
Studying theatre at Muhlenberg is really exciting most of the time. It feels like performance opportunities abound, and everyone is always involved in some sort of project. But once you graduate, it gets a lot more difficult. Most auditions aren’t right down the road. The job market for theatre is really competitive, and depending on where you live, opportunities can be scarce. Anxiety surrounding their future careers is something many artists struggle with. In the face of all this uncertainty, seven Muhlenberg alumni decided to take their futures into their own hands.
Haley Arnold ‘23, Maddy Burk ‘23, Amanda Berkson ‘23, Shira Holtz ‘24, Lilli Brown ‘23, Ashley Paseltiner ‘23 and Alison Rutyna ‘23 founded “Amalgamation Theatre Collective” last year. Arnold, one of the company’s co-artistic directors, expressed, “Amalgamation all began when Maddy and I were chatting about having our play ideas rejected from Muhlenberg Theater Association (MTA) studio productions. I sort of made the joke that we should just do it ourselves, and then it wasn’t a joke.”
Holtz, head of marketing and development, added, “Amalgamation’s creation came from a want for there to be more theatrical work created with joy, empathy, wonder and people put first. All of us on the Amalgamation team have worked on processes where this was the case, and where it wasn’t, and it was important to us to create a space where we could always put that at the forefront.”
During their time at Muhlenberg, they tested the waters with “Patchwork Theatre Festival, a series of three full-length, student-run plays performed in the school’s underutilized amphitheaters.” Arnold continued, “We all agreed we wanted more…Now we have an operating LLC [Limited Liability Company] and have just produced our debut production.”
That debut production was “Too Much Light Makes the Baby Go Blind,” which ran this past weekend at Civic Theatre in Allentown. The play is best described by its subtitle—“30 Plays in 60 Minutes.” The numbers one through thirty were hung on a clothesline strung from the ceiling, and the audience shouted out numbers at the end of every play. In this way, the show was different every night. A timer sat behind the action onstage, and in silent moments its ticking was a stark reminder of the intended time limit of the show. It was an exciting, interactive experience that encouraged the audience to think deeply about the nature of going to the theatre.
“Spontaneity and improvisation can leave an impact, as can any kind of theatre that is produced with intention and care.” – Katy Olson ’27
Arnold, who directed the show, chose it for Amalgamation’s debut production because “[It was] one of the first productions I saw as a student at Muhlenberg. It sort of felt like an homage to how I found my footing as a director and theatre maker. It is a structural and technical challenge that I was excited to embark on as a director. But it is also undeniably relevant to the world we are living in—more and more each day, it seems.”
The passion Arnold felt for this show was easy to see for the actors in the show. Eliyah Burg ‘28, for example, said that Arnold “made sure we were given the space to have fun, go crazy and experiment with the plays and with ourselves and how we would exist onstage, while still honoring and uplifting and really just pouring so much love into each individual play so that each one had its moment to shine.” This space for experimentation was especially helpful for some of the actors who were less experienced with improv. Katy Olson ‘27 said, “A challenge of the process for me was to not let myself get stuck on ‘bad’ choices that I made during the improvisation portions of the show. I quickly learned that whether I liked my choices or not, I needed to keep moving forward!”
The biggest challenge of the rehearsal process was the fact that it took place over winter break. Those in the cast who are current students went home, and those who had already graduated were not necessarily available all the time. The company found a way to make it work, however. Liv Fornasieri ‘24 stated, “I ended up mostly rehearsing over Zoom and coming up for rehearsals every other weekend. It was definitely a challenge not being in-person for all of the rehearsals, but I am eternally grateful for the flexibility and support of the cast and crew. Plus, the nature of the show itself also allowed me to have the flexibility to not be in-person all of the time, which was an added bonus!”
So what should the audience have taken away from the production? According to Olson, “Spontaneity and improvisation can leave an impact, as can any kind of theatre that is produced with intention and care.” And Arnold tells us to “Be observant, be present, be self aware. Self awareness followed by kindness is the path forward.”
Holtz shared how you can keep up with Amalgamation: “Check us out @amalgamationtheatreco on Instagram and on our website amalgamationtheatreco.com.”

















