Home Campus Voices The fate of the liberal arts: A look at Muhlenberg College

The fate of the liberal arts: A look at Muhlenberg College

1106
Photo by Kira Bretsky '27.

Small liberal arts colleges all across the country are under pressure, and Muhlenberg is one of them. Enrollment dips, budget cuts and departures of faculty and staff can make it feel like something is uniquely wrong with our campus. But that is far from true. However, just because we aren’t alone doesn’t make our choices any less important. They matter more. 

Nationally, college enrollment has dipped dramatically. Commonly referred to as the “enrollment cliff,” as of spring 2026, there were 15.5 million undergraduate students enrolled, the lowest since the peak in 2010 with 18.1 million undergraduates. This is especially true for the regions where we recruit the most. Pennsylvania’s enrollment dropped 17.4% since 2010. New Jersey’s is even lower, dropping 20%. New York is down 18.4%. These numbers largely result from the 2008 recession– people were not having children due to economic hardship, so now there are fewer college-aged students. Coupled with that, more students are choosing to go into the trades. From just 2020 to 2023, trade school enrollment grew by nearly 5%. Vocational and community college saw major surges, such as a 16% jump in vocational community college registrations and a 23% spike in construction trade programs. Ultimately, the same number of colleges are competing for fewer and fewer students.

This makes the way Muhlenberg markets and brands itself essential. In a time when most students are choosing large, state institutions, we need to be able to defend picking Muhlenberg. Nationally, about 72% of college students attend public institutions, drawn in by the big name recognition and football Saturdays. They are thriving while smaller colleges struggle. We can’t compete with them. But we shouldn’t try. We all chose Muhlenberg, a small school, for a reason. Real relationships with professors, a community where you are more than just a number and that feels truly like home. That is what we have to encourage: the power of small colleges, but also the positives of ‘Berg.

So, as painful as the faculty and staff cuts are, they partly serve as a correction. Muhlenberg College used to sit at a student-to-faculty ratio of 8:1, which was, respectfully, too low. 10:1 to 14:1 is the most common at small private liberal arts colleges, and we will now stand at 12:1. Muhlenberg has been operating with a workforce that was needed back when it had a larger student body of 2,220 in 2010. When enrollment shrinks, unfortunately, everything else needs to. This explains the cuts, but it still doesn’t make them painless because behind every position is a person who knows students by name.

There are some changes on campus that I feel like students have been quick to react to. The Seegers Expansion deserves some recognition, not just complaints about money and construction. Yes, while the work right now is disruptive and weighing on the College’s finances, it promises to deliver a lot as well: a new center to welcome prospective students, a hot spot of academic success and a celebration space. Those are the kinds of things that prospective students and families look for and notice, and allow bigger recruiting efforts. It also offers a lot to our current student body too, which is often neglected. Signature events like Senior Ball, formals and concerts can be taken to the next level instead of happening in weird, unaesthetic places. Offices like the Health Professions Advising, the Career Center and Global Education will be condensed under one roof in the center of campus, being more accessible. Bringing in more potential new students is likely to increase enrollment, which in turn brings more money to the College, benefiting the current student body.

The Seegers refresh also matters for the feel of the campus. Spaces like Java Joe, General’s Quarters and the Red Doors were old and dingy, and they needed to be redone. Once construction ends, life and the hominess can return to those spaces. 

I won’t pretend that the changes to Seegers are a guaranteed success. The costs are real, and if the enrollment doesn’t come, the College would’ve probably taken a measure they didn’t need to. The project was a calculated risk they took on– there is no other choice but to see it through and embrace it. And to be clear, Muhlenberg is at a real advantage financially. Sitting at about $337 million, colleges of our size typically have endowments under $100 million. That’s a cushion that competing institutions of our size would envy. However, having a cushion is not a strategy. It may buy time and flexibility, yet it’s what we do in that time that matters. 

Too often we find ourselves caught in an echo chamber of doom and despair. Scrolling through anonymous platforms like YikYak, you’ll be flooded with negative comments about Dhall falling short or construction noise becoming a prediction that the College won’t survive. Some of that frustration and critique is earned. But a campus that only hears the worst stories about itself starts to believe it. Complaining is drastically different from critique. Critique calls for action and belongs in front of people: in town halls, in emails, in conversations where change can actually result. We need to devote equal time to the positives. 

To me, the most crucial thing that Muhlenberg faces is choosing its next president. Shrinking enrollment, shrinking budgets and more will all land on that person’s desk. We need to move in a positive direction instead of managing decline. We need to be able to make hard decisions but justify them openly. Most importantly, we need a president who knows Muhlenberg. The place where a professor asks to get drinks with you at The Tav, when you’re walking into Dhall and see the person you never thought college could bring you and how much students love the pizza rustica. Someone who understands that feeling will know that Muhlenberg is worth fighting for. 

Because somewhere out there right now is a high school senior who can’t even fathom the impact Muhlenberg will have on their life. Someone who might feel homesick in September and not want to leave come December. Someone who will walk down Academic Row for the first time and think, this is where I am supposed to be. That student is counting on us to still be here. I’m counting on us to still be here.

So, Muhlenberg isn’t the only one facing these problems. But it may be one of the few colleges with the endowment, the community and the opportunity to come out stronger. Whether we do depends heavily on the choices we make now.

+ posts

Amanda Growney ‘28 is a history major on the pre-law track. She is absolutely thrilled to be a copy editor for The Muhlenberg Weekly. When she's not attending classes or club meetings, you’ll find her rewatching “How I Met Your Mother,” watching a sports game, socializing with friends, or sleeping.

Previous articleHand-crafted
Next articleBattling in the conference
Amanda Growney
Amanda Growney ‘28 is a history major on the pre-law track. She is absolutely thrilled to be a copy editor for The Muhlenberg Weekly. When she's not attending classes or club meetings, you’ll find her rewatching “How I Met Your Mother,” watching a sports game, socializing with friends, or sleeping.