Home Campus Voices Across the Aisle: The War in Iran

Across the Aisle: The War in Iran

As conflict in the Middle East has grown in recent months, Muhlenberg political organizations take a closer look at some of the effects of the war in Iran.

336

When the United States and Israel struck Iran on Feb. 28, the attack came after years of increasing tension over Iran’s nuclear program, including the 2018 U.S. withdrawal from the 2015 nuclear deal and a brief Israel-Iran war in June 2025. The strikes killed Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, and by March 4 Iranian forces had declared the Strait of Hormuz closed. About a fifth of the world’s oil supply normally passes through that waterway, and the International Energy Agency has called the resulting shortfall the largest oil supply disruption on record. Brent Crude, the global benchmark, jumped from about $72 a barrel just before the war to nearly $120 at its peak. 

A ceasefire was announced on April 8, but ship traffic stayed far below prewar levels. Crude exports returned to roughly prewar levels in September, before attacks on shipping surged again this month and pushed Brent back up to around $110. The effects have reached American households: gasoline averages about $4.34 a gallon, and Moody’s estimates the war has cost the typical family roughly $2,000. As these costs mount, we asked three campus clubs to weigh in on diplomacy, America’s global role and the balance between strategic alliances and human rights. 

Diplomacy: Looking back at the Obama-era Iran nuclear deal, was withdrawing from the agreement the right decision? What should the United States have done differently? 

Muhlenberg College Democrats: 

Under the Obama-era nuclear deal, there were strong safeguards against Iran’s development of a nuclear weapon, including blocking highly enriched uranium and plutonium which are necessary components to the creation of a nuclear bomb. This deal was effective in protecting the international community, therefore we should not have pulled out. Since pulling out of the deal, Iran has had rapid advancements towards a nuclear weapon that would have been impossible under the strict scrutiny of the deal. We either should have stayed in the original deal or taken more serious diplomatic measures towards a new deal before hastily escalating into a war which has virtually no capacity to fully wipe out the nuclear weapon program in Iran and has put us in a position in which we are unable to check Iran’s nuclear progress. 

Muhlenberg Young Democratic Socialists of America:

The United States’ withdrawal from the 2015 Iran Nuclear Deal was a mistake. The deal would have made it harder for Iran to build up its nuclear program, requiring at least one year, which would give countries more time to respond. DSA calls for an end to American imperialism in West Asia and the restoration of diplomacy in Iran, which starts by rejoining. Since 2019, it has been accelerating the development of its nuclear program to an alarming level. This is largely due to escalating tensions between the U.S. and Iran, which started with the United States’ role in the 1953 coup ousting Prime Minister Mossadegh and currently with the ever-increasing imposition of sanctions against Iran. A willingness to negotiate in good faith whilst recognizing the sovereignty of the Iranian people is crucial to improving U.S.-Iranian relations.

Muhlenberg College Republicans:

It is debatable whether or not withdrawing was the right idea. The agreement had many valid limitations such as not adequately preventing Iran from developing nuclear weapons, failure to address Iran’s ballistic missile program and limitations on immediate access to suspected nuclear sites. Any agreement needs to have strong, enforceable measures. The Iran nuclear deal had extremely narrow measures. As president Reagan famously said, “Trust, but verify.” The  United States should have sought out a stronger, more comprehensive deal with less limitations. It would be worthwhile to re-negotiate a stronger agreement, so long as enforcement is met.

America’s global role: Should the United States serve as the global enforcer of the rules-based international order, from protecting freedom of navigation to upholding international treaties, even at the risk of deeper military involvement? Or should that burden be shared, or left to others?

Muhlenberg College Democrats: 

America does have an important role as a global enforcer. Our participation in the Obama-era nuclear deal was an effective way of upholding this international order. Throughout history, the most effective way this order has been upheld by the U.S. is through diplomacy, such as the Iran deal. When the military has gotten involved it has usually led to a larger disruption of international order, as we see here with the disputes over the Strait of Hormuz, as well as incurring great costs of lives, as we saw with the Feb. 28 bombing of a school building which killed over 100 children. In this case, military involvement is proving to be much more costly than the deal which was initially in place. 

