On March 10, the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights (OCR) sent letters to 60 colleges and universities, including Muhlenberg, “warning them of potential enforcement actions if they do not fulfill their obligations under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act,” said a press release by the DOE. The letter highlights the need to protect Jewish students on campus.
The OCR’s press release also stated that the Department launched direct investigations into five universities where widespread antisemitic harassment has been reported. “The 55 additional universities are under investigation or monitoring in response to complaints filed with OCR.”
According to an email sent to the campus community by President Kathleen Harring, the College does not have an open investigation with the OCR. “To our knowledge, Muhlenberg is not on the list of institutions with open investigations related to shared ancestry. In 2024 Muhlenberg entered a resolution agreement with [the] OCR, addressing a previous complaint and continues to execute the agreement in all regards.”
However, the actions taken against one institution in particular, Columbia University, raise concerns among the faculty regarding academic freedom and free speech. The press release announced the immediate cancellation of $400 million in federal funding to Columbia University due to the school’s alleged “inaction to protect Jewish students from discrimination.”
In order to restore federal funding, the Donald Trump administration outlined nine policy changes that the school must take “as a precondition for formal negotiations regarding Columbia University’s continued financial relationship with the United States government.”
As of March 21, Columbia has conceded to Trump’s demands, which include banning masks (with exceptions to religious and medical reasons), hiring 36 campus police officers with the power to arrest students and appointing a senior vice provost to oversee the Department of Middle East, South Asian and African Studies as well as the Center for Palestine Studies.
“I think this sets a really scary and dangerous precedent,” said Ross Dardani, professor of political science and co-chair of the Curriculum Committee. He explains that if universities and colleges allow the Trump administration to gain control over their programs, there are concerns about academic freedom and the ability for faculty to teach courses or do research on the topics that they want. “Columbia decided that they’re going to accept the terms of the Trump administration’s demands – allow government interference – and for a private institution to do that – that’s very unsettling.”
“I see this as the federal government acting in an anti-constitutional, authoritarian way to suppress academic free speech,” added Jeremy Teissere, professor of Neuroscience and chair of the Academic Policy Committee. “Given the recent sanctions at Columbia, the Department of Education is essentially threatening to withhold federal funding for a college or university because it doesn’t like the speech associated with campus protest or scholarly discourse.” It must be noted that the Trump administration is also making strides to dismantle the Department of Education, which includes the OCR.
College campuses have always been a site of political discourse and a space where diverse opinions could be shared without fear of censorship. Columbia, in particular, has been a historic site for protest, such as during the Vietnam War in the 1960s and with regard to the South African Apartheid in the 80s.
“One of the reasons the Trump administration’s challenges to the entire higher ed[ucation] sector and to specific institutions like Columbia are unsettling is that it is difficult to differentiate when these actions emerge from the legitimate concerns that equitable access to educational experience is protected for all students, (and I would say faculty and staff), and when these actions are indicative of an undemocratic turn in our broader politics designed to silence difference and imposing particular understandings,” said Brian Mello, professor of political science and associate dean of faculty development. “Countries that have experienced well-studied forms of democratic backsliding, like Turkey and Hungary, have experienced moments when populist administrations have taken over higher ed[ucation], closed academic departments and arrested hundreds of faculty and students. This reality is why I think there is such concern about political actions that threaten the independence of colleges and universities more broadly.”
Faculty are particularly concerned with academic departments going into federal receivership, or in this case, academic receivership, which entails a departmental chair being imposed from the outside by a dean or provost when “the department is judged unable to govern itself effectively,” taking control away from the faculty. While the receivers are meant to be impartial, many nonetheless view this to be a means of the government controlling academic departments.
“We must defend the freedom to teach and to learn without governmental interference,” said Teissere. “We must defend the right of faculty and students to pursue controversial questions and to participate in difficult discussions without the looming threat of ideological submission.”
“I think a case can be made for federal oversight to assure that no forms of bias or anti-semitism interfere with equal access to education,” said Mello. “But this kind of federal oversight, which has typically involved the Office of Civil Rights investigating and working with colleges and universities to mitigate any problems, is quite different from the government ordering or itself getting involved in taking over the administration of any particular academic department, unit or college campus.”
Dardani also addressed the unsettling nature of the Trump administration’s bypass of civil rights procedures in order to withhold federal funding. “With Title VI, there’s all these processes and procedures in place, where the threat of withholding federal funding is supposed to be the last possible option, where it’s usually a years-long process that happens where schools are notified by the OCR that they are potentially violating civil rights laws. And then there’s usually an attempt to come to some type of agreement or settlement. And if you keep going in the process, before the federal funding could even actually be revoked, Congress is supposed to be notified, and then Congress is supposed to have time as well to review the situation and to see if some type of agreement or settlement can be reached.”
