Home Campus Voices A Letter From the Editor: On “Swimming Against the Tide”

A Letter From the Editor: On “Swimming Against the Tide”

5761

To the Muhlenberg Community,

Over the past several days, our newsroom has listened closely to the voices of students responding to our recent article, “Swimming Against the Tide.” The concerns raised – representation, ethical responsibility and statistical integrity – are real and important. We want to acknowledge those concerns directly, transparently and with care.

First and foremost, we recognize that aspects of the article, particularly the framing and wording around individuals who identify as transgender, have caused hurt. We also recognize the need and the corresponding lack of transgender voices within the article. We understand that publishing this piece at a time when the trans community is facing broader political attacks adds to their anxiety and we want to make it clear that we hear you. 

We also acknowledge the serious issues raised about the data presented. The survey cited in the article reflected responses from only 32 students, just four of whom were non-athletes – yet it was generalized to represent the views of 97 percent of “students at Muhlenberg.” That claim was misleading to add in an infographic meant to represent the article and did not meet the standards of accuracy and clarity that The Muhlenberg Weekly is committed to upholding. 

In response, we have removed the infographic accompanying the article on our website. This image was a flashpoint for misrepresentation, and its continued presence would only deepen the damage caused. Having also made several edits to the online edition to include more inclusive language, we have chosen to keep the article itself online, not to ignore or dismiss the critiques, but because we believe that removing the piece entirely would silence the many students who have used it as a springboard for meaningful and necessary dialogue.

Our mission is to be a platform for all voices in our community – even when those voices are in disagreement, even when that dialogue is difficult. We believe in accountability, not erasure. To that end, we are reposting the article on our social media with a new image and invite students to continue commenting, sharing their thoughts and expressing their perspectives. As we do with all of our articles, we also encourage you to write a response piece or a Letter to the Editor and will prioritize making space for those voices. 

This has been a learning moment for our newsroom. It has shown us that we must do better – especially when covering issues that affect historically marginalized communities. Moving forward, we are revisiting our editorial processes and engaging more intentionally with sensitivity when it comes to statistics and language.

Journalism is not just about telling stories – it’s about listening, learning and growing. We’re committed to doing all three as we move forward into the next semester.

Keanna Peña, editor-in-chief

+ posts

Keanna Peña '25 is the Editor-in-Chief of the Muhlenberg Weekly. She is an English and Creative Writing major with a minor in Dance. She is passionate about informing the student body and sharing her creative writing.