Home Sports Back on track: Mules regain form in 56–7 statement victory against McDaniel

Back on track: Mules regain form in 56–7 statement victory against McDaniel

“This year we want it really bad,” Peyton Elliott says, as team depth and focus fuel a commanding win.

390
Muhlenberg football continues there Centennial conference dominance in their win against McDaniel. Photo by Sierra Addy '27.

The Muhlenberg College football team delivered a dominant response following its first loss of the season, rolling past McDaniel College 56–7 on Saturday, Oct. 18, in Westminster, Md. The Mules (5–1 overall, 2–1 Centennial Conference) scored on eight of their ten possessions and controlled the game from the opening kick. 

Running back Matthew Manning ’26 led the way early, scoring three first-half touchdowns while surpassing the 1,000-yard career rushing mark. Isaac Schaffer-Neitz ‘27 added a career-best performance, rushing for 97 yards and two touchdowns on just nine carries. “I think any kind of run play worked,” Schaffer-Neitz said. “The offensive line was playing very well and taking care of the defensive line and linebackers.”

Quarterback Dante Mahaffey ‘26 orchestrated the offense and threw for 160 yards and a touchdown while adding another score on the ground. By halftime, the Mules led 35–0 and had completely dictated the pace of the game.

“This year we’re a very close-knit team, we want [the conference title] really bad, Last season wasn’t what we wanted, so we put a lot of work in during the offseason. This team is more hungry than last year.” – Peyton Elliott ’26

Muhlenberg’s defense and special teams forced multiple turnovers and limited McDaniel to just 216 total yards. Early in the game,  Thomas Curreri ’28 recorded a sack that led to a fumble recovery, while Peyton Elliott ’26 pounced on a key special teams fumble that helped extend the Mules first-half lead.

Elliott described the sideline atmosphere as both energetic and focused “from what I could hear on the sidelines, everyone’s juiced after big plays,” he said. “Teammates are supporting each other, backups are pointing out tips that guys on the field haven’t seen yet. There’s a lot of energy, a lot of juice, but we’re locked in at the same time.”

Linebacker Ethan Kalkanis ‘28 led the defense with seven tackles and his first career interception, while Brian Walsh ’28 added a sack and fumble recovery to seal a near-perfect defensive effort.

The Mules continued to build their lead in the second half with contributions from younger players. Shawn Pelovitz ‘29 and Sebastian Chaney ‘28 each scored their first career touchdowns and kicker Andrew Deutsch ‘28 stayed perfect on getting extra points for the Mules and went seven-for-seven.

Schaffer-Neitz said the team’s strong chemistry has been key to sustaining consistency. “We’re such a close team, we’re friends off the field and do stuff together,” he said. “That makes it easier to go out there, be confident and succeed at the same level.”

Elliott said this year’s squad is closer and more motivated than ever. “This year we’re a very close-knit team, we want [the conference title] really bad,” he said. “Last season wasn’t what we wanted, so we put a lot of work in during the offseason. This team is more hungry than last year.” Elliott credited discipline as the defense’s biggest area of growth. “Since last year, we’ve grown a lot as a defense. Plays will come to you if everyone just does their job. Not a lot of mistakes, and that discipline factor has been huge for us.”

Schaffer-Neitz pointed to the team’s depth as a major difference-maker. “We started the year younger than in past seasons, but we’ve gotten better each game,” he said. “We’re really deep this year, a bunch of guys are making plays.”

On the topic of performing away from home, both players highlighted the importance of mindset. “Playing on the road, it’s about getting your mind right,” Elliott said. “Overnight trips are tougher because your routine is off, but the mindset is always to win.” Schaffer-Neitz added, “It’s pretty cool to see other stadiums and fans. For our team, it’s not a huge difference, home or away, we play the same.”

“These next two weeks are the most important of the season. We’re playing for each other and staying healthy so we can make a big playoff push.” – Peyton Elliott ’26

As the Mules gear up for their final stretch, the team’s goals remain clear. “The focus is to win, make the playoffs, and go on a good playoff run,” Elliott said. “These next two weeks are the most important of the season. We’re playing for each other and staying healthy so we can make a big playoff push.”

Schaffer-Neitz added, “Obviously wins are the goal, but we need to start fast and keep that same intensity during every play of the game. That’s going to be extremely important for the rest of the season.”

With the commanding 56–7 win over McDaniel, the Mules reminded everyone of their identity: disciplined, balanced and united. As they head into the final weeks of the season, setting up an important two-game stretch against Carnegie Mellon University and Johns Hopkins University, two of the Centennial’s toughest opponents, is crucial for the team. Muhlenberg looks poised to make another strong postseason push, driven by team chemistry and belief in one another.

+ posts