Home Arts & Culture A play for Everybody

A play for Everybody

Muhlenberg brings death to life in the Studio Theater.

535
Muhlenberg Theatre and Dance presented "Everybody" this past weekend. Photo courtesy of Ian Graybill ‘26.

The precise moment “Everybody” began was delightfully unclear. Was it when the lights dimmed and focused on Dominick Borgess ‘27 as Usher/God as they launched into an irreverent and informative curtain speech? Was it when the five Somebodies alternating through the role of Everybody made their way into the audience? Maybe it was as soon as viewers stepped out of the Trexler Pavilion and into the “everywhere and nowhere of the epic southwestern desert,” as written in the director’s note? Or even with the play’s supposed origin in fifteenth-century England? Regardless, it started with and sustained an impressive balance of comedy and heart in the face of existentialism.

Written by recent Pulitzer-winning playwright Branden Jacobs-Jenkins and directed by Professor of Theatre and Dance Leslie Hill with Assistant Director Ian Graybill ‘26, “Everybody” tells the story of Everybody, a human representation of anyone and everyone as they meet and grapple with Death. As Everybody prepares to present their life before God, Everybody meets other manifestations of concepts in Friendship, Cousin, Kinship, Stuff and Love and pleads with them to help them on their journey. What makes the show especially interesting is its quintuple casting– with its five lead actors, or Somebodies, receiving rotating roles every night through a lottery system. This meant memorizing over 60 pages worth of all sides of conversations, amounting to 120 possible performance combinations!

Reflecting on this seemingly Sisyphean task, Somebody actor Hannah Scarlatoiu ‘26 said, “Doing a role like this was everything I could’ve asked for. It was definitely a huge challenge and a lot crazier than I ever expected, but it pushed me to be less perfectionistic when it comes to my acting. I had to trust myself, but also felt so much comfort in sharing roles with four other actors. If things ever went ‘wrong,’ we would always be able to support one another. Overall, this process was a dream to have. I got to be weird and silly and also play a character with a deeply emotional and relatable story.”

Another performer who chose to remain anonymous stated, “I will say that the process was a little difficult. I think there was some favoritism shown among the cast, and some cast members did not take the responsibility of this show seriously. There were also differences in everyone’s ideas of what this show was and was meant to be. Even with all of this, I think the final product was very beautiful. Everyone brought something so different to this show, and I think it meant a lot to all of us. It was really nice to be able to see how different each role was with who brought it to life.”

Costume crew member Lilly Fleischer ‘29 also remarked on the character changes and their influence on her involvement. Even those working behind the scenes felt the effects of the lottery, as the actor’s various roles in the production meant different quick changes with different people during every show; especially the changes of Somebodies Mae Anglim and Hannah Scarlatoiu which fluctuated based on their roles as they participated in the mid-show dance macabre. Fleischer described the simultaneous suspense, stress and joy of seeing who would play each track on any given night.

That being said, the whole team’s efforts paid off as viewer Griffin Blackburn ‘28 reported, “Watching the actors get their roles drawn from a hat live was such a fun and unique experience as an audience member.” Sof Öberg ‘26 echoed this sentiment, saying, “I thought it was a really good show! It was so cool to know that no performance would be exactly the same, and it was clear that every single one of the Somebodies had their own unique versions of each character…I didn’t fully understand the western design, but it didn’t hinder my enjoyment of the piece.”

Similarly, just as humanity and its relationships are made visible on stage, so too is death. Death comes to life in the performance of Reece Holden ‘29, understudy/dramaturg Talia Schwartz ‘28 and their crew of Danse Macabre performers. Choreographed by Associate Professor of Dance Heidi Cruz-Austin, the dance macabre took place at around the two-thirds mark of the show, with cowboy hat toting Death conducting skeletons in neck ruffs through laughter and tears all swirled into a modern balletic story intermission. Öberg said, “The dance macabre was one of my favorite moments, I thought it added the perfect moment of levity while staying true to the world of the play.”

In addition to this character portrayal, death was also present in Everybody in a metaphorical sense, with many senior cast and crew members in their final semesters. Somebody actor Leighann Koppenhofer ‘26 stated, “‘Everybody’ was incredibly special to have as my last Muhlenberg departmental show. This show is about endings, and coming to accept them with grace, as scary as they may be. As I am personally coming to the end of my college experience, it’s a beautiful parallel and reminds me that although what comes next is unknown, in many ways it is just the beginning.”

The universal theme of “Everybody” begs consideration of how the play can be applied to life and provoke a different experience for different viewers and participants. With cast and audience intermingled in the risers and a line dance after bows, “Everybody” asks the question of when the play really ends and what we bring with us when it does.

To that point, we conclude with the words of Jacobs-Jenkins through an anonymous cast member, “I hope the audience left with the final words of the Usher, ‘You know, just really being nice to each other. For once. And I’m talking about everybody.’”

+ posts