
The Muhlenberg men’s soccer team had an impressive run in the Centennial Conference (CC) playoffs, overcoming formidable rivals and securing a place in the NCAA tournament. The Mules (12-3-6) demonstrated their championship potential with solid performances and a resilient team spirit, marking another chapter in the program’s legacy.
The third-seeded Mules began their playoff journey with a narrow 1-0 victory over McDaniel, advancing them to the semifinal against Franklin & Marshall (F&M) for the third consecutive year. Thomas Schreiber ‘28 scored the game’s only goal, capitalizing on a blocked clearing attempt from the McDaniel goalie. The Mules’ defense, led by goalkeeper Ben Mulford ‘26, secured their fourth straight shutout, allowing the team to move forward.
In the semifinal, Muhlenberg faced 19th-ranked F&M and won 2-1, marking the third straight year they defeated the Diplomats in the CC semifinals on the road. The Mules struck early with Sim Dorsey ‘26 heading in a throw-in from Sam Roberts ‘27, followed by a goal from Gabe Blikshteyn ‘27, assisted by Dorsey. Despite F&M’s intense offense, Mulford’s nine saves, including some in high-pressure situations, helped Muhlenberg maintain the lead.
Reflecting on the match, Mulford shared, “The most memorable part of the season thus far has to be beating [F&M] for the third straight year in the semi-finals of the Centennial Conference tournament on the road. That feeling never gets old. What stands out is the togetherness of our team and the standard that we have set over the last few years no matter the flow of the match, we will stick together, persevere and come out victorious. The semi-final games against F&M epitomize this.”
The championship game saw Muhlenberg face top-seeded Johns Hopkins. In a hard-fought battle that ended in a 1-1 draw after regular time and overtime, the Mules narrowly missed the title in a 5-3 shootout loss. After a scoreless first half, Johns Hopkins took a 1-0 lead, but Muhlenberg rallied when Blikshteyn drew a crucial foul, setting up a free kick by Mack Metcalf ‘28. Roberts’ final tap-in tied the game late in regulation. A blast by Jake Mendelson ‘25 nearly gave Muhlenberg the lead, hitting the crossbar with just minutes remaining. In the penalty shootout, Johns Hopkins prevailed, claiming their second consecutive CC title.
“The outcomes that we have seen not only this year but the three previous years as well, regarding the postseason of any stature (Centennial or ECAC) reflects the team and program’s standards.” – Evan Schlotterbeck ’25
After the loss, Dorsey highlighted the team’s resolve, stating, “At this point, after losing a tough final to Johns Hopkins, our biggest goal as a team is to continue to earn another day. This has been our motto for the last week as we have made our playoff run; it has all been about fighting on the pitch together to give ourselves a chance to play one more day, as nothing is guaranteed now. We’ve got a week to prepare now for the NCAA tournament, and we intend to go to Amherst and get two victories and cement our legacy within the Muhlenberg men’s soccer program.”
The Mules’ journey through the playoffs highlighted the team’s resilience, with leaders reflecting on the season’s most memorable moments and their hopes for the NCAA Tournament. Captain Evan Schlotterbeck ‘25 underscored the high standards set by the program, saying, “The outcomes that we have seen not only this year but the three previous years as well, regarding the postseason of any stature (Centennial or Eastern College Athletic Conference) reflects the team and program’s standards. We do not show up on Aug. 18 to go through the motions– to cruise through a season. We arrive having already put in tons of work and of the mentality that we are here to win championships.”
Schlotterbeck also encouraged younger players, adding, “I offer this advice. Cherish not only the wins and positive moments but the whole experience of being a part of Muhlenberg men’s soccer. The losses, the preseasons, the team meetings, and even the fitness workouts early in the morning. I love every part of this journey, and I understand that you are now responsible for maintaining and elevating the championship-caliber standard. The expectation is that Muhlenberg will fight for championships every year, and that is not easy, but I know the younger players are ready to carry that weight. I am unbelievably proud to have been a part of such a great group and program.”
Muhlenberg earned a place in the NCAA tournament with a strong 12-3-6 record and an impressive playoff performance. The Mules’ first-round match against Stevens is on Nov. 16 in Amherst, Mass. As the team prepares for this new stage, it will carry with it the experiences, lessons, and resilience from a season that saw it overcome numerous challenges and uphold Muhlenberg’s reputation for championship-level play.
Whether or not the Mules bring home the NCAA title, their season is a testament to their determination, skill and unity. The team’s playoff journey, filled with dramatic goals, tense defenses and unforgettable moments, has solidified Muhlenberg men’s soccer as a force to be reckoned with, both in the Centennial Conference and beyond.

















