Home Campus Voices Letter to the Editor

Letter to the Editor

1174

Dear College Campus Community, 

We, members of the Muhlenberg chapter of the American Association of University Professors (AAUP), care deeply about the educational mission of the College and the learning conditions of our students. We also know that faculty working conditions impact student learning conditions.

Recently, the Board of Trustees made an unprecedented decision that has harmed working conditions at the College. On Feb. 7, four professors were waiting by the phone to learn if they would celebrate earning tenure, a singular milestone in their academic career, or lose their jobs. Board members instead postponed voting on the tenure application of our colleagues, providing no clear rationale for this delay nor a concrete timeline for a future vote. Our colleagues were pushed into indefinite professional limbo.

The news of this decision shocked faculty members given the importance of tenure in academic careers. The tenure process is also central for maintaining standards of excellence at the College. As all professors do when applying for tenure, these four professors had completed a multi-year application process. They submitted hundreds of pages of documentation speaking to their work in teaching, scholarship and service to the College and they were evaluated by colleagues.

On Feb. 12, the AAUP chapter made a simple request. We sent a letter to the President, Provost, the Interim CFO and Board members requesting the presence of the CFO and a Board member at the Feb. 13 faculty meeting to explain this decision. We communicated that if this request was not met, we would walk out of the faculty meeting. We received no response from the Board and neither a Board member nor the CFO attended the faculty meeting, so we walked out. Numerous faculty members who are not members of the AAUP joined us, speaking to the broad concern for this issue. The meeting officially ended because there were no longer enough faculty members present to conduct business.

We call for an immediate vote on the four tenure cases by Monday, March 16. We also call for a Board member to join the next scheduled faculty meeting, either in person or by Zoom, on Friday, March 20 to discuss their recent decision. If not, we will boycott the next faculty meeting, thus halting important discussion, planning and voting on issues related to curriculum, campus policies and the future of the College. We are eager to continue with this work, but cannot proceed until our colleagues’ tenure cases are resolved.

Given the complex challenges facing many small liberal arts colleges and higher education across the country, we find it very unfortunate that our attention must now be focused on this issue rather than these other pressing issues. Creating a crisis of faculty working conditions at this critical time for the College was completely avoidable and unnecessary. And faculty working conditions are student learning conditions. Once these issues are resolved, we look forward to focusing our energies on addressing immediate challenges and realizing the educational mission of the College.

–Muhlenberg AAUP

+ posts

It is the policy of The Muhlenberg Weekly to foster relationships with its readership, including through discourse in its Opinion/Editorial section. Therefore, members of the College Community are encouraged to submit Letters to the Editor on any topic of interest to Muhlenberg, in direct reference to an article or otherwise.