On Sept. 24, just states away in the artistic epicenter, New York City (NYC), The Tank Theater opened its curtains for what once was a Muhlenberg College student-written and performed play, “-in-chief.” The show, written by Ally Duvak ‘22, made its initial debut in the spring semester of 2024 as a part of the Theater and Dance Department’s “‘Berg New Works” (BNW) initiative. Now, what started in the Studio Theater has taken on a life of its own beyond Muhlenberg’s campus.
BNW featured the writing of several students, including full length productions like “-in-chief,” as well as some staged readings towards the end of the semester. The idea was to help students with the typical development process of early drafts of their very own plays in a more obliging environment with the guidance of Theater and Dance faculty and staff. “In most professional settings, new plays get a 29-hour workshop period before a staged reading or performance. I’m not sure exactly how many hours I got to spend with ‘-in-chief’ before it was performed at Muhlenberg in February 2024, but it was certainly more than 29,” says Duvak. “This generous amount of time let me experiment hugely with the script and land on a version of which I could be proud.”
The program further aimed to mold and shape the piece across its various aspects: an experience for writers, actors, directors and crew members alike. Dan Harel ‘26, an original leading player in the piece, comments, “Being able to shape the character with my own personality is a mark that I get to leave on the play forever and I’m proud of the way it has developed over the years.” The show featured several student actors and crew members like Harel, granting them the opportunity to explore the realm of fresh storytelling and to spectate what may be down the road for them as they pursue careers in the arts.
After the workshopping stages of BNW and gauging audience reception, it was clear to those involved that the piece had the potential to continue down a path towards further theatrical success.
The journey from Allentown to Manhattan did not occur by happenstance. After the workshopping stages of BNW and guaging audience reception, it was clear to those involved that the piece had the potential to continue towards further theatrical success. “I hope the play goes to the top,” says actor Shay Seymour ‘27. “In our fractured nation we need a beacon of hope and the arts have always been that, and so I hope that someone out there in the big world of Broadway can see this spark of truth and kindle it into a flame that will warm us with its beautiful and powerful message.”
According to Duvak, “The Tank is constantly taking submissions via email. After seeing some of their programming in summer 2024, I submitted the latest draft of ‘-in-chief’ to their team followed up this past spring with the opportunity to put the play on stage in September. They are open to presenting any and all kinds of art, not just theatre, and do not charge you to use their space. If you’re reading this, you should submit to The Tank!” After getting picked up by The Tank, Duvak self-produced the production with a new cast and crew.
The experience was new and exciting territory for both the words on the page and Duvak. “Frankly, I think I’m still waiting for it to fully hit me. Self-producing is a whirlwind! But I was so honored by how many people showed up for ‘-in-chief,’ and in so many ways: donating, attending online or making it to the city to see it in person.” She continues, “This was also my first time hearing the play during this presidency and it felt dramatically different than in March 2024. I learned a lot about what it means to make theatre that speaks to both the past and the present and am trying to make this play as prescient as possible before it reaches its final draft.”
Directed by Cecilia Bracey and assistant directed by alum Anna Item ‘25, who also worked as an associate director on the original production, the current draft ran for four days at The Tank, but not without its challenges, “I really tried to abandon my perceptions of the play’s staging and specific line readings so that I could create space for the new cast to really play and make their characters their own,” Item describes. “Given how developmental the ‘Berg New Works process was and how much backstory was created by the Muhlenberg cast, that was sometimes difficult, but when the actors in the NYC production would ask me about how an actor delivered a line in the last production, I never answered them!” Also present were new logistics to contend with such as budgeting, time and access to rehearsal spaces.
The play underwent significant development from draft to draft, having adjusted and fine tuned some character dynamics and casting choices, while also updating some of the relevant political headlines and events that are projected onto the stage to further resonate with current audiences. According to Item, “Ally experimented with a lot of changes in this new version of the script that upped the stakes and pondered different casting dynamics. With a more diverse actor pool in NYC than at Muhlenberg, we were able to consider identity a lot more in casting and the writing of the play itself. I thought it made the play that much richer to represent the experiences of college students who are dealing with racist microaggressions at school, even from liberal white classmates, while a proud racist is being voted into office.”
Item describes the play as a period piece, something she finds unique about the show due to how recently these events occurred. Nonetheless, there is something to be said about the retention of its relevancy and how that has affected the play’s development.
