Home Campus Voices Opinion: A tired hockey fan’s plea

Opinion: A tired hockey fan’s plea

Stop treating real hockey players like they’re another episode of “Heated Rivalry.”

1291
photo courtesy of @_willsmith2 on instagram

“Heated Rivalry” fans, I’m tired. It’s a great show, and I understand exactly why so many people are obsessed with it. But, as a big fan of real life hockey, I take real issue with the ways the new eyes on my beloved sport have reshaped what hockey fandom looks like. Suddenly, instead of conversations about gameplay, strategy, or even behind the scenes coaching and management decisions that affect the game, the hockey conversation seems to be centered around theorized relationships between players, be they on the same team or different ones.

Now, when most of my close friends came back to campus after winter break raving about “Heated Rivalry,” I initially found myself  hesitant to watch. It’s no secret that “Heated Rivalry” is, well, heated– the coldness of the ice Shane Hollander and Ilya Rozanov play hockey on is offset by the steamy and explicit portrayals of intimacy we see them engage in. No judgement, but that just isn’t my cup of tea, personally.

That being said, as time went on, and “Heated Rivalry” became more and more prominent, I found myself wanting to be part of the cultural moment. Plus, I’m a huge hockey fan, and the show’s about hockey players, so I figured there would at least be something in it for me.

I texted my friends nine minutes into the first episode. “This show is NOT about hockey.”

Now, that’s not to say I didn’t enjoy the show. By the end of episode six, I found myself enamored with the sweetness of Shane and Ilya’s relationship and the overall arc of the show. But I stand by my initial reaction– “Heated Rivalry” is not about ice hockey. It is a love story about two men who have a whole lotta sex, and they also happen to be ice hockey players.

Ultimately, I’m not interested in getting into the particulars of the show itself. The Weekly has already talked about it, the campus has already talked about it and everyone is entitled to their own take on the content of the show. What I am interested in talking about is the real world effects of the sudden influx of eyes on ice hockey and the real life people– particularly the young men who play it.

As I mentioned, I’m a huge hockey fan, especially of my hometown team, the San Jose Sharks. I’m the first to admit that objectively, they’re not a great hockey team. I crash out on my Instagram close friends story several times a week about it. They haven’t made the playoffs in six seasons, and are probably about to miss them for the seventh, despite the fact that they’ve managed to climb slightly higher in the league ranks by restructuring the team around young talent. They started playing in the 1991-92 season, and have made the Stanley Cup finals once. There’s a reason the slogan is “The Future is Teal”– the present sure isn’t. For new ice hockey fans fresh off of watching “Heated Rivalry” looking to watch a winning team like Shane or Ilya’s, there is no reason to pick the Sharks as your team, other than the charm of the players themselves. 

Us Sharks fans like to say that our team runs on the power of friendship– our guys on the ice exude camaraderie, with good energy coming across through social media posts, on the bench of games and on the ice. They might not be the best at hockey, but the Sharks sure are fun to watch, and the players are easy to connect with. And there’s no one easier to connect with than our “baby sharks”– young players in their early careers.

For anyone who knows anything about the National Hockey League (NHL) or watched men’s hockey at the winter Olympics, when you think of the Sharks, you think of one player in particular: 19-year-old phenom Macklin “Mack” Celebrini. 2024 first overall draft pick, Canadian boy wonder, recently took home a silver medal for team Canada at the 2026 Olympics– this kid is indubitably the future of the sport. “Heated Rivalry” fans, does that sound familiar? 

In the context of the Sharks, where there is Mack, there is his best friend Will. 20-year-old Will “Smitty” Smith, 2023 fourth overall draft pick for the Sharks. Known as “WillMack,” Mack and Smitty both played their first NHL season together in 2024, play on the same starting line and live together both at home and on the road. These two are dynamite on the ice and off it, and you can’t look away from the two of them. With the long history of shipping players, particularly amongst female hockey fans, it’s no wonder that these two get romantic allegations. 

Now, I’m sure you’re going “but Almarah, you’ve just spent three paragraphs telling us that Mack and Smitty are best friends. The second word in ‘Heated Rivalry’ is rivalry. Sure, Mack might be the spitting image of Shane Hollander in real life, but Smitty is nothing like Ilya, and they literally play on the same team.” ENTER BOSTON COLLEGE (BC) AND BOSTON UNIVERSITY (BU).

BC and BU are rivals in every sense of the word, but especially in what is both of their number one sports: ice hockey. Where did Smitty and Mack play in 2023? BC and BU respectively. Before they were best friends and line mates for the Sharks, they were the opposing star centers for perhaps the most intense college hockey rivalry out there.  I ask again, “Heated Rivalry” fans, especially those who’ve read the book series, does that sound familiar?  I haven’t even mentioned the rivalrous tension between Mack and Connor Bedard of the Chicago Blackhawks, who grew up training in Canada together, or Smitty and Gabe Perrault of the New York Rangers, who played right wing to Smitty’s center at BC. 

Now that I’ve infodumped to you about my Sharks, you have the context to understand what I’m actually upset about. Which is to say, “Heated Rivalry” fans, I’m begging you to stop being weird to real hockey players! When I scroll on TikTok, I see videos upon videos of new fans at NHL games, fresh from watching “Heated Rivalry.” While videos questioning when the players on ice are going to kiss are ostensibly jokes, I see these kinds of things every few scrolls. Fans show up to games with signs highlighting their friendship. The Sharks even had to change their open practice rules because fans were treating players in an uncomfortable manner. I see edits of real hockey players, particularly young players like Mack, Smitty, Bedard and Perrault set to songs from the show. 

And I get it– shipping hockey players has been around forever. Shane and Ilya themselves are based on Sydney Crosby and Alexander Ovechkin, who’ve been shipped for their entire careers. But since “Heated Rivalry” was released, I can’t open the comments of a post that’s about Mack or Smitty’s hockey skills without running into people shipping them. I see Mack compared to Shane constantly, despite the fact that one is a fictional character and one is a real person. It leaves a bad taste in my mouth, especially because these guys are 19 and 20– I’m literally older than them, and what feels like the entire internet is speculating on their friendship when all they want to do is shoot pucks into goals.

What I’m asking everyone to remember is that hockey players are real people. In particular, they are real young people, who can see everything that gets posted about them. They see people speculating on their supposed relationships when they’re supposed to be getting in the headspace to play the game they’re being paid to play. There’s so much to talk about when it comes to hockey that has nothing to do with the relationships of the players. Let’s talk about how Macklin Celebrini and Will Smith play on the ice, because they’re one of the most dynamic and exciting duos to watch in the entire NHL. That’s why so many eyes are on the Sharks right now to begin with.

Don’t get me wrong, if you loved “Heated Rivalry” and are getting into hockey because of it, especially if you are a woman, welcome! We’re happy to have you! Hockey is awesome, and the Sharks are fun and easy to love. But please, I’m begging you, be respectful to the players playing the game we all love. “Heated Rivalry” is there for your fix of gay romance, and hockey is there for everything else.

+ posts

Almarah ‘26 is a media & communication and theatre double major with a minor in creative writing and journalism. When not working on the paper, you can find them working with the Muhlenberg Theatre Association or the Muhlenberg Comedy Association. Occasionally they have time to watch any Spider-Man movie.