Home Campus Voices Across the aisle: The politics of reproductive freedom

Across the aisle: The politics of reproductive freedom

As national and state battles over abortion access continue, Muhlenberg students from across the political spectrum discuss reproductive rights, bodily autonomy and the role of government in personal decisions.

1194
Various political groups around campus discuss reproductive rights and freedom. Graphic by Kabir Burman '27.

Women in Politics:

The overturning of Roe v. Wade in 2022 was a monumental Supreme Court decision in regards to reproductive rights that continues to carry weight today. The initial case of Roe v. Wade was decided in 1973, which the Court at the time ruled to legalize abortions in a broad range of circumstances while minimizing state regulations to reproductive rights. In 2021, however, the Supreme Court was once again presented with a similar case known as Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization. This time, the Justices reversed their decision from Roe v. Wade, concluding that abortions are not a protected right in the Constitution. This decision ultimately opened the door for states to decide their own reproductive legislation without federal restrictions. Today, the topic of abortion, and more broadly reproductive health as a whole, continues to be heavily debated. What makes this topic particularly contentious is the deep moral basis from which many derive their opinions. Regardless, opinions tend to vary across the political spectrum and we’ve asked Muhlenberg College Democrats and Muhlenberg College Republicans to share where their party stands on this issue. 

Rights vs. Regulation: Does the Constitution guarantee a right to privacy in personal healthcare decisions, and how should the right to reproductive freedom be interpreted today? Should it be protected at the federal level or decided state by state? 

College Democrats: 

The Supreme Court has found that a combination of the First, Third, Fourth and Fourteenth amendments of the Constitution give us the implied right to privacy. This right was established in Griswold v. Connecticut, the case which set the precedent for other landmark decisions such as Obergefell v. Hodges (right to gay marriage) and Lawrence v. Texas (right to sexual autonomy), and of course Roe v. Wade, which established a federally protected right to abortion. This implied right to privacy is deeply rooted in many of our cherished rights as Americans. It is imperative to the protection of these rights that Roe v. Wade is reinstated, under its original constitutional context.  By passing the protection of this right down to the states, we jeopardize many of our personal freedoms, which are granted to us in the Constitution. This loss of freedom is in addition to the public health crisis that is created by abolishing federal-level protections for abortion.  

College Republicans:

While the Constitution does not explicitly guarantee a right to privacy in personal healthcare decisions, it does affirm that every person has the right to life. The American College of Pediatricians argues that biological evidence shows that from the moment of conception, the embryo is a genetically distinct living human organism and therefore should be protected under the constitutional right to life. Many Americans, however, interpret the issue differently. 

Abortion had federal protection under Roe v. Wade (1973), which recognized a constitutional right to abortion. This precedent was overturned in 2022 by Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, in which the Supreme Court ruled that the Constitution does not guarantee a right to abortion and that regulatory authority should return to the states. Polling shows that many moderate Republicans support leaving abortion policy to the states. Recent reporting indicates that 43% of Americans identify as pro-life but oppose a federal abortion ban, while 13% support a complete federal ban. Because of the significant national division on the matter, a federal abortion ban appears unlikely in the foreseeable future. For many advocates, this debate is understood as not only a reproductive rights question, but as a broader human rights issue. 

Public Policy and Access: Nearly half of U.S. states have enacted abortion restrictions or bans since Dobbs, while others have expanded protections. What role should government play in ensuring– or limiting– access to abortion and contraception?

College Democrats: 

There is never any reason for the government to be involved in a woman’s decisions about her own body. Immediately before the Roe v. Wade decision, which removed the power to ban abortions from the states,  200 women were recorded as having died from illegal abortion attempts and complications per year, not including the unrecorded deaths. These are the horror stories that you hear of women trying to fall down stairs, ingesting poisons or using instruments to try to induce an abortion. State abortion bans do not stop abortion; they stop safe abortions. Women will always exercise their right to choose what is best for them and their bodies. By protecting abortion at the federal level, we protect this right and save thousands of women’s lives. The government should not decide what a woman does with her own body. 

College Republicans:

Recent judicial decisions have shifted abortion access to state-level authority, meaning each state now determines its own regulations and the extent of allowed abortion services. In 2017, President Donald Trump signed legislation described by Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California as a measure that “defund[ed] Planned Parenthood” by restricting federal Medicaid reimbursements. Supporters of state-centered policy argue that federal tax revenues should not be used to support organizations that provide abortion services and that such decisions should remain aligned with state jurisdiction.

Concerns about contraception and adolescent sexual behavior are often linked to variability in the quality and comprehensiveness of sexual-education curricula across states. Some analyses argue that current approaches to sex education do not adequately communicate the medical, psychological and social risks associated with early sexual activity. Public Square Magazine observes that many modern sex-education programs omit key behavioral risk information, creating gaps in what young people are taught about sexual decision-making. United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) reports that early exposure to sexual content, including pornography, is linked to poorer mental health, greater sexism and objectification and increased vulnerability to sexual violence.

These findings underscore the importance of strengthening evidence-based, developmentally appropriate sexual-education programs to ensure that adolescents receive accurate information that supports healthy and informed choices.

Finding Common Ground: Despite divisions, surveys show majority support for exceptions in cases of rape, incest or maternal health risk. Are there shared principles between pro-life and pro-choice perspectives– such as reducing unintended pregnancies or supporting mothers and children?

College Democrats: 

Pro-choice is not synonymous with pro-abortion. The democratic conviction of being pro-choice is a larger desire for women to have autonomy over their own bodies and lives; this includes the woman’s right to choose to get an abortion. This can also look like offering women services and counseling to be able to make the best and most informed decisions for their own bodies, providing comprehensive sexual education which focuses on preventative safe sex practices and offering pregnant women support with whatever decision they make. We also think that continued support for mothers and children is crucial to protecting American lives. This means supporting young families during and after their pregnancies by protecting programs like Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and public healthcare, which support young families’ health and needs. 

College Republicans:

Many Republicans who identify as moderately pro-life support exceptions for rape, incest or significant maternal health risks. Data from the Guttmacher Institute show these cases are rare: only 1% of abortions involve rape, and less than 0.5% involve incest. Pro-life advocates argue that these emotionally charged cases shouldn’t dictate policy and that ending a life in response to tragedy doesn’t address the underlying harm.

Some pro-life groups argue that restricting abortion could lower unintended pregnancies by changing cultural norms. They argue that concerns about a rise in “unsafe abortions” are overstated, pointing instead to documented cases in which abortion facilities– such as Planned Parenthood locations– have transferred patients to hospitals for emergency treatments. Some pro-life sources warn that abortion may cause physical or psychological complications, including post-abortion distress. 

For many people, the abortion debate is grounded more in moral and ethical beliefs than in policy. Since most abortions are not related to rape or incest, pro-life advocates argue that choosing sexual activity means accepting the risk of pregnancy. From this view, cases involving rape, incest or maternal risk offer some common ground, but the larger debate centers on human dignity and protecting vulnerable life.

+ posts

Kabir Burman '27 is an international student from India double majoring in media & communication and political science. He is constantly looking for new ways to bring you the stories that matter and feature different perspectives. If you can't find him in the newsroom, you'll find him playing the piano, taking a nap, or planning his next trip to NYC!