Home Campus Voices I joined a cult and I think I get the hype

I joined a cult and I think I get the hype

1903
Megan Hansen '26 attended Donald Trump's rally at the PPL Center in Allentown, Pa. and shares takeaways. Photo by Megan Hansen '26.
Megan Hansen '26 attended Donald Trump's rally at the PPL Center in Allentown, Pa. and shares takeaways. Photo by Megan Hansen '26.

Our campus is prone to chronic discourse about what students refer to as “the Muhlenbubble”: the scope of interaction amongst students and its general limitation to Muhlenberg culture. Staying within the confines of the Muhlenbubble entails ignorance to the community around us, the function of social scenes which differ from that of a small liberal arts school and opinions that stray from our predominant demographic. To stay within the Muhlenbubble is to stay in one’s own lane. Simply speaking, the concept of the Muhlenbubble is a quirky way of speaking about confirmation bias. 

I would like to think that my occasional trips to the open fields of Pennsylvania as a girl from New York makes me a rare exception to a recurring case that creeps up on a large percentage of our student body. However, confirmation bias is unavoidable to a generation that is voting for the first time in the most politically polarized environment our country has faced. I remember scrolling through my classmates’ Instagram stories during the prime time of social media activism and unfollowing those who posted things that seemed absurd to me. I would be so viscerally angered that someone who grew up just down the block from me would have the capability to believe such outlandish thoughts (beliefs that were not reflective of mine). It is evident to me now that my Instagram feed, friend group and general social circle are direct results of confirmation bias. 

I think there is some validity to such a bias, though, in many situations. A lot of political differences in the 2024 election stem from prejudices, morals and general opinions on human rights cases. It is hard not to equate modern-day Republicanism to bigotry given some of the stances the party has taken on abortion, border control, gun safety, transgender rights, etc. Especially when it comes to MAGA Republicans, it is often hard to sympathize with or even understand “the other side”. 

Perhaps it is a newfound sense of collegiate maturity as I enter my third year at Muhlenberg, or the self-awareness I possess regarding the lack of effort I put into trying to view things from other standpoints; but when I heard that Presidential Candidate Donald J. Trump would be holding a rally just four minutes away from Muhlenberg’s campus, I had the sudden impulse to attend. I have always wondered how Trump, who I view as an elderly chauvinist with little to no political knowledge, has been able to captivate masses. This man has procured a cult-like following, and I must try to understand why. I had to burst my bubble. I had to join the cult.

So last Tuesday, I got on the bus with a fellow Weekly reporter and hauled myself over to the PPL Center, ready to see just what Trump says that makes him so likable to his admirers as a person with a deep preestablished detestment for him. I arrived to a line that spanned blocks upon blocks to enter the event. We stood on it for upwards of four hours. Along it, vendors sold merchandise with unfortunately catchy phrases on it, music was being played, food was being passed down, as was the wave, chants were started and even children joined in Halloween costumes. It was like joining a giant conga line at a family reception. 

Everyone was very friendly with the caveat that they believed we were a part of the double entendre of a political party present on the line. People did not shy away from getting to know their fellow rallygoers, as I eavesdropped on conversations about friends and work– chatting was not exclusive to politics. Some women in front of us even asked questions about college life and seemed genuinely interested in what we had to say. They all seemed genuinely happy to be there. The only time I had ever felt any sort of excitement being radiated from a crowd akin to this was when I was waiting in line at The Eras Tour; you would think we were in line to see a superstar given the sheer level of elation. If I was a part of the MAGA cohort, I honestly think I would have had the time of my life. 

What I found at the rally, and what must be one of the more attractive aspects of the Trump lovers cult that has developed across the country, is a community full of like-minded people validating each other’s beliefs and celebrating what brings them together— another extreme case of confirmation bias. I had entered a completely new but indirectly parallel social sphere: the “MAGAbubble”. Trump himself, at this point in his political career, might have less to do with the devotion than I had assumed going into the event. At the very least, I anticipated him to be a captivating public speaker who knows how to get a crowd fired up, but the attendees seemed just as excited to be there as to hear what he had to say. In fact, Trump was less than impressive, as I would actively watch him get distracted in the middle of sentences and jump from point to point with no cohesivity and very little logic. What I think Trump really does for these people is give them a forum to say what they are thinking but can not say out loud: beliefs rooted in hatred, discomfort or unfamiliarity. 

Now, they attend these rallies essentially to preach to a choir. Here, they are not made to feel like bad people for their beliefs; so to them, Trump is inclusive in a very different way. We overheard multiple conversations mocking his presidential opponent Kamala Harris and claiming she used sexual advances to acquire her position, saw signs that said “burn the homos” and were even passed a piece of paper with a plan to riot and stage a coup if Trump loses written out in full detail on both sides in small font. Even those who attended the rally who do not possess such extreme views are able to feel like it is okay that they do not prioritize equity when casting their vote. If Trump allows people to say what they are thinking to the extent that people can openly spew radical standpoints, he will certainly protect and validate the average middle-class citizens that have been misled to believe that voting for Trump will generally benefit them even if it is at the expense of others (though many have also been misled to believe that there is no imminent threat to others). 

That being said, if there is one thing I learned from attending the rally, it’s that ignorance truly is bliss. The comfort provided by the confirmation bias that exists within the “MAGAbubble” is certainly attractive. The need to find a likeness with others is only human, which is why we see large communal fanbases for artists like Taylor Swift. Problems arise though, when we equate political figures to these celebrities and icons. To vehemently support a candidate is understandable, as our future lies in their hands. But what I found at the rally is that many people forget that politicians exist as public servants elected to reflect the greater population of a progressing country. Although I am proud of myself for trying to understand where these voters are coming from, I hold steadfast in my belief that their support for Trump is rooted in exactly that: ignorance. As I previously stated, the validity I find in being unable to sympathize with those belonging to a differing political party is that some things are too morally contentious to overlook. After trying to join the cult, I have ultimately decided that it doesn’t matter how many times you dance to “Y.M.C.A.” or how much free stuff you offer me, I will never find community with those who not only disagree with me morally, but in my eyes, actively threaten or overlook the safety and well being of fellow Americans.

+ posts

Megan ‘26 is a Theater Studies and English Literature double major with a minor in Film Studies. She is extremely grateful to have worked with the talented and passionate students on the Weekly staff since her first year. When she isn’t working in the production room, you can find her directing shows on campus, writing sketch comedy, leading the Muhlenberg Film Association, or enjoying a night with her friends.