Home Campus Voices OPINION: Muhlenberg’s money. Students need to know more

OPINION: Muhlenberg’s money. Students need to know more

1967
A statue of Henry Melchoir Muhlenberg looms in the Haas College Center. Photo by Kira Bretsky '27.
A statue of Henry Melchoir Muhlenberg looms in the Haas College Center. Photo by Kira Bretsky '27.

Several small Pa. colleges have had to close their doors in recent years due to financial struggles and dropping attendance rates. Philadelphia’s University of the Arts (UA Arts) is an extreme example, where years of financial stress preceded the announcement of its closure in June of 2024. The closure blindsided students, faculty and staff, many of whom learned of the closure from social media and news articles before UA Arts’ official announcement. Stress on small colleges spiked amid financial aid delays, new regulations on mergers and the repeal of race-conscious affirmative action in 2023. President Donald Trump’s promises to gut the Department of Education would also affect small colleges like Muhlenberg by limiting their ability to offer federal grants and  other aid to students in need. We have already seen several decisive actions from the President with regard to other campaign promises like immigration and Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) funding since his inauguration. Students and employees should know more about their college’s financial health, because it directly concerns their future. 

Muhlenberg is under a particular lens for the–as yet unexplained–firing of tenured professor Maura Finkelstein, Ph.D., and scrutiny of colleges is heightened across the country, and it is clear that understanding a college’s decisions often comes down to understanding its finances. Questions about Finkelstein’s termination, the campus bookstore and health center being contracted to outside entities and required on-campus living for most students are not individual issues as they have been previously covered; they are all–potentially–tied to monetary concerns. There could be other factors, but the reasoning is not clear to the average student or employee. 

Muhlenberg’s 2023 audit reported a total of over $550 million in net assets, a number comparable to other East Coast colleges with similar undergraduate attendance. The publicly available audit is dense, full of difficult-to-read jargon and provides no specific information on where donations come from. Occasionally, community members hear of large new projects—the construction of a new building or the expansion of the student center—but the budget for these projects is only a small fraction of Muhlenberg’s operating budget. A $7.5 million donation is noted as merely a “gift to ignite funding for one new building and an expansion to Seegers Union.” By comparison, the total assets are massive. 

UA Arts’ President Kerry Walk, Ph.D., commented that the University’s financial situation had worsened–enrollment had declined from 2013–and that in a situation which “came to light very suddenly,” they could not cover some unanticipated expenses, including, a later article states, “major infrastructure repairs.” The claim is that the financial situation had been declining for several years, but also that the closure was totally unexpected. While UA Arts may have stayed open longer if not for the sudden expenses, students and employees should have been aware of the risk that their institution was one disaster from closure. The University promised to assist students in transferring to other institutions, but 350 faculty and staff members were left without jobs. UA Art’s closure highlights how little students and employees at any private college know about their institution’s longevity. 

Making prospective community members aware of Muhlenberg–and other colleges’–financial health would allow them to make informed decisions about their future education and/or employment, as well as allowing current community members to react to the colleges’ situations, perhaps allowing more robust, collaborative responses to financial difficulties. Some public colleges have engaged with their communities through various projects, from creating urban food-gardens to mentoring highschool students. Allentown is affected by the college’s health and it could be even more deeply benefited if more students understood what resources the college has to offer them in creating programs like these. Financial transparency would be a small step in fostering trust and student agency within Muhlenberg’s community.

There are reasons for the dearth of information available about Muhlenberg’s finances. Private colleges like Muhlenberg are held to less rigorous standards of transparency than public ones; they are funded by tuition, donations and investments rather than taxpayer money, and so are afforded more freedom and secrecy by law. More publicity might drive away some donors, and knowing every detail of a college’s budget would be overwhelming for students and employees, preventing them from identifying useful information. The solution is not to withhold information entirely, but to intentionally provide it in ways that are readable for community members. 

If, as it says in its mission statement, Muhlenberg wishes to create students who are “equipped with ethical and civic values and prepared for lives of leadership and service,” it should become more transparent about its financial status, and do so in ways that are designed to help students, faculty and staff make informed decisions.

+ posts