Home Arts & Culture BergImmersive presents The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals

BergImmersive presents The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals

Student-run theatre company’s first musical happens to be about a guy who hates musicals

1591
Berg Immersive's "The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals" opens on Nov. 21. Photo from @bergimmersive on Instagram.
Berg Immersive's "The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals" opens on Nov. 21. Photo from @bergimmersive on Instagram.

Tickets for BergImmersive’s upcoming production of “The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals” (“TGDWLM”) sold out almost instantly when released, leading the cast and creative team to add a Saturday matinee for those who weren’t able to grab a ticket in the original sale. Muhlenberg’s student-run immersive theatre company, ‘BergImmersive, is debuting its first musical production since establishing itself as an official campus organization in fall 2023. The horror comedy, originally produced by the internet-famous theatrical company, StarKid Productions (“StarKid”), will be playing in Moyer Hall from Nov. 21-23 to a sold-out audience. 

The show tells the story of a man who hates musicals named Paul (Gray Douglass ‘27) and how he fights against the odds as his hometown of Hatchetfield is overrun by an alien hive mind that causes everyone to sing and dance as if in a musical. Directors Cal Martin-Singer ‘25 and Dylan Sheppard ‘25 proposed this musical towards the end of last semester when BergImmersive put out a notice for director applications. The two had been thinking about proposing the show since freshman year, and things began to become a reality when Sheppard was inspired to map out a floor plan after seeing BergImmersive’s 12 Ophelias last spring. Martin-Singer shared why they were interested in bringing this musical to Muhlenberg audiences specifically: “‘[TGWDLM]’ has been one of my favorite shows in the world for years, and ever since I started seeing BergImmersive shows, I had a nagging thought that the immersive format would be absolutely fantastic for a show like ‘[TGWDLM].’ It’s such a campy, silly, lighthearted and mostly unserious show (save for a few heart-wrenching moments here and there), which I think is something that the entire campus community needs right now. Our main priority is for the audience to have fun.” 

StarKid Productions is unique in that it publishes its musicals on YouTube for anyone to view free of charge, which poses a challenge for those who take on StarKid originals, in that they are competing with a version of the musical that many view as iconic. However, BergImmersive’s production is sure to be inherently different from the original, given the company’s focus on audience engagement. Sheppard, who also serves as the production’s musical director, provided some hints as to how audiences can expect to become immersed in the world of Hatchetfield: “We have turned the entire first floor of Moyer into Hatchetfield, with some rooms and hallways being major locations. The Hivemind is raring up for opening night, and is so excited for anyone and everyone to see the show. In a way, we hope the audience also becomes a bit of a character.” On this, Martin-Singer added “Get ready to join the Hivemind.”

BergImmersive is continuing its tradition of using Moyer Hall, an academic building, as a theatrical space to produce their shows. This poses yet another challenge for the cast and creative team as they must navigate using an unconventional space as a theater. It also is a stark contrast from the original production by StarKid, which is set in a simple black box. However, Moyer Hall also serves as a world of opportunity for directors given the variety of spaces in the building, including multiple floors of classrooms and lab spaces. Bird Palermo ‘25, who is playing Davidson, Sam and others commented on the immersive aspect of the production: “‘[TGWDLM]’ is immersive both in the physical staging of the show, being in the first floor of Moyer – classrooms, Miller Forum, hallways and all! And the concept, which I won’t say too much about, revolves around a tour of Hatchetfield, the town the musical is set in. I’ve personally never done anything quite like this show before, and it was really fun as a performer to explore meta-theatrical concepts and unusual theatrical spaces.”

“TGWDLM”  can be considered an ensemble show given how all actors, except Douglass, play multiple roles in a very fast-paced manner. Emma Howson ‘27, who plays General MacNamara and others, shared her experience navigating differentiating each of her characters: “Playing multiple roles is definitely difficult, but I’ve had ample opportunity during the process to flesh out each of my characters. I conferenced with [Sheppard] and [Martin-Singer] at the beginning of the process to develop my unnamed characters into fuller people, which helped inform my performance and made those bit characters more fun to play!”

“I’ve personally never done anything quite like this show before, and it was really fun as a performer to explore meta-theatrical concepts and unusual theatrical spaces.” – Bird Palermo ’25

Alina Hernandez ‘25, who plays Charlotte and others, expanded on how Sheppard and Martin-Singer have assisted the cast in their understanding of their characters:  “I’ve loved this show since it first came out on YouTube during my sophomore year of high school, and Charlotte was my dream role. She was so fun to create and mold. Our directors, [Martin-Singer] and [Sheppard], made a detailed list of questions for us to answer as a way to get to know our characters better. The answers felt like they just flowed out of me, and I felt like I knew her so well. The best way I could describe her is a Bible-thumping Taylor Swift enthusiast and cat lover who secretly carries a pack of reds and a flask in her purse.”

This musical is especially unique in that along with its characterization as an ensemble show, it also provides room for complexity in each character, such as the character of Emma (played by Rhyan Brogowski ‘28) who is struggling with the death of her sister. Brogowski commented on finding the balance between the comedic and dramatic elements of her character with the statement, “I was surprised to find that it is easier for me to be dramatic rather than comedic. I either am not sure how to play it or I make myself laugh, whereas being serious is a lot more grounded. I have loved playing off of scene partners and getting into the moment when it comes to comedic scenes, and I think it is definitely helping me grow as an actor.” 

Cast members shared what they are most excited for Muhlenberg audiences to see from this production. Hernandez said “I’m most excited for Muhlenberg audiences to see the level of detail we as a cast have put in and how we really made it our own. We created the pre-show as a way for the audience to get acclimated to our world. The audience isn’t going to sit in a chair for the next 2 hours; they’re going on a guided tour of Hatchetfield as the new apotheosized citizens perform the story of what happened to them and their town… ’Berg Production set up a beautiful lighting system that completely transforms the space.” The fact that all performances of “The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals” are completely sold out proves that Muhlenberg community members are more than ready to see what BergImmersive has in store.

+ posts

Samantha Tempkin '25 is a theatre and media & communication double major. During her time with The Weekly, she served as an assistant editor for News and a lead editor for Arts & Culture.