In the fall of 2025, Muhlenberg College made the decision to sunset both the Dana Scholars Program and the Muhlenberg Scholars Program, making the class of 2029 the last class for both programs. The decision was primarily informed by the Admissions data analysis, although conversations with program directors and administrators also ensued. 

“In spring 2025, Muhlenberg experienced difficulty in enrolling full cohorts for each of the four honors programs,” according to Interim Vice President of Enrollment Management Terry Cowdrey, in consultation with Provost Laura Furge. “The data showed that the number of students who accepted our offer to be included in an honors program was lower than that of students with comparable academic records who were not invited to participate in an honors program.” 

Cowdrey also adds that the College’s honors programs had more requirements than those of other colleges, and that the general academic merit scholarships had been less than those offered by many peer institutions. “Eliminating two honors programs and the scholarship portion of a third [program] allowed the reallocation of those funds to the general academic merit scholarships awarded at the time of admission.” She emphasized that “students currently in the honors programs will still receive their honors program scholarships,” and added that the addition of an experiential learning requirement for all students, along with “many new ways for students to fulfill that learning requirement,” provides a “stronger framework for students to pursue their passion.”

Sharing his thoughts on the rationale behind ending the honors programs, Director of the Muhlenberg Scholars Program Matt Moore believes, “You can’t compare [the students who received admissions to honors programs to those with comparable academic records who were not], one-to-one.” Rather, he says, “we should be looking at this group who are given honors program invitations and asking what defines them?… because my assumption is that those people possess attributes that are not strictly measurable quantifiably.” Moore also adds that he and Director of the Dana Scholars Program Ioanna Chatzidimitrou had “offered to become a part of the admissions process, so that we could add our labor to the goal of yielding higher percentages of students. We had some pretty concrete ideas…” which he says were raised in a faculty meeting, only to be “summarily dismissed.”

Regarding the reallocation of scholarship funds to different merit scholarships, Moore reveals that “this is the first time I’ve seen this rationale.” He continues, “We were told that this was an Admissions decision, but the directors were never put in contact with Admissions… Things were lost in communication, probably in both directions.” Expanding on this new piece of information, Moore states, “I would have appreciated a larger conversation about benefit-loss analysis, because I don’t know how much they think we’re benefitting from this.”

Reflecting on what the Dana Scholars Program contributed to the College, Chatzidimitrou says, “the public facing ethos that is carried through this program and through the students of this program… that was the ethos of the scholar citizen or citizen scholar. The best thing we can do is mobilize what we learn as academics and to serve the needs of the world.” Sharing the same sentiment, Moore says that “these programs brought people together into literal rooms, in classes, that they would take together across four years.” Expounding on this point, Chatzidimitrou characterizes Dana Scholars as “students that are very likely to do research presentations and share them with the rest of the community. Those are the kinds of students that are in a lead academically as well as civically. So, yes, their presence on our campus– and I’m talking about the Danas that I know well– is important. They’re a net positive.” 

When asked how she thinks the termination of the programs aligns with the College’s broader strategic plan, Chatzidimitrou responded: “It doesn’t. I don’t see it. I don’t because I think [the program] is very well aligned with our existing curriculum.” She says of the College that “Some things are changing around here and you see it. But our mission hasn’t changed– we’re a liberal arts college serving the intellectually curious and the civically engaged.” 

Speaking on the recruitment and yield of prospective students, Moore shares that “based on my experience with students in honors programs, it sure looks like an overwhelming majority of them would not have chosen Muhlenberg without these programs.” 

Sophia Stassi ‘28 of the Dana Scholars Program shares that “The [Dana Scholars Program] was definitely a huge deciding factor when deciding where to go to school. Not only did the program give me a scholarship but I knew I wanted to go to a school with an honors program because I thought it could help me push myself academically and help with success in the future.” 

Eliyah Burg ‘28 of the Muhlenberg Scholars Program believes she would not have come to Muhlenberg if it weren’t for the program, explaining that “I only applied to schools that checked three boxes: a strong program in my major areas, Jewish community and strong academics or an honors college– the honors programs were how Muhlenberg fulfilled that final criteria. Additionally, I wouldn’t have been able to afford to come here without the academic scholarships the program provided.” 

Jack Roseman ‘29 of the Dana Scholars Program shares that he likely would still have come to Muhlenberg if it weren’t for the program, “but the decision would be harder… and I would probably consider other colleges… that also gave me generous offers.” Similarly, Priya Gupta ‘27 of the Muhlenberg Scholars Program says that she “would have considered other options without the honors program, but I believe I would have still decided to attend Muhlenberg.” She adds that as a Muhlenberg Scholar, she has been “provided the opportunity to interact regularly with a cohort of scholars to discuss [their] differing interests, research, and coursework. This distinction has allowed [them] to engage in academic dialogues, interdisciplinary discussions, and provide support for each other as [they] have grown both socially and academically since [their] first semesters at Muhlenberg.”

Reflecting on what the program meant to her, Burg believes that the discontinuation will negatively impact the College’s reputation: “In eliminating the Muhlenberg and Dana Scholars programs, the college has essentially halved the number of opportunities for strong academic students at the college, which I am sure will affect its reputation both as I consider how it would have affected my own college search, as well as the way it will affect the way I speak to prospective students (which I do quite often)—if a student asked me about the quality of academics here at Muhlenberg, I will not lie to them.”

+ posts

Tony '28 is a biology major. When he's not in class or writing for the Weekly, he's usually doing some research, reading a book, or lowballing on Grailed.