
When asked what their biggest concerns were this coming election cycle, voters have increasingly selected the topic of immigration. The Republican candidate, Donald Trump, has made it one of his key issues and prioritized it as a critique against the current Biden-Harris administration. With him dedicating time at almost every campaign stop to highlight border issues and his plans to fix them should he win the election, Kamala Harris has become a target. Labels such as “border czar” are being widely used by the GOP to attack her record.
While it is crucial to note that under Biden, Harris was not charged with formulating or implementing policy at the border; she was, in fact, tasked with formulating a diplomatic assignment to reduce the incentives that cause migrants to leave. Nevertheless, with immigration continuing to be a dominant issue at the polls, it may be helpful to better understand the various perspectives candidates present. Whether that’s policies advocating deportation and militarization or humanitarian approaches addressing migration’s root causes, their stances on immigration reflect each of the candidate’s broader visions for America’s future.
The Democratic Party (Harris-Walz):
Despite her role in the administration’s response being contested, immigration remains one of Harris’s biggest weaknesses. Herein, her policies have undergone a notable shift with proposals like:
- Balancing Security: She supports increased funding for border staff and technology while emphasizing strategic rather than expansive security measures.
- Addressing Root Causes of Migration: Plans to address increased immigration by providing support for economic stability and security in Central America.
- Bringing back the Bi-Partisan Border Deal: Would ask Congress to authorize increased funding for border agents, detention facilities, and fentanyl detection technology.
The Republican Party (Trump-Vance)
Although he has been reported to have lobbied for the failure of the aforementioned border deal, if elected, he hopes to implement a historically restrictive US immigration agenda starting in 2025:
- Strict Border Security: He has prioritized completing the border wall and deploying American military forces to the border.
- Mass Deportation Plan: Envisions a large-scale deportation effort targeting undocumented immigrants currently residing in the U.S.
- Deporting student protestors: Deporting and revoking the visas of foreign students who have participated in pro-Palestinian/anti-Israel protests by “proactively send[ing] ICE.”
The Green Party (Stein-Ware)
The Green party continues to prioritize humanitarian and environmental factors in its immigration policy with proposals such as:
- Humanitarian Focus: Opposes militarized borders and border walls, advocating for humane treatment and rights for immigrants.
- Root Causes of Migration: Emphasizes calls for addressing climate change and contributing U.S. foreign policies to mitigate migration pressures.
- Opposition to Military Intervention: Seeks to end U.S. military actions and sanctions contributing to global instability and migration flows.
The Libertarian Party (Oliver-Maat)
Similar to their approach on the economy, Libertarians advocate for minimal government intervention and allowing the market to regulate itself through initiatives such as:
- Minimal Government Intervention: Opposes the border wall and government land seizure via eminent domain for border security.
- Ending the War on Drugs: Advocates for ending the War on Drugs, which they believe fuels border violence and crime.
- Free-Market Immigration Approach: Supports fewer immigration restrictions, allowing migrants to seek labor opportunities with minimal government regulation.
With less than a week left until election day, voters are faced with a range of immigration policies that could dramatically shape the nation’s approach to border security, humanitarian aid and foreign relations. While Trump’s policies emphasize enforcement and strict deportation measures, Harris and the Democrats propose an approach that includes security measures alongside legal pathways for migrants. Meanwhile, the Green and Libertarian parties advocate for reducing government intervention in different ways—whether through humanitarian programs or free-market solutions.
To that end, the outcome of this election will not only determine approaches to border security and humanitarian concerns but also broader values that shape the nation’s identity. America, stands at a crossroads where these foundational values are once again central to the conversation. With many immigrants fleeing their homes due to worsening economic conditions and authoritarian governments, the right to vote has never been more of a privilege. Understanding the complex issues on the ballot allows voters to engage thoughtfully in shaping the nation’s future. To that end, the team at BergVotes hopes this series has empowered readers to make an informed choice, embracing the democratic privilege of voting as they cast their ballots on Nov. 5.
Kabir Burman '27 is an international student from India double majoring in media & communication and political science. He is constantly looking for new ways to bring you the stories that matter and feature different perspectives. If you can't find him in the newsroom, you'll find him playing the piano, taking a nap, or planning his next trip to NYC!


















