The “Tush Push” or “Brotherly Shove” is one of, if not the most criticized plays in all of football. The main criticism is that when the Philadelphia Eagles run it, their offensive linemen are offside or starting before the ball is snapped. Yet, these same critiques magically vanish when any other team runs the play. The play has gotten so much heat that there was a vote to ban it, but the vote failed with only twenty-two teams voting to ban the Tush Push, two teams short of getting the play banned. Rather than coming at this play from an emotional perspective, let’s view it through from a logical standpoint
The play has gotten so much heat that there was a vote to ban it, but the vote failed with only twenty-two teams voting to ban the Tush Push while needing twenty-four votes to get the play banned. Rather than coming at this play from an emotional perspective, let’s view it through from a logical standpoint.
In 2013, the National Football League (NFL) changed similar rules to ban defensive players from overloading gaps in the line of scrimmage to block kicks to help ensure player safety. I get that football is a naturally dangerous sport with all the tackles and hits taken, but to say that the offense can do something but the defense can’t for player safety is disingenuous. It gives the impression that the NFL is willing to make plays when it protects the offense, but not the defense, because the Tush Push and overload are fundamentally the same play. Offensively, the Tush Push is overloading the middle to get one or two yards, while defensively, the overload is to get one or two yards behind the line of scrimmage to block a kick. This rule was further cemented with a 2017 rule change, which prevented players from leaping over the line of scrimmage for player safety; a change proposed by the Eagles of all teams. At the time, there was a similar outcry: how can we officiate people jumping over the line of scrimmage? The difference is that when defenders were being criticized, the NFL changed the rules in the name of player safety but when the offense gets condemned the vote fails.
These concerns are not limited to commentators and spectators, people on the ground and in the game also have concerns. Atlanta Falcons’ Head Coach Raheem Morris said in an interview on ESPN’s “Get Up,” “There’s just no other play in our game where you can absolutely get behind somebody and push them, I never really understood it, why that was legal. So, I’ve definitely been one of those guys voting against that.” That criticism is completely logical, there is no other play in football that requires a push from behind the line of scrimmage to help the offense gain yards. Furthermore, having a running back push from behind overloads the gaps created by the offensive line– a violation of the 2013 rule change. Another potential penalty is a “chop block” or two every time the play gets run. A chop block is when two blockers engage on one defender with one block above the waist and another block low, taking the defender off his feet. For the Tush Push to work, the offensive line goes low to the ground and then the quarterback and running back both push for yardage; that combo means the first block is low and then a high-level engagement with defenders could be a chop block. That laundry list of potential penalties on this one play is bad, but it isn’t the worst potential criticism.
“There’s just no other play in our game where you can absolutely get behind somebody and push them, I never really understood it, why that was legal. So, I’ve definitely been one of those guys voting against that.” – Atlanta Falcons head coach Raheem Morris
The Indianapolis Colts voted to ban the Tush Push– which is the greatest case in favor of banning it. The Tush Push was popularized by the Philadelphia Eagles in 2022 under Offensive Coordinator Shane Steichen who then left to become the Colts’ head coach for the 2023-2024 season. Despite hiring the offensive coordinator who made it popular, the Colts rarely run the Tush Push. That means the Colts have a coach who has inside knowledge of how to run the play and still decided they don’t want it in the league. But for now, the Eagles and all other teams in the NFL are allowed to use the Tush Push.


















