Home News Faculty boycott in response to administrative decisions halts faculty meeting

Faculty boycott in response to administrative decisions halts faculty meeting

3/20 faculty meeting failed to reach quorum, alternative meeting led by the AAUP.

2282
Photo by Maddie Ciliento '25

Muhlenberg College faculty meetings follow Robert’s Rules of Order– a guide on the rules and regulations of parliamentary procedure. One such rule is the required number of people present for a meeting, or the “quorum.” The quorum for Muhlenberg faculty meetings is 78 voting faculty members– one more than half of all faculty at Muhlenberg. On Friday, March 20, the quorum that is typically easily surpassed fell nine people short which meant the faculty meeting could not begin. Provost Laura Furge waited until approximately 2:23 p.m., almost ten minutes after the actual start time, in hopes that more faculty would join the meeting to meet the minimum required. When it became clear that a faculty meeting would not be able to commence, faculty asked if there could instead be a conversation with President Kathleen Harring. Harring agreed, and Furge made it clear that this would not qualify as a faculty meeting. Chip Gruen, chair of the Academic Policy Committee, then said that he was “a little disappointed we don’t have the numbers here to do our business.” 

I was then asked by a professor to leave the meeting.

On the Monday prior to the faculty meeting, Muhlenberg’s chapter of American Association of University Professors (AAUP) posted a message on BergConnect explaining that faculty were planning to boycott the meeting: “In a letter sent to the Board published in The Weekly, we stated that unless tenure decisions were communicated on Monday, March 16 and a member of the Board was scheduled to speak with faculty at the meeting today, we would boycott. Therefore, because our requests were not met, we are boycotting today’s faculty meeting.”

An anonymous faculty member shared the details of the conversation that occurred between the faculty and Harring. “Our colleagues had just been tenured, so she gave the timeline for the process that led to them eventually being tenured on Thursday. She also referred back to the [Board of] Trustees’ initial request to delay reviewing those tenure cases until they had additional information from the College. The president shared that she and the provost had provided the information that the trustees were looking for.”

After the update, the conversation transitioned into a Q&A session with faculty about the future of the College. “Aside from the tenure issue, moving forward, we’ve been warned that a group of non-tenured faculty are in danger of receiving letters of non-reappointment,” said the anonymous faculty member. “And there’s disagreement about how necessary those cuts are going to be, there’s disagreement about the best way to get the College out of the deficit that it’s facing.”

The faculty member said there was a lot of discussion about the reluctance of the Board of Trustees to meet with the full faculty. “We did not get a clear answer to that question,” they said. 

They shared that they “didn’t walk away from that meeting feeling like [they] had a really good understanding of why the Board [of Trustees] is not interested in meeting with the faculty as a whole.”

Across the campus in a conference room in Fahy Commons, roughly 50 faculty members attended an alternative meeting hosted by the AAUP. The meeting was focused on discussion and mobilization for the next steps of the AAUP regarding the recent delay in tenure and subsequent refusal of the board to meet with the faculty as a whole. 

Ben Carter, professor of anthropology & sociology and member of the steering committee for Muhlenberg’s AAUP, shared his perspectives on the faculty boycott and the tensions that led to the faculty mobilization. He described the delay from the Board of Trustees in awarding tenure to four faculty members as the “proverbial straw that broke the camel’s back.” Although tenure eventually was awarded, Carter stated that “the camel’s back has not been fixed yet.”

This is because, he continued, the issue of tenure is “not the only straw. Many of those other straws are also about communication. It’s not just one issue, but the primary issue is about having some sort of ability to have discussions.” 

Carter shared that although granting the faculty tenure was one of  AAUP’s requests, they also asked that a member of the Board of Trustees attend the faculty meeting on March 20 to explain the decision making process for both delaying and ultimately granting tenure.

Carter hopes that the boycott “sends a clear message [to administration] that greater transparency, greater clarity, is needed, and that there’s a great deal of frustration about that.”

Right now, there is no one quick-fix solution to the end of the faculty boycott. Carter stated, “There are issues of transparency and clarity and at this point, I can’t give you a clear answer of what needs to happen. I think there needs to be some trust reestablished between the Board and the faculty, and I don’t know what that looks like and that  needs to be determined through interaction. So if we don’t have that interaction, it’s pretty hard to know exactly what the solution is.”

Regarding what he wants the students to know, Carter shared that for him, “it is about education. It is about students, and what this institution is or isn’t. I hope students recognize that faculty are here for the students, and so are the folks on AAUP. Sometimes our conversations are about what’s best for the faculty involved, but the principle behind that is that we’re here for education. As some of my colleagues like to say, ‘faculty working conditions are student learning conditions.’”He continued, stating, “I’m not here for faculty. The faculty are great, but I’m here for education. A threat, unintended or otherwise, to something like tenure, undermines that education. This concern with tenure isn’t about protecting jobs, it’s about protecting the freedom to teach what our scholarship suggests is best and what helps students see the world in fundamentally new ways.”

+ posts

Amy Swartz ‘26 is an English & Creative Writing and Political Science double major. She has been part of The Weekly since her freshman year, and is thrilled to be Editor in Chief! Outside of the Weekly, you can always find her reading a new book, crafting, or rewatching an episode of her favorite sitcoms!