Yet, clearly these actions were not taken by the Trump administration, as funding was revoked on March 7, just days after Columbia was told they were under review. “You don’t need to get into the weeds of how civil rights law has historically worked to recognize that if Columbia wanted to challenge this legally, they would have really strong arguments to make,” said Dardani. “So then you have to ask yourself, why does it seem like they’re basically willing to just capitulate to the Trump administration? The way I would interpret that is, I think maybe a part of the calculation that they’re making is that they don’t want to escalate things. I mean, we’re seeing now behavior from the Trump administration, especially in relation to the judicial branch, that even if they were to challenge this legally and were able to have legal outcomes that were in their favor, how confident does Columbia feel that the Trump administration would even abide by or follow a judicial order?”
Student groups and their leaders decided to share their thoughts and their fears regarding the overstepping of the Trump administration.
“I can think of very few instances where government intervention in protests and academic programming on private college campuses is acceptable,” said Skylyn Ellison ‘27, the president of Muhlenberg College Democrats. “For me, it just feels way too close to censorship and feels like it is being used as a way to threaten the academic freedom and integrity of Columbia. It also worries me how much this feels like a slippery slope into the loss of all academic freedom on university campuses. I do acknowledge that this situation is very nuanced and I can see that in some situations, in reference to hate speech on campuses, there may need to be government intervention, but I do not agree with the way this situation was handled.”
Ellison continues by speaking on the revocation of $400 million in federal funding. “I think that the government pulling funding at that magnitude to force compliance stands as a major federal overreach,” Ellison said. “It is not the responsibility of the federal government alone to decide how private universities work or what they teach. This makes me worried for the future of academic freedom which is crucial to maintaining a productive and informed population and the future of the right to protest, which is protected under the First Amendment.”
“One has to wonder, how will Muhlenberg ensure the safety of its students and academic freedom of its institution, while also abiding by federal policy that is actively pushing against principles of academic freedom?”
Muhlenberg’s Jewish Voices for Palestinian Liberation shared, “It’s a really scary action to see from the Trump Administration because it’s just so blatantly anti-free speech and clearly attacking nonviolent student protestors exercising their right to dissent. It’s also frightening to see a university like Columbia, which would claim to value diversity of thought and has publicly apologized for cooperating with state repression of peaceful student protestors against the Vietnam War, cooperating with and facilitating state violence against its own students. We’ve got to acknowledge that this is how tyranny starts and we’ve got to stand against it in any instance we can, and frankly, our academic institutions are failing to do that in a big way right now.”
Dardani added, “Timothy Snyder has a book, ‘On Tyranny,’ and he talks about the idea of obeying in advance. I think that’s what we’re seeing with higher education institutions and the Trump administration. Whether you’re on the list or not… You just don’t want to become the target of the Trump administration right now.”
As previously reported by The Weekly, colleges like The University of Houston and Ohio State University are getting rid of their diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) departments and multicultural centers in compliance with the administration’s directives, for fear of federal funding cuts.
This causes concern for a place like Muhlenberg, which has been making strides in creating a more diverse and equitable environment. One of those initiatives is the addition of the Race & Power requirement to the Pathways of Discovery curriculum. Will the College come under threat by the Trump administration for such a requirement?
“This is not just a Columbia story,” Dardani emphasized. “This has really broad, national implications, especially in regard to academic freedom and the role of universities and colleges.”
“What this means for Muhlenberg, to me, is that we need to continue to uphold our commitments to creating an educational experience dedicated to applying various modes of inquiry to think [and] tackle the major problems of our world; continue to foster a zest for reasoned debate and civil discourse that builds toward lives of leadership and service, and does so in a way that is committed to equity and inclusion,” said Mello.
In an email sent to the campus community on Feb. 28, Harring emphasized that the College will uphold its commitment to its policies and DEI. She wrote, “Muhlenberg’s practices have always been in compliance with federal and state regulations. To date, there have not been any changes to established federal or state laws.” Yet, does that matter under the current administration?
So far, there have been no reports of colleges or universities condemning the actions taken by the Trump administration. One has to wonder, how will Muhlenberg ensure the safety of its students and academic freedom of its institution, while also abiding by federal policy that is actively pushing against principles of academic freedom?
Keanna Peña '25 is the Editor-in-Chief of the Muhlenberg Weekly. She is an English and Creative Writing major with a minor in Dance. She is passionate about informing the student body and sharing her creative writing.



















