Home Campus Voices OPINION: The flop of Taylor Swift?

OPINION: The flop of Taylor Swift?

Written by a fan of Taylor Swift.

1742
Photo from @taylorswift on Instagram.

If you’ve been a consistent reader of mine, you probably know that I’ve written a few articles about Taylor Swift and pop culture in general. Knowing that, it’s safe to say that writing this article pains me, but it’s been weighing on my mind. After the recent Taylor Swift album, and just news of her in general, my love of her artistry has dwindled. And sure, yes, I know there are a lot more important things to talk about than Taylor Swift, but bear with me. As a former hardcore defender of Swift, I fear I have little left to defend, and I feel inclined to talk about what I see as the consistent fall of her and her music. 

Now, I still listen to Swift’s music somewhat consistently– I mean I love almost (almost) all of her albums and they always end up on at least one of my many playlists. I also despise the more unnecessary hate she gets, which is usually rooted in misogyny– comments on how her body looks, or how many guys she’s dated and all the stupid shit. I don’t see the point in picking apart every little thing about an objectively successful woman, especially when those little things are rooted in bigotry and hate for women. Like, get a life if you still cry about seeing Swift on your TV for football games. 

With that all being said, though, I still cannot help but feel recently disappointed by her. For starters, in a musical sense, her most recent album, “The Life of a Showgirl,”  in my opinion, lacked in many areas. I know some diehard Swifties will defend this album, but to me, pointing out where it flopped is important for a fan to do to Swift, and any artist they enjoy. And yes, perhaps this album is some people’s cup of tea, and that’s great for them, but as someone who would call themselves a fan of Swift, this album was nothing compared to what she’s created before.

The lyrics were let downs and borderline corny, which is the opposite of what she is capable of writing and has written. With songs titled “Eldest Daughter” and “CANCELLED!” I was imagining lyrics that would be profound, or at least catchy, and instead I was given, “I’m not a bad bitch / And this isn’t savage,” and “Did you girl-boss too close to the sun?” Wow… I’m sorry but that is ass (IN MY OPINION). Compared to other lyrics she’s written in past albums, such as, “Now you hang from my lips / Like the Gardens of Babylon,” in the song  “Cowboy Like Me,” (from “Evermore”) or, “Did some force take you bеcause I didn’t pray / Every single thing to come has turned into ashes,” in the song “Bigger Than The Sky,” (from “Midnights”) the lyrics of this recent album just fall short. And while those are just two examples, most of the album emulates similar cheesy and cliche lyrics, which again compared to the plethora of lyrics she’s written that are poetic and profound, just really let me down.  

Some argue that these lyrics are all a part of the theme for this album, but I just can’t get behind it. I also just found this album to be a bit unoriginal, and for Swift, I feel as though she has created such original and transformative pop albums for the genre as a whole– which is what makes this flop of hers so shocking.

“Some argue that these lyrics are all a part of the theme for this album, but I just can’t get behind it. I also just found this album to be a bit unoriginal, and for Swift, I feel as though she has created such original and transformative pop albums for the genre as a whole– which is what makes this flop of hers so shocking.”

While I will say that one album doesn’t dictate the true artistry of Swift, I can’t say her last few albums have been amazing either. “The Tortured Poets Department” also wasn’t really my favorite– I honestly liked the second album of it better than the actual album she mainly advertised– The Anthology.  Again, this is my opinion, but I wouldn’t be surprised if other Taylor Swift fans agreed. 

I guess what I’m trying to say overall is that I’ve noticed a decline in originality and artistry in Swift’s music, and while I still love and listen to her songs, I can’t help but feel disappointed. That’s not all though, as many fans of hers have pointed out, her hypocrisy of being possible friends of hardcore Trump supporters despite speaking out against Trump, or at least having done so in the past. Plus, this fact exists in conjunction with the fact that she really hasn’t even spoken much to politics recently. And yes, we shouldn’t put celebrities on a pedestal and expect them to always be politically engaged, but for someone like Swift who has such a large fan base, being outspoken on her political views is incredibly important to mobilize voters and inform her audience. Let’s not forget too the rumored relationship she had with Matty Healy, another controversial figure many fans of Swift had a problem with. While, as I mentioned, I do resent conversations surrounding Swift’s relationships in the context of general judgement and misogyny, I do notice that she does publicly relate to and interact with many people who go against the moral and political values she preaches on a significantly deep level.  What I’m saying here is Swift has acted in opposition to what she’s spoken out against, and me, along with other fans, have started to pick up and have an issue with this. 

This isn’t an issue only related to Swift, but again, with her having such a big following, it’s easy to see the ways she impacts her fans, as well as those who aren’t fans. I guess overall, as someone who has been a longtime fan, I’m disappointed in not only her recent music, but her recent character. While I know that I know nothing about who Swift really is, I think it’s safe to say that she has a large impact on most people, and for someone who has that power and must know she has that power, I expect better. But then again, perhaps this is just a lesson for all of us not to expect much from the celebrities we idolize, because there’s always room for them to disappoint us.

In the end, I won’t stop enjoying Swift’s music and defending her against the bigots, but I can confidently say that I hope to see better from her and her artistry for the future because as of right now, she’s kind of flopping.  

+ posts

Emily Nally ‘27 is an English and Creative Writing major with a Women and Gender Studies minor. She is editor of the Campus Voices section and is so excited to be a part of such an immersive organization on campus. Outside of the Weekly, you can find Emily rereading “Little Women,” binge watching “Gilmore Girls,” or being really cool practicing her flute and guitar.

Previous articleFruitful Musings
Next articleMicro-Astrology: Nov. 6, 2025
Emily Nally
Emily Nally ‘27 is an English and Creative Writing major with a Women and Gender Studies minor. She is editor of the Campus Voices section and is so excited to be a part of such an immersive organization on campus. Outside of the Weekly, you can find Emily rereading “Little Women,” binge watching “Gilmore Girls,” or being really cool practicing her flute and guitar.