Home Sports Competing until the final possession

Competing until the final possession

Muhlenberg’s double overtime performance sets the tone for the year ahead.

374
Men's basketball falls to Moravian University in a tough, double overtime battle. Photo by Sierra Addy '27.

The Muhlenberg men’s basketball team opened its 2025–2026 season in dramatic fashion against Moravian University, battling through regulation and two overtime periods before falling just short  in a tightly contested 96-93 game. While the outcome was not what the Mules hoped for, the performance reflected the team’s preseason focus on energy, conditioning and unity. For many players, the game provided both a test and a statement of what this year’s roster is capable of becoming.

One of the team’s guards, Drew Greene ‘26, emphasized the importance of the strong start. “I think we definitely started out better than normal,” Greene said. “We came out with energy and threw a first punch at them. People think we’re not supposed to be that great this year, but those first four or five minutes were a great start for us. There was great communication and hustle.” He added that playing hard and vocal early helped balance out mistakes. “When you’re playing early and loud, taking charges makes up for a lot of mistakes.”

“We came out with energy and threw a first punch at them. People think we’re not supposed to be that great this year, but those first four or five minutes were a great start for us. There was great communication and hustle.” – Drew Greene ’26

The environment wasn’t just intense because it was opening night. Elias Sherman-Murphy ‘27 described the atmosphere as fueled by familiarity and rivalry. “The intensity was high from the beginning of the game,” Sherman-Murphy said. “It was a rivalry game for both teams and we beat them last year, so they were looking to get their revenge.”

Forward Peter Stanton-Shepherd ‘27 pointed to the team’s strong defensive approach early on, continuing, “We talked through actions and played with a good level of intensity. The game turned out to be long and grueling, and we lost some of that as it went, but the way we started showed what we’re capable of.”

Much of that readiness came from what many players described as the most demanding preseason they’ve experienced. Stanton-Shepard said, “Practices have been very competitive because there were new spots for different positions available. There have been tough stretches and we still made some mental mistakes, but for a first game, it was a good sign of where we are.”

Greene agreed, pointing to the conditioning work that paid off. “Going into double overtime, you have to be in great shape. During practices and lifts, we pushed each other, and it definitely showed. We faced adversity, and we didn’t back down.”

Forward Nate Hoffman ‘26 noted that the team entered the game fully expecting intensity. “We came into the game knowing it was going to be intense and fast-paced,” Hoffman said. “We were excited to get out there and compete and get the season started.”

Hoffman added, “There was great energy throughout the game. Guys on the court played hard the entire game, and guys on the bench provided good energy. Everyone was trying to give us the best chance to win.”

Sherman-Murphy echoed that the group stayed mentally centered during critical stretches. “It was pretty calm honestly,” he said of the overtime huddles. “We knew what we had to do in order to execute. The main thing was we needed to get stops on defense.”

Coaching messaging also played a role. Greene recalled a moment entering overtime: “The coach said, ‘Why not just enjoy this and play five more minutes together?’” he shared. “It was about staying present and embracing the moment.”

After the final buzzer, Sherman-Murphy added, the message was rooted in perspective. “It was pretty simple,” he said. “This was a good first test for us and even though we lost, it will prepare us for games in the future. Being that it was the first game, it’s going to get sloppy at times. We just have to keep making the right play.”

“It was pretty simple. This was a good first test for us and even though we lost, it will prepare us for games in the future. Being that it was the first game, it’s going to get sloppy at times. We just have to keep making the right play.” – Elias Sherman-Murphy ‘27

Looking ahead, the loss serves as both motivation and a reference point. “We’re upset about the loss,” Stanton-Shepard said. “We’re going to come with fire, focus in practice and take care of business one game at a time.”

Greene agreed, stating, “The main takeaway is to keep fighting and stick together. We didn’t get the result we wanted, but this can help us later in the season.”

With the season just underway, the Mules have already shown resilience, depth and belief. The next test arrives quickly on Nov. 14 at the University of Mount Union. Hoffman summed up the mindset for the upcoming game and the season in general simply: “We’re excited, we’re hungry and we’re ready to compete.”

+ posts