Home News Dozens exit faculty meeting, cite frustrations over tenure postponement

Dozens exit faculty meeting, cite frustrations over tenure postponement

The Muhlenberg chapter of AAUP staged a walkout, promising to boycott the next meeting if no board of trustees members attend.

5400
Photo by Esther Ojo ‘29.

After an unusual start to the Feb. 13 faculty meeting, with the President’s remarks moved to the end of the agenda, roughly 30 minutes into the meeting, Associate Professor of Psychology Connie Wofle asked to be recognized from Zoom. However, no one in the room was able to hear her. As Provost Laura Furge attempted to fix the audio, the Zoom screen displayed a graphic that read “austerity is not a plan,” with the American Association of University Professors (AAUP) logo underneath. Flyers with this graphic were also being passed around the room before the meeting began.

With the audio issues unresolved, Associate Professor of Political Science Ross Dardani rose in Wolfe’s place, to read a statement on behalf of Muhlenberg’s chapter of the AAUP, citing the lack of fairness surrounding the Board of Trustees’ decision to postpone the tenure decisions of four professors, which they said was “unconscionable, unfair to these individuals and erodes trust.” 

“Our chapter of AAUP made a simple request– that a member of the Board be present today to explain this unprecedented action. As there is no Board representative present, and in the spirit of standing in solidarity with our colleagues, we cannot and will not continue to be present at this meeting,” Dardani read from a statement. “We will boycott the next faculty meeting as well if the Board does not either attend that meeting or rectify the problem and vote on the four cases.” Many of the present faculty exited the room, with more virtual attendees logging off of the Zoom meeting. No member of the Board of Trustees was in attendance, which President Kathleen Harring later stated was due to a family emergency.

On Thursday, Feb. 5, the Board of Trustees’ Education Policies and Faculty Affairs Committee notified Harring and Furge of their decision to hold off on awarding tenure to four members of the Muhlenberg faculty, which would then be shared with the full Board on Saturday, Feb. 7. “The faculty candidates, their department chairs, the Faculty Evaluation Committee as well as the full faculty were notified of the tenure postponement as soon as possible after the decision was finalized on Saturday,” Harring explained to The Weekly. 

Being awarded tenure is a six-year holistic process. Those who receive tenure are granted job security, and the College is able to ensure that faculty members will continue their professorship at Muhlenberg. “Tenure is very meaningful for the College, for departments and for individuals because we all work so hard for it. The way it happened last Saturday was shocking because it didn’t happen. When you don’t get tenure, you lose your job. So putting it off indefinitely… puts the tenure candidates in a particularly precarious position,” reflected Professor of History Cathy Ouellette. Those faculty members in limbo “both don’t know if they’ll have a job, and it’s too late to go on the market this year for a job that starts in the fall.” 

The faculty meeting was unable to continue because they could not reach the 78-person quorum, but Harring and Furge remained to address those who stayed after the adjournment. 

After the faculty walkout, Harring stated that she was “prepared to provide more information and clarity” on the tenure postponement, acknowledging that she had personally contacted all four of the faculty members. “I know how extremely upsetting this news is to our candidates and to each and every member of the faculty. [Furge] and I were also surprised… and shared our concerns about the impact of this decision with the Committee and the Board.” Harring also confirmed that there have been no discussions with the Board about eliminating tenure from the College, and that all proceedings of this process followed the faculty handbook. She concluded, assuring that she is “working promptly” to meet with the Board to voice recommendations and work toward completing the tenure process by early April.

Associate Professor of Public Health Kathleen Bachynski, who received tenure last year, shared after the meeting, “I know firsthand how much is involved in this rigorous process, and what an important day it is in an academic’s career. I was shocked and sick at heart to learn that four of my colleagues who did everything asked of them, and who should have been celebrating their achievement, are now in an indefinite limbo without any clear explanation as to why.”

Ouellette was part of the group who left the meeting, which was “a personal decision because someone in my department was affected. Although there’s legally nothing wrong with what the Board did according to the faculty handbook, what it does is break the spirit of the system and of the individuals specifically affected by that lack of communication and lack of certainty of their academic futures at the College.”

The remaining faculty stayed for over an hour to voice concerns and seek information from the senior staff about both the recent tenure decision, and what it might signal for the College.

Much of the conversation about the tenure decision went beyond the postponement, and toward a concern over the president’s alleged blindsiding by the Board. “Who is holding the Board accountable?” asked Lecturer of Dance Robyn Watson. Professor of Political Science Lanethea Mathews-Schultz held a similar sentiment earlier in the meeting when asking, “Where’s our liaison to the Board?,” relating back to Harring’s alleged surprise at the decision, while serving as that liaison. Mathews-Schultz added that two different groups of faculty have sent letters to the Board without response. 

Lynda Yankaskas, associate professor of history, also raised concern over the communication between the president and the Board that would lead to her surprise at this decision. “We can’t do any planning because we don’t know who our colleagues will be.” She conceded that while she believes Harring understands the weight of this situation, a comment most other speakers shared, she questioned whether the Board fully understood the implications of the postponement.

“I’m horrified at the idea that our Board could totally surprise our president and provost about something,” said Professor of Biology Erika Iyengar, voicing a confusion regarding how to speak honestly with colleagues or prospective students about whether they should work at or attend the College. “Professor morale has tanked.” Harring thanked Iyengar for her perspective, with no additional comments. 

“I often go to lunch with candidates for jobs,” said Brett Fadem, professor of physics. “I don’t know what to say to them at this point, and don’t know how to interact with students… I’m concerned about how to present the College in a positive way when everything is insecure.” Harring stated that she is committed to speaking openly and honestly with candidates.

Francesca Coppa, professor of English and film studies, said that some of the recent changes at the College, “seem to be at break-neck, reckless, potentially arrogant speeds… I’m all about moving fast, but this is too fast and there’s too much pressure to do the consensus building… I want us to make good decisions.” 

Muhlenberg’s AAUP chapter said in a statement after the meeting, “This tenure delay also speaks to the broader frustrations many faculty have felt regarding the lack of transparency when it comes to decisions that directly impact our work here at the College. Muhlenberg AAUP was re-activated for moments like these to give faculty the space to work together to advocate for each other, which is why AAUP walked out of last week’s faculty meeting. As the College navigates an uncertain future, we seek more transparency and clear communication regarding the major decisions that impact our future.”

+ posts

Harry Glicklin ‘26 is a media & communication and English double major who is absolutely jazzed to be a managing editor for The Muhlenberg Weekly. Outside of the office, Harry is a member of the Muhlenberg AcaFellas, the WMUH Allentown radio station, Hillel, a campus tour guide and writing tutor.