the American Association of University Professors (AAUP) to President Kathleen Harring, Ph.D. The letter acknowledged that the FPPC’s investigation has been completed and they concluded that “‘the administration did not meet the burden of proof by a preponderance of the evidence that the actions of Dr. Finkelstein met the conditions for termination for cause.’ As a result, [the FPPC] unanimously recommended ‘reconsideration’ of Professor Finkelstein’s termination.”  

The AAUP urges the College to “rescind the dismissal notice and reinstate Professor Finkelstein to her academic responsibilities.” 

Although not confirmed by the College, Finkelstein was reportedly fired for pro-Palestine speech.

Finkelstein’s employment at the College has been a contentious issue for over a year. On Jan. 18, 2024, President Harring sent an email to the College community that they were investigating an Office of Civil Rights (OCR) complaint against Muhlenberg. On Jan. 24, 2024, Provost Laura Furge emailed students that Finkelstein was placed on leave. In late May, according to the AAUP, Finkelstein was informed that the College intended to terminate her for an Instagram post that allegedly “met the standard for online discrimination and harassment involving hateful speech.” The faculty handbook dictates that a professor can ask the FPPC to review their case. The FPPC may then make recommendations to the provost and president. On Aug. 27, 2024, the FPPC confirmed a request from Finkelstein to review her case and they began their review on Sept. 3. On Sept. 30, the OCR letter was made public, which outlined all of the complaints against the College and Finkelstein. 

“The AAUP urges the College to “rescind the dismissal notice and reinstate Professor Finkelstein to her academic responsibilities.””

Since then, there has not been an update on Finkelstein’s case until this semester with the release of this AAUP letter on Jan. 24. According to the handbook, the president must respond with their decision to the faculty member, which is Finkelstein in this case, within 21 business days of receipt of the FPPC’s findings. At the first faculty meeting of the semester, President Harring told the faculty that she had received the FPPC’s report for her consideration and would examine the case for a final determination. 

The Weekly will follow up when the College comes to a resolution of the Finkelstein case.

+ posts

Keanna Peña '25 is the Editor-in-Chief of the Muhlenberg Weekly. She is an English and Creative Writing major with a minor in Dance. She is passionate about informing the student body and sharing her creative writing.