Home Campus Voices Opinion: Discourse in Defeat

Opinion: Discourse in Defeat

Elections spark a reckoning with intolerance, echo chambers, and the need for open dialogue on an increasingly divided college campus.

547

In the immediate aftermath of the election, students, staff and faculty alike witnessed a wide range of reactions. While some rejoiced proudly, posting about their preferred candidate’s victory on social media, most of the stories I came across lamented the outcome, declaring that democracy had officially ended and cautioned against President-elect Donald Trump’s growing dictatorial tendencies.  Among many of the latter, a disturbing trend emerged.

Many were enraged that notwithstanding the myriad of demeaning comments Trump and his allies had made against women, against LGBTQ+ individuals, against people of color and against many other marginalized communities– despite all of those comments, a majority of the country had still decided to vote for him. Some people stated that they would no longer consider them friends and family if they chose to vote for Trump. It was also noted that while Trump supporters may not be bigots themselves, those supporters had decided that Trump’s behavior was not a dealbreaker. 

Accordingly, many declared that, “If u voted for Trump, I mean this in the most disrespectful way possible, I do not want anything to do with you.”

Unfortunately, this enmity towards Republicans and conservatives, more broadly, is a story that is all too familiar to Muhlenberg and many other colleges across the country. A 2019 study of students at the University of North Carolina found that nearly 68 percent of conservative students fear social repercussions for voicing their opinions. This isn’t a problem for right-leaning students alone; almost half of moderates and 24 percent of liberals were also censoring themselves in class out of fear of the negative consequences of speaking up. If colleges are supposed to be spaces for “reasoned and civil debate” and an “inclusive and diverse campus,” as our mission statement states, why do we remain hostile to diversity in our political preferences?

One argument I hear repeatedly that may explain those results points to an individual’s duty to be “intolerant of intolerance” by discriminating against those who would hurt others through their bigoted words and actions. While standing up for others is an undeniably noble aim, one must caution against completely disregarding those who would oppose them and inhabiting a bubble. While we readily talk about the dangers of echo chambers in our political science or media & communication classes, if we want to apply those same lessons to our lives, we must begin engaging with those who fundamentally disagree with our viewpoints. 

Whether that’s giving your Republican-leaning roommate another chance or hearing out your Trump-supporter uncle at Thanksgiving dinner, these interactions will be uncomfortable. Some individuals may be beyond your reach and unable to have a constructive conversation, however, it may fall on you to at least try and take that first step. If we truly believe in the strength and validity of our positions, challenging them by speaking to those who differ from us may be the first step in strengthening our arguments by finding faults in our own logic— maybe even swaying someone’s mind towards your position. 

In a campus voices piece last year that discussed tensions on campus arising from the conflict in the Middle East, I highlighted that it was likely not going to be “the last time we may find ourselves at odds with one another.” The truth is that over 76 million Americans voted for Trump. I met one of his voters at a polling station, and when I approached them to ask them about the election for The Weekly’s election day coverage, they said something that stood out to me: “I voted for Trump, so you probably don’t want to talk to me.” If we genuinely do want to move forward as a functional democratic society, we need to do a better job reaching out as journalists, as classmates and yes, sometimes even as friends and family.

+ posts

Kabir Burman '27 is an international student from India double majoring in media & communication and political science. He is constantly looking for new ways to bring you the stories that matter and feature different perspectives. If you can't find him in the newsroom, you'll find him playing the piano, taking a nap, or planning his next trip to NYC!