Muhlenberg Young Democratic Socialists of America:

Stepping back from the “global enforcer” role is essential to dismantling the U.S. empire, which has caused excessive destruction and suffering abroad, but also to veterans at home, who historically have not received the care they deserve. The U.S. needs to prioritize diplomacy in enforcing international treaties. U.S. strikes in Iran have had devastating impacts on civilians, culminating in the killing of at least 1,469 Iranians between February and July of this year. The escalation of conflict in Iran only further sours relations and harms civilians, both of which will not make Iran any more willing to come to the table and make a deal. Domestically, current U.S. strategy in Iran costs the average American household almost $2,000, with surging energy costs causing a sharp increase in inflation and price of everyday goods.

Muhlenberg College Republicans:

The number one priority should be protecting American citizens wherever they are in the world. The United States certainly should have a role in maintaining national security, but it should exhaust all diplomatic opportunities before using military force.

There is real division within the Republican party on Reagan’s well-known “Peace through strength” phrase, particularly regarding the war in Iran. Some Republicans support prolonged military involvement, while others are concerned about the long-term costs.

It ought to be an international effort to maintain international ocean commerce. The United States should work with other nations who have similar interests to work together in upholding and protecting freedom of navigation.

Alliances vs. values: How should the United States balance strategic interests with human-rights concerns when providing military, economic or diplomatic support to allies?

Muhlenberg College Democrats: 

In this scenario, attacking Iran was not beneficial to us or our allies. It has led to domestic hardship such as the rising price of fuel and the loss of 21 American lives according to the Pentagon, though The Washington Post reported at least 22. The United States should not be persuaded into military action by its allies if this decision is not in the best interest of everyone. Using violent escalation instead of continuing effective diplomatic efforts has led us to violate human rights of those living in Iran. Since the start of the war, there have been more than 1,700 reported civilian deaths in Iran. Additionally, we endanger our allies in the region by provoking Iran and hurt our allies all over the world by causing trade interruption and endangering the fragile nuclear peace through the United States’ rash decisions and weak strategy. 

Muhlenberg Young Democratic Socialists of America:

The U.S. should back out of providing economic and military support that will escalate regional conflicts. There should be a greater focus on solidarity with the working class transnationally, who bear the brunt of the destructive consequences of military conflicts. Economic and strategic goals should never take precedence over the protection of the human right to live long, healthy lives away from destruction and suffering. The U.S. must consider the impact on innocent civilians when deciding who and how to provide aid to avoid further fueling the military-industrial complex.

Muhlenberg College Republicans:

The U.S. should prioritize national security while encouraging allies to respect human rights. From a republican perspective, American support for allies should be based on whether or not it advances U.S. interests. However, this support should not be unlimited. When an ally engages in human rights abuses, the U.S. should consider limiting assistance in order to prioritize human-rights concerns.

In April 2026, the Senate rejected two resolutions that would have blocked approximately $450 million in proposed weapons sales to Israel. Republican senators voted against the resolutions, reflecting support for continued military cooperation with a strategic U.S. ally. The Republican Party is known for continuing to support military cooperation with its allies, however they should consider restrictions when there is credible evidence when U.S. assistance contributes to human rights abuses.

+ posts

Kabir Burman '27 is an international student from India double majoring in media & communication and political science. He is constantly looking for new ways to bring you the stories that matter and feature different perspectives. If you can't find him in the newsroom, you'll find him playing the piano, taking a nap, or planning his next trip to NYC!

Previous articleLanyard
Next articlePhoebe Bridgers’ phone-free concert
Kabir Burman
Kabir Burman '27 is an international student from India double majoring in media & communication and political science. He is constantly looking for new ways to bring you the stories that matter and feature different perspectives. If you can't find him in the newsroom, you'll find him playing the piano, taking a nap, or planning his next trip to NYC!