Sept. 11, 2001, planes are hijacked and crashed into the twin towers and the Pentagon. In the ensuing destruction and violence, 309,472 people die.
Sept. 11, 2025, 2,977 (I’m guessing here– I didn’t count) tiny U.S. flags go up on little old Muhlenberg’s campus.
If the 309,472 number seems a little high to you, well, it’s not the one usually reported. Data from Iraq Body Count– as interpreted by the Independent– shows that 306,495 violent deaths occurred from 2003 to 2022 in or as a consequence of the Iraq-American War. The vast majority were Iraqi civilians: 208,964. Smaller, but roughly equal numbers of Iraq national military forces (48,719) and Iraqi soldiers opposing the U.S. invasion (39,881) were killed.
U.S. military and U.S. contractor deaths bring the total U.S. deaths to 11,225.
The numbers do not equate. Do you think we could fit that 298,247 Iraq flags on Academic Row?

We have all learned by now, from the ongoing genocide of Palestinians, what the indirect deaths of war are– those from lack of access to food, water, shelter and medical care. The numbers above do not include indirect deaths of the Iraq-American War.
War kills the people who live on the ground where it is fought (you may recall this from middle school U.S. history, where someone may have informed you more Americans died in the Slaveholder Rebellion– ahem Civil War– than in World War I and World War II combined). (Ignore that the U.S. stayed out of both wars as long as it could. Pretend we were heroes who’s boat just arrived late).
As I write this (on Sept. 16), there are still signs up on Academic Row calling those flags a “9/11 Memorial.”
I call them festivities. The U.S. has always been in need of excuses for its violence in the Middle East. Why not celebrate such a grand one nearly a quarter of a century on?
Let those who experienced personal loss during and because of Sept. 11 mourn in the way anyone does: tell stories, weep, attempt to rebuild.
Nowhere do 9/11 festivities honor the 2,977 U.S. residents who died on Sept. 11 2001; they animate their corpses to fight today’s cultural battles through performative patriotism. If we are going to resurrect the memories of the people killed after the 9/11 attacks to fight the political battles of 2025, add in the other 298,247 of them, and see how the balance shifts.
(P.S. if we are going to resurrect any Americans from Sept. 11, let them be the passengers of Flight 93 who acted directly, and violently, to prevent greater violence).
Photo by Arwen Lutwyche ’26


















