Within academia, the widespread use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) raises substantial concerns for intellectual development and academic integrity, while simultaneously opening doors for innovation. Muhlenberg professors across different disciplines and departments shared their perspectives on AI in the classroom, as well as how they implement or restrict AI in their curriculum.
Eduardo Olid Guerrero, professor of Spanish, is a faculty chair for the College Committee for Technology and Digital Learning, which is working to create guidelines for professors to base their course policies. “The guidelines describe four levels of [AI] use (prohibited, allowed with prior permission, allowed with acknowledgment or freely permitted), which instructors can apply to a whole course or to individual assignments.” The guidelines recommend that every syllabus explicitly states its AI policy and the reasoning behind it, as well as disclosure and citation, AI literacy and detection software.
Due to the addition of AI features to many popular academic tools, like Google Platforms, Grammarly and Quizlet, it is necessary for professors to define what they consider to be AI usage. According to Brett Fadem, professor of physics, “By ‘using AI,’ I mean any use of a generative AI tool to produce, check or explain work. How much is permitted depends on the setting, and falls into three tiers. On exams and during class, AI is not permitted. On homework, it is permitted after a student has made a good-faith effort, when it serves as a tutor. For some tasks, it is actively encouraged. Coding is the clearest example of the last tier. In my judgment, AI’s spatial reasoning is still limited, but its ability to generate powerful computer code is impressive, so I direct its use toward what it does well.”
Fadem is also a strong advocate of AI assisted workflows, and has found it to be useful for Canvas organization and generating course materials. “Grading is where AI has helped most. Grading has always taken me a long time, and I tend to fall behind. My AI-assisted workflows have shortened the time it takes me to respond to student submissions, and they provide a level of detailed feedback I would struggle to match on my own. I protect student privacy by anonymizing submissions before AI sees them and by using the College’s own AI account for work involving student data. I review the AI’s feedback, and I make the final grading decisions myself.”
Youngsun Jang, assistant professor of computer science (CS), generally encourages students in his upper-level courses to use AI tools. “Especially in Software Engineering and Web Software Development, students can use AI to develop real software projects. These projects can also become part of their portfolios when they apply for jobs.” He believes that it will be difficult for CS and data science students to find jobs without a basic threshold of AI knowledge and skills.
Jang continued, “In my Software Engineering course, I actively encourage students to use AI for coding. I want them to spend more time on requirements, design and problem-solving. However, students must understand the code they submit. During project demos and presentations, I ask students to explain their code through code walkthroughs. If they cannot explain their code, they lose points.”
A popular topic of conversation surrounding AI is its ability to serve as a substitute for critical thinking and literacy. Tad Robinson, professor and chair of philosophy, strictly prohibits the use of AI in his courses for this reason, taking steps to design assignments in which there is friction in the process of using AI. “As a teacher, my goal is to help students develop a specific set of intellectual skills and habits of mind, and I don’t think AI serves these goals. In fact, I think in at least many cases it straightforwardly subverts them. To be clear, I think [Large Language Models (LLMs)] are valuable tools for many different tasks, BUT not for what I am trying to teach. I don’t use AI for grading or for any course mechanics.”
David Tafler, professor of media & communication and film studies, currently teaches a first-year seminar devoted to the representation and ramifications of AI. His goal as a professor is to spin the topic in a way that can encourage critical and analytic skills through writing. “The seminar themes work as a catalyst. Artificial Intelligence challenges the development of those intellectual skills. Therefore, the students enrolled in THIS seminar with AI as its theme must tackle the very meaning of thinking analytically and critically on a metalevel– engaging in a process while concurrently deconstructing it.”
As AI advances every day, professors must continuously find ways to adjust their methods and policies to fit students’ best interests. Academia is being forcibly shifted, so it is integral that institutions, including Muhlenberg, find a balance in their compliance with and resistance against it.


















