
Disclaimer: If you are a firm believer of Santa Claus I suggest you stop reading now, or else he’ll put you on the naughty list.
Has Thanksgiving happened yet? No. Are my social media feeds already filled with Christmas? Yeah, duh. For those who celebrate and enjoy or are just innocently scrolling through Instagram, the feeling that it’s already Christmas season is quite present. Interestingly enough, I’ve seen things beyond wish lists, decorating or ice skating on my feed. I’ve noticed some controversial, argument-inducing posts regarding Christmas’s most commercial, and perhaps loved figure: Santa Claus.
Now don’t worry, Santa hasn’t been caught in some Twitter scandal that’s left him out of commission this December. Where the controversy lies is actually within the households, and more specifically parents who celebrate Christmas. What they’re debating about is quite a bombshell: should they tell their kids Santa Claus is real, or that he’s not?
Now when I say this, I don’t mean that parents are figuring out how to finally tell their kids Santa isn’t real, I mean parents are deciding if they should ever tell their kid that he’s real, or if they should raise their kids from the start knowing that he’s fake. Personally, growing up in a Santa-believer house, if you will, this idea was originally quite shocking to me. Never telling your kids about the magic behind Santa? Sounds heartbreaking to me. Yet with each holiday season, I continue to see more and more parents take to social media to inform the public that they have decided not to do Santa for Christmas, and I cannot help but consider this argument.
On the one hand, telling your kid that Santa is real brings a type of magic to the holidays. The Santa tactic can motivate kids to act kind, knowing that he sees them when they’re sleeping and knows when they’re awake, as the song goes. Santa is also just a fantastical idea that brings intense excitement to kids. Believing in Santa makes many holiday activities much more exciting, like watching movies about him, or baking cookies and writing him a letter. There could also be a notion that believing in Santa is a great imaginative activity for kids that keeps their minds moving. Not to mention, while it is obviously fun for kids, it can be equally as fun for the parents, who get to tune into their own playful and imaginative selves, basking in nostalgia.
Yet on the other side of the argument, some parents argue the ethical standpoint of essentially lying to their kids about whether something is real when it actually isn’t. Many may feel uncomfortable telling their kid something that isn’t true and worry that their bond of trust could be broken when the truth is found out. With that being said, some parents also argue that the moment a kid realizes Santa isn’t real can crush them and their sense of imagination. Telling your kid Santa is real has become borderline problematic, according to some parents online. Many parents take to TikTok especially to tell others why they told their kids Santa isn’t real, which is why, in my opinion, we’ve seen so much more traction on Santa Claus and what to tell kids about him. With social media being a pivotal tool to voice opinions, it seems to have left even more parents at a loss for what they should do this holiday season.
Is there a right or wrong thing to do in this situation? Honestly, and not shockingly, no, at the end of the day, it is the parents’ decision to act how they want to regarding Santa Claus, and they don’t need to really back up their reasoning as to why. If Santa is canceled in their household, then so be it! Though, as a former firm Santa believer, I am partial to telling your kids he is real. Maybe I’m controversial! Or maybe I’m just whimsical, who knows! What I do know is that there is nothing like a little extra imaginative magic to make the special season a bit more special, as Hallmark-y as it sounds. I’d argue, too, that you don’t always have to outrightly tell your kid Santa isn’t real. In fact, most kids when they hit a certain age will realize it themselves, and that’s okay. Sometimes the discovery of them figuring it out is all part of the learning and growing process, an essential lesson that kids have to learn eventually. Whatever the case may be, it would be hard to convince me Santa Claus is canceled, or that he should be. Let the mythical man live! He’s brought that Christmas spirit for long enough, and personally I think he should keep it going, at least he will in my future household.
Emily Nally ‘27 is an English and Creative Writing major with a Women and Gender Studies minor. She is editor of the Campus Voices section and is so excited to be a part of such an immersive organization on campus. Outside of the Weekly, you can find Emily rereading “Little Women,” binge watching “Gilmore Girls,” or being really cool practicing her flute and guitar.


















