Home Sports What it means to be a captain

What it means to be a captain

The ins and outs of leadership courtesy of Muhlenberg student-athletes

1919
Photo by Kira Bretsky '27.
Photo by Kira Bretsky '27.

“Attitude reflects leadership.” “Leadership is not a position, but an action and example.” “Leaders stare adversity in the face and challenge it for others.” These are just a few of the endless list of sayings about or describing leadership in a general sense. Sure, they may be argued or questioned, but either way, leaders exist everywhere in a variety of forms, and whether they are recognized as such is hardly the point. Leaders do what they must regardless of the benefit to themselves, and refuse to be content with anything different.

At Muhlenberg College, numerous student-athletes have come through one or more of the institution’s athletic programs and have contributed to the success and development of Muhlenberg athletics in multiple ways. Each of those student-athletes were leaders in their own right, and on top of that, few were selected to be designated as team captains over their time at ‘Berg. Having spoken to several Muhlenberg captains of the 2024-25 competitive year, one thing is clear: Leadership is not set in stone, and it never will be. The first and most important steps to leadership seem to be adaptability and vulnerability amongst a team throughout a journey to winning a Centennial Conference or National championship, or whatever the ultimate goal may be.

Infielder Kaya Mahy ‘25, a leader on the Muhlenberg softball team, one which does not directly appoint captains, mentioned something along the same lines: “The most valuable lesson I have learned from being a leader is that there is no right or wrong way to be one. No one should feel they need to fit a certain description of a leader and change themselves. Being a leader comes in many formats– quietly encouraging and supporting teammates, leading by example and setting a good standard of how to work hard or pushing teammates to be the best versions of themselves with tough love. All of these are ways to lead and every team needs all kinds of leaders to be successful.” 

More practically, leadership may take the form of being an example for teammates, coaches or friends and maintaining the standard of a program on and off the field, court or course. Finding ways to embody a team’s culture and values has been shown to make a difference.

“Being a captain means you’ve gained the trust of your teammates and coaching staff to lead your team into battle,” said Kevin Adams ‘25, midfielder for the Muhlenberg men’s soccer team. “A captain sets the tone for the rest of the team, addresses any underlying issues that may be affecting the team and holds the entire team accountable for their actions. Through your everyday actions and attitude, a captain is expected to lead by example and provide reason to believe in a bigger goal than an individual.”

Leader within the Muhlenberg men’s wrestling team Joey Lamparelli ‘25 echoed a similar message, “For me, being a captain is more than just holding a title—it’s about setting the tone for my team every day. Leadership isn’t limited to leading warm-ups or giving speeches; it’s about holding myself accountable so that my teammates follow. One of the most important lessons I’ve learned as a leader in wrestling is that actions speak louder than words. I can’t expect my teammates to push themselves if I’m not willing to do the same.” Exemplifying the desired effort will never run out of steam. “Show, don’t tell,” is a phrase that has and will continue to persevere in the vernacular.

“To me, being a captain means advocating for your team in a way that stems from love,” – Paola Navarro ’25

Leadership may also involve building and nurturing close, empathic relationships between teammates or coaches. Although it is easy to recognize athletic achievement and prowess, those same student-athletes are human too and deserve the proper respect a healthy connection garners. “To me, being a captain means advocating for your team in a way that stems from love,” commented Paola Navarro ‘25, one of three captains of the Muhlenberg women’s track and field team. “I am able to individually and cohesively support my teammates in a way that is special to our relationships. It allows me to appreciate their growth and dedication to the team while being able to additionally voice their feedback.”

Furthermore, Muhlenberg women’s basketball guard Rachel Saxton ‘25 added, “The most valuable thing I have learned from my experiences of being a captain is that it’s not just about giving orders or being the one to make the decision. It’s really about serving others and lifting their spirits so they can be the best for themselves but also the best for their team! It’s taught me to support, encourage and protect my teammates while also learning the skills of accountability and adaptability.” Win or loss, there is always space to be the one in the room who others look to for guidance, and a leader is one who can see through their joy or pain to be there for others.

As winter sports come to a close and spring sports ramp up, a new round of teams will simultaneously begin and end their journey toward glory. Beneath those names and numbers lie leaders attempting to create a standard of consistent, high-level performance in all areas. Some may stand out and others may be more reserved, but the end goal remains the same: to guide a team on the path to victory. Infielder Kaitlyn Buurman ‘25 of Muhlenberg softball mentions, “Being a captain means being able to see your teammates, hear your teammates and work toward creating a culture of excellence on and off the field through one’s leadership efforts.  A leader is someone who does the right thing when no one is watching.” Then, when the lights eventually turn on, the Mules come to win.

+ posts

Evan is a media and communication major minoring in creative writing and journalism with a passion for sports writing as well as soccer, being outdoors and spending time with close friends and family. He is eager to continue learning about and tinkering with writing while learning from the talented Weekly staff.