To whom it may concern,
Through her article this past week, “A Conservative Response to ICE,” Vice President of Muhlenberg College Republicans Jenny Ryan makes an unwitting argument that highlights the growing divide within MAGA between constitution-abiding Republicans with a conscience and drone-like blind loyalists.
Ryan frames her article, and thereby the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) operations she is writing about, as a “left vs. right” issue, traditionally along party lines. This framing sets President Donald Trump and Republicans en masse as those who support these operations, and assumes those who don’t are Democrats. Ryan communicates to her reader that her fundamental understanding of the matter is misplaced, just as poorly as the article’s source citation.
Though it isn’t the global reaching (Sinclair owned local news station) “Komo News” that Ryan cites, the latest NPR/PBS News/Marist poll Immigration and Customs Enforcement states that now “65% of Americans” believe that ICE has “gone too far” in their operations.
Furthermore, Ryan reinforces her one-sided narrative by framing the protests taking place, protected by the First Amendment, as inherent causes for violence against ICE agents, and as the reason ICE has gotten violent. However, the same NPR poll states that “When it comes to mass protests against ICE, by a 59%-to-40% margin, more said demonstrations are legitimate as opposed to people acting unlawfully.” The insinuation the protests are causing violence? “60% of Americans believe ICE uses excessive force” and do not think ICE should have “absolute immunity.”
I believe that Ryan’s politics again blocks her from seeing the truth when she suggests that we were not this angry when President Barack Obama deported “three million people,” and therefore we are just being hypocrites. But, if those who hold this belief followed the news their whole lives, and not only when Donald Trump tells them they can, they would remember that there were vast protests to President Obama’s deportation policy, and their lack of follow through with judges.
To me, it is clear that Jenny thought referencing Obama’s deportation policy would be a “gotcha” moment, proving our political hypocrisy. She did, however, forget that we, the majority, see this not as an issue of politics, but as an issue of basic human rights.
Additionally, all those deportations Obama carried out, no matter how just or unjust they were, were completed without the summary execution of American citizens.
Though Ryan may believe that “blocking roads” and “name calling and unprofessional language” escalates violence and starts this violence with ICE, I’d be more willing to bet it’s the tear gassing of children, open executions of American citizens and usage of military technology to track and identify Americans.
The arguments used in her article are loud mischaracterizations and misunderstandings of the founders’ vision for our society, the articles failure to present America’s storied history truthfully–as a nation of immigrants– and its open embrace and defence of an oligarchical fascist government is woefully shameful and boorish in nature.
Finally, in her opening paragraphs, Ryan states former President Joe Biden failed his oath to the Constitution and states that, “Faithfully executing existing law is something the president and administration officials swear on the Bible to do.” Elected officials taking their oaths seriously is something Ryan and I agree on, especially when those oaths are sworn in on holy texts. In which case I would like to remind you all that “Trump did not put his hand on the Bible at inauguration.”
- Seth Buckwalter
It is the policy of The Muhlenberg Weekly to foster relationships with its readership, including through discourse in its Opinion/Editorial section. Therefore, members of the College Community are encouraged to submit Letters to the Editor on any topic of interest to Muhlenberg, in direct reference to an article or otherwise.


















