Home Arts & Culture Muhlenberg arts faculty on combating artistic censorship

Muhlenberg arts faculty on combating artistic censorship

Advice for students looking to pursue the arts as activism under the current administration.

782
Photo credit to Muhlenberg's Zenfolio.
Photo credit to Muhlenberg's Zenfolio.

President Donald Trump’s attack on the arts and education is evident through the dismantling of the Department of Education as well as Trump’s takeover of The John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts under the assertion that, “We don’t need ‘woke’ at the Kennedy Center” in response to recent performances featuring drag artists. However, this censorship seems to be manifesting itself in less overt ways even here at Muhlenberg College. For instance, Professor of Dance Robyn Watson shared a recent anecdote in which she was notified by her students that links provided by the Library of Congress to biographies of Black figures and dancers integral to the formation of modern tap dance were no longer available, even though she had referenced them for classes prior. “I had a conversation with students about how even in the midst of information being restricted, it doesn’t mean that that information is fully gone,” Watson explained. “You just need to now find other segways to look for it.” 

Given that Muhlenberg is a liberal arts college, many students graduate with a newfound appreciation for the arts and humanities as well as its ability to influence social change. However, recent legislation that promotes artistic censorship and limits the presentation of diverse perspectives has left many feeling uncertain about how they will continue to use the arts as an avenue for justice. Watson’s assertion that there are methods in which artists can express themselves and tell diverse stories even amidst efforts to silence those voices is a sentiment shared among faculty. 

“All of this is disheartening because we’re seeing a kind of dismantling of different venues to express ourselves,” acknowledges Associate Professor of Theatre Leticia Robles-Moreno on the impact of these events. “The first response is kind of feeling hopeless and sad. However, it’s also helping us, I believe, to find people that share respect and hold a special place for these kinds of ideas – critical thinking, freedom of expression and creativity.”

Emanuela Kucik, who is the director of the Africana Studies program and an associate professor of English and Africana Studies, says, “I always try to remind students that these anti-DEI [diversity, equity and inclusion] bans are happening because the principles of DEI –  diversity, equity and inclusion – are working. These initiatives and policies are actively creating real, positive change and are trying to provide everyone with equitable access to a wide range of opportunities.” 

Kucik also commented on the inextricable link between the arts and social justice through the lens of the increase in book bannings. “People don’t go out of their way to ban initiatives and art that aren’t creating tangible change, so when we see these bans, it’s because these DEI initiatives and books that focus on diversity, equity and inclusion are inspiring change across the country. I try to remember that as inspiration to fight harder than ever for DEI initiatives and to fight harder than ever against book bans because we need the groundbreaking change this work can provide. I hope artists will take this to heart and remember that their work is more important than ever right now, and their voices deserve – and need – to be heard.”

Elizabeth Nathanson’s perspective as a media and communication professor with concentrations in pop culture is telling of what media scholars might be hoping to see from artists in the next few years. She says, “These attacks and attempts to limit the creative expression of artists is not new, but this current iteration is poised to intimidate those who wish to use their art to challenge the status quo. As destabilizing as this moment is, art and culture can offer hope and visions of alternative ways of being, and I hope that students (and all of us) can continue to be inspired to ask meaningful questions about and through creative worlds. Popular culture can offer common ground to have complex conversations about texts that at times challenge and at other times uphold power relations, and at this moment of fractured communities and divisions, having that shared space feels particularly important.” 

“I think one of the most implicit ways of how social justice in particular can be practiced is through the arts itself,” states Watson, who emphasizes that seemingly small actions in artmaking can go a long way towards advocating for others. She provides examples of how this can look like anything from “dancing to music that was used as music for resistance or music for marching in your choreographic work” to “asking if you can offer free dance classes once a week for ages 10-12.” She says, “There’s space to still do justice work without labelling it as justice work because the issue is that when it’s labeled as justice work, that puts an alert on this particular administration to dismantle it.”

“I think one of the most implicit ways of how social justice in particular can be practiced is through the arts itself.” – Professor of Dance Robyn Watson

Faculty also provided advice for students in their respective academic fields who plan on pursuing social justice work through these subject areas. Kucik shares, “Africana Studies grew out of a tradition of activism, and the field is a blend of activism and scholarship, so these students are continuing a long tradition of fighting for diversity, equity and inclusion, and they stand on the shoulders of all who came before them and fought for those same principles in different historical contexts. Literature has also often been used as a tool for freedom, so I hope that students in both English and Africana Studies will continue intertwining scholarship, activism, literature, art and more to highlight the beautiful diversity of our world and to make that world equitable, peaceful, inclusive and safe for all.” 

Robles-Moreno provided insight for theater students specifically, sharing, “One of the core values of our program and of Muhlenberg in general is collaboration. My advice or words of encouragement is to not to forget that particular power of art that is the power of bringing people together to collaborate and to listen. I think that collaborative element of art is what we have to hold onto because that creates safe spaces and spaces of belonging.”

On a similar note, both Robles-Moreno and Nathanson mentioned how they love when students make connections between different classes and testify that these are needed more than ever. Nathanson says, “Sharing knowledge across disciplines like that seems especially valuable these days in order to show how we can continue to foster a space for community and support ongoing creative expression.”

Although the limits imposed by the current administration may require artists to consider different ways of using their artistic expression to uplift the voices of marginalized communities, artists and educators like Watson remain just as dedicated to these causes as they were before. Watson says, “As far as this space, I am still teaching this Black art form, the beauty and the hurt of this art form which often includes how racism has affected and infected it. Unless someone is actually pulling me or yanking me away from this classroom, I am still going to teach the way I’ve been teaching when this administration wasn’t here.” As the Artistic Director for dance productions at Muhlenberg, Watson also shares what she hopes her students will bring to mainstage works in the wake of artistic censorship and anti-DEI legislation: “I want them to think outside of themselves, even though it is still your story, there is still space to think beyond. I also want them to start thinking about other bodies in the space, whether those are full-bodied dancers, whether those are disabled body dancers, whether those are neurological dancers, and how they can still contribute to the goal and the objective of their stories.”

Robles-Moreno also comments on how she hopes students will continue to incorporate these discussions into their academic work at Muhlenberg: “I always tell my students you have the right to be heard, you have the right to be listened to and you have the right to ask questions. So, it’s important to ask questions and to create spaces for uncomfortable conversations. To be brave enough to be uncomfortable, and also approaching faculty. Maybe not in class, but office hours, going with yourself or with other people. I think this is the moment to ask questions.”

+ posts

Samantha Tempkin '25 is a theatre and media & communication double major. During her time with The Weekly, she served as an assistant editor for News and a lead editor for Arts & Culture.