“In ‘-in-chief,’ the editor-in-chief of a college newspaper manages a divisive Pennsylvania swing county newsroom as the impending 2016 presidential election looms over the United States. While all eyes are on the national stage, the editor-in-chief finds herself grappling with cataclysmic events much closer to home,” summarizes Duvak.
The story has since grown in tandem with the tension of America’s political climate. Item continues, “This play hits so much harder as an audience living during the second term of Trump’s presidency. The play was originally performed during the Biden administration, and at the time we hoped that the way the play dissects the relationship between the political and the personal would maybe sway some audience members to reconsider how they’d vote in the then-upcoming 2024 election.” She is excited to revisit the play across decades, as both politics and performance continue to evolve since each draft of the play was created.
According to Duvak, the BNW process was crucial to kickstart this evolution, and the burgeoning to come. “It was not just the ample amount of time that helped with this: I was, and still am, deeply grateful for the flexibility and talent of the generous cast and crew who took the ideas I tossed into the rehearsal room and ran with them. The ‘Berg New Works team left an indelible mark on this script.”
Seymour affirms, reflecting on BNW as a whole and what they hope to see in the future for campus playwrights like Duvak. “I believe to make this [BNW], better the department needs to give it more love and care because right now it seems like an afterthought… it takes a village, and we need to stop ignoring the homegrown art that we have right here in our backyard in favor of big budget musicals that cost us an arm and a leg to do.” While they highly value their experience as part of the process, akin to the scripts at hand, there is always room to learn and grow.
Still, Gabriel Jason Dean, assistant professor of english literatures & writing and theatre, informs The Weekly, “I, along with my colleagues, am committed to making sure that student playwriting is part of the theater and dance culture. Muhlenberg is one of the only schools of our size that supports student playwriting in this scaffolded, thoughtful and consistent way. Most creative writing programs, if they exist at our sister schools, do not have a playwright on faculty. BNW is a very unique and wonderful thing…” BNW productions will continue to happen every three years. This year, BNW is partnering with the Center for Ethics to create a community-wide 24 hour play festival with guest playwright and Muhlenberg alum Avery Deutsch.
“I’m not exaggerating when I say this experience changed my life. I knew what it meant to write but not what it was to be a playwright in a development space and I learned so much from that process, even though my formal education at Muhlenberg had ended more than a year before -in-chief began.” – Ally Duvak, Muhlenberg Alumni, playwright of -in-chief
On her experience with BNW, Duvak says, “I’m not exaggerating when I say this experience changed my life. I knew what it meant to write but not what it was to be a playwright in a development space and I learned so much from that process, even though my formal education at Muhlenberg had ended more than a year before ‘-in-chief’ began. I’m excited to see the future of this program and admire that it meets plays at multiple stages of development: from workshopping, to staged readings, to a full staging. I think this is crucial for student writers and puts Muhlenberg theatre and dance on a strong path to being at the forefront of generative academic spaces producing new work.”
Duvak encourages other young writers to follow a similar progression for their early drafts, both in and outside of BNW and the opportunities granted by the theater and dance department or the MTA. “I would advise student playwrights to try and hear their work out loud as much as possible,” she says “This doesn’t have to be in a formal reading setting: bribe your theatre-adjacent friends with some snacks, have them come to your dorm and sit and read your current draft aloud. Nothing helps more than hearing which lines get reactions, where your readers or audience seem confused and who or what they want to learn more about.”
As for what’s next, Duvak is pursuing a Master of Arts in Theatre and Non-Profit Administration at Villanova University. The writer says, “These days I read a lot of plays, send a lot of emails and drink a lot of caffeine. If all goes to plan, I should complete my degree in May 2027.” As for the play itself, the journey is far from over. “My lips are sealed for now…” she says, “but I can promise that you have not seen the last of ‘-in-chief!’ To keep up with the play, please follow us at @inchiefplay on Instagram.”
Photographs by Kira Bretsky ’27, Coltrane Cho and courtesy of The Tank.
Note: A correction has been made to note that BNW is still an ongoing project, and is being supported in the Theater & Dance Department.
Megan ‘26 is a Theater Studies and English Literature double major with a minor in Film Studies. She is extremely grateful to have worked with the talented and passionate students on the Weekly staff since her first year. When she isn’t working in the production room, you can find her directing shows on campus, writing sketch comedy, leading the Muhlenberg Film Association, or enjoying a night with her friends.





















