One game came down to a field goal as time expired. The next resulted in a 42-point lead before halftime. For the Muhlenberg football team, both victories reflected the same approach: consistent preparation throughout the week and a determination to keep its Centennial Conference (CC) championship ambitions alive.
The Mules erased a 14-point fourth-quarter deficit to defeat nationally ranked Franklin & Marshall (F&M) 31-28 on Oct. 10, then overwhelmed McDaniel 49-7 on Oct. 17. The consecutive CC victories improved Muhlenberg to 4-2 overall and 2-1 in conference play.
For running back Amari Dunn ‘27, beating F&M carried a lot of significance after last season’s narrow loss to the Diplomats. “It’s a great feeling winning against the defending conference champions, especially [after] losing a close one last year to them,” Dunn said. “Our backs were against the wall, and we dug deep to pull it off.”
Against an undefeated F&M team ranked No. 21 amongst Division III teams by the American Football Coaches Association, Muhlenberg needed contributions from every player. Jahmir Brown ‘30 answered the Diplomats’ first touchdown with a 100-yard kickoff return, tying the school record. Caleb Pasols ‘29 later turned a pass from quarterback Luke Spang ‘28 into a 63-yard touchdown, breaking several tackles along the way.
Still, the Mules entered the fourth quarter trailing 28-14. An eight-yard touchdown reception by Pasols cut the deficit, although the extra point failed. After the defense forced a three-and-out, Muhlenberg drove 69 yards, finishing with a seven-yard touchdown run from Dunn. Chris Holland ‘28 caught the ensuing two-point conversion to tie the score with 7:15 remaining.
Dunn finished with a career-high 157 rushing yards on 33 carries against a defense that entered the game ranked No. 11 nationally against the run. A late defensive stop and an 18-yard punt return from Tommy Donnelly ‘27 gave Muhlenberg possession at the F&M 33. The offense moved into position for a 29-yard field goal from Nicholas D’Amico ‘27 with three seconds left.
“By the time I ran out there with three seconds left, the offense and defense had already done the hard work,” D’Amico said. “F&M called a timeout to try to ice me, but I was calm and confident in our process.” With John Roeder ‘27 snapping and Brandon Booker ‘28 holding, D’Amico delivered the winning kick as time expired. “Getting lifted by my teammates is something I’ll never forget,” he said.
The following game offered considerably less suspense with Muhlenberg scoring 42 first-half points against McDaniel, beginning with touchdown passes of 19 and nine yards from Spang to Holland. Holland finished with career highs of four receptions and 52 receiving yards. His two touchdowns matched his career total entering the game.
The defense repeatedly created opportunities for success. Ben Girard ‘28 recovered a fumble at the McDaniel 14-yard line, setting up JR Walley’s ‘28 six-yard touchdown run. Linebacker CJ Newman ‘27 added an interception, while a botched McDaniel punt resulted in a safety. Walley also threw a 20-yard touchdown pass to Aidan Mack G‘27 on a trick play, and Spang connected with Donnelly for another score before halftime.
Muhlenberg held McDaniel to just 15 yards of total offense and negative 43 rushing yards. Girard recorded two sacks, producing losses of 16 and 13 yards. Despite the contrasting scores, Girard said the team’s preparation remained consistent. “The team doesn’t prepare differently for different teams; the process stays the same, which is super important,” he said.
With the outcome secure, more players had opportunities to contribute. Quarterback Nicholas Humpf ‘28 found Danny Cullen ‘27 for a 30-yard touchdown in the second half, marking Humpf’s first collegiate passing touchdown and Cullen’s first receiving touchdown.
Dunn singled out that moment as a highlight, pointing to the work both players put in on and off the field. “Seeing Daniel Cullen touchdown thrown by Nick Humpf is great to see because those guys work very hard on the field and off the field, so seeing that play out was pretty cool,” he said.
Both victories moved Muhlenberg into a tie for third in the conference alongside F&M and Dickinson, with a matchup against conference co-leader Carnegie Mellon ahead. For D’Amico, the objectives remain clear. “We want to win out, compete for a Centennial Conference title, and get back to the [National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA)] tournament.”
The Mules head to Pittsburgh this week to face Carnegie Mellon University on Oct. 24 to continue their quest toward the CC Championship.


















