2 p.m. on Saturday: I am having a lazy morning in bed when the national anthem plays through my dorm window. This, before buzzers or cheering, tells me a football game is on.
Let’s back up a minute in my history…
My parents are immigrants to the U.S., albeit those the current administration is visibly uprooting, attacking, imprisoning, disappearing; they are white, highly educated, from England. Still, I like to think it means I received a lower dose of American patriotism at home.
I am born three years after they arrive, in Pennsylvania.
By first grade, I know Thanksgiving (turkey!), the presidents (later, I find a coloring page I don’t remember, of Obama’s swearing in, nothing colored except his face, which sports a drawl of yellow), Martin Luther King Jr., Rosa Parks and Malcolm X (a series of myths, misconceptions, lies): the essentials.
“I pledge allegiance to the Flag…” each morning, but my siblings, born abroad, won’t be citizens for years. It doesn’t occur to me to wonder if they too stand, hand on heart, for “…the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.”
“’I pledge allegiance to the Flag…’ each morning, but my siblings, born abroad, won’t be citizens for years. It doesn’t occur to me to wonder if they too stand, hand on heart, for ‘…the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.’”
Middle school American history essay question 1: “What caused the culture of the Colonies to become so different from England, to allow the Revolution to happen?” I get a “C” (and probably panic), because the answer was to quote the textbook and write that, “The Atlantic Ocean is wide. Distance allows change.” Neither I nor the textbook ask, “How much of U.S. culture did change?”
My AP U.S. History teacher, a woman with a doctorate in Antebellum U.S. history explains the “great experiment.” America is an experiment in liberty and justice for all. We haven’t done it…yet! 91,031 days (dating my draft) since independence, and slavery– the elimination of unpaid, forced labor in prisons would benefit everyone– legal for each one of them. How many trials does one experiment need?
Over supper, Mum reminds me she’s never taken a U.S. history course when I explain the Three-Fifth’s Compromise. My APUSH teacher often despaired, “This is probably the last U.S. history class you’ll take.”
My uncle visits from England. We talk 9/11 over supper. I am sipping my first beer. I say the way 9/11 exists in the U.S. public consciousness is created, not natural. Uncle disagrees. Dad doesn’t. “When I was in college, there were times I couldn’t take the train because there were bomb threats from the IRA. It was something we had to deal with. Americans aren’t used to that.” Mum too, “There is a difference in the reporting. American lives, and other lives.” Then, “We’d just come to America in 2001. We felt pressure, as foreigners, to keep quiet, not to criticize,” (there is a case for underutilized white-privilege here, yes).
In August, Mum interrupts me– doom-scrolling– to ask if college radicalized me. I said something incoherent about exploitation a week ago, is what happened.
I’m not sure if I received that lower dose of patriotism. But I’ve been watching my parents show signs. They, like a great many immigrants, feel they owe something to the U.S. They fly a flag now. I hope it came free with an “A” on the citizenship exam.
Mum and I do a 5k run (or walk, thankfully) raising money for a non-profit. Before the whistle blows, a speaker turns on, painfully loud. The runners turn, confused until they find the nearest flag. Lots of flags fly in Baltimore. Hands find hearts. This is, again, a non-profit, not a government organization. We are doing the national anthem…because…this is a sporting event? Cross arms, grumble, make no further fuss.
Trey Reed is found hung from a tree at college. He is my age. The Departmenr of Justice was reconstructed in Trump’s image months ago, but there was a lineage of lynchings, through the Emmett Till Antilynching Act, through Paul Robeson’s 1951 “We Charge Genocide” petition, and back another 80 years. Think about walking in a direction, and think about running in it.
After I write about the 9/11 memorial at Muhlenberg, Shajnin Howlader reaches out, and shares her story.
Back in November 2024, when 45,000 Palestinians had already been killed and two million more displaced, Harris comes to Muhlenberg the day before the election– Trump was in Allentown weeks earlier. I don’t attend Harris’ rally, but the aura on campus is…big. I am in on it.
At the rally, Shajnin takes a chance and disrupts proceedings: “I want to vote for you, but how can I vote for you when you keep on sending 2,000-pound bombs to my family? How could I vote for you when you are causing a genocide? How are our rights protected when you are enabling a genocide?”
Harris says, “That’s okay, and it is my pledge to you to listen to those who will be impacted by the decisions I make…to listen to people who disagree with me…I am not going to be a leader who believes that people who disagree with me should be put in jail…I will give them a seat at the table,” as the dissenter is removed by the Secret Service.
The crowd, including no few Muhlenberg students, begins chanting: “U…S..A! US…A! U..S.A! U.S.A! U.S.A!” All is repaired.
Imagine being chanted at. Imagine how much more terrifying the reaction at a Trump rally could be. Imagine these are your options, because one of them is better. Think about walking in a direction, and think about running in it.
2 p.m. on a Saturday: I am having a lazy (be honest this time) afternoon when the national anthem plays through my dorm window. Football game. Is the crowd standing? Are hands on hearts? Have they turned, like compasses, to a striped flag?
If a 2,000-pound bomb interrupted…would they still stand?
Maybe they would; I’ll admit: “U…S..A! U…S..A! U..S.A! U.S.A! U.S.A!” has a hell of a ring to it.
I cannot promise a part 2, the bridge to [ ] We WILL have to figure it out, though.


















