Maybe I’ll whisper it to you, slyly under the shining of the sun. Or maybe I’ll write it for some measure of notability.
What is there to begin with when discussing humiliation? If you are thinking of the question in terms of love? Or like? Should I make you suffer by making you think? Making you confront all that you haven’t said? Ultimately what is better? To speak or to die? A question posed by Marguerite de Navarre and articulated by a pretty French woman as rain slithered down the sweaty windows of Crema, Italy in Guadagnino’s vibrant film that viscerally touches life, speaks to sex. I will now write of the question, hope you don’t sweat under the sun, and then I will go on living my life, scraping for the answer. Go on soaking in the feeling after speaking, or wishing to shake your head hard enough in hopes you forget I ever spoke at all.
It was asked in this detached way. Well maybe detached isn’t the right word. I mean what right word is there to encompass a question many don’t understand the weight of? That a question asked with slyness, brought up again in underlying conversation by blue water and wet sheet music would blanket the entirety of the “Call Me by Your Name” novel and subsequent film’s every utterance, every theme.
Before speaking there is the checking of the watch, the lingering at the staircase, the crack of the egg. Before dying there is a night that feels like heaven, golden lamplight on the cobblestones of Bergamo, Italy, the smell of vomit in the air.
Elio admitted to his mother; “I’d never have the courage to ask such a question.” And I wonder in a world where silence is such a dangerous, cowardly thing, where the courage to speak comes from. Where the need is present. Self preservation? To explain and explain to those who look at you and think they understand it all. Speaking is attempting to translate all that has moved within your body to the outside. To the dangers of another. In some ways it is a reduction of who you are, the more you do it, the closer you are to a weakened version of yourself. You may speak it, but what do they hear? Is it worth it to speak aloud to others? Who see the arch of my brow and believe I am mean. Well I am not mean, I am just set this way.
Maybe it isn’t about courage but maybe you keep silent to keep it all clean and tidy, to hold your fingers tightly around the saving grace that you never said anything at all. That you remained a mystery. Unfelt. Remained without fault.
I think first of speaking aloud in terms of being a young frivolous, determined, human, woman. To speak aloud can be seen as humiliation, to be naked with all your clothes on, to be what they envision in all its glory. Get rid of the riddle you once were, the novelty you held. To love in of itself is not simply “loving” but scraping for it, because the other does not want to show too much under scrutiny, under the pointed finger of desperation. To speak is a desperation that is respected if you do it softly in the mirror first.
I think of speaking in a room filled with others. I think of speaking as this floating thing to grasp while everyone is speaking after a secure round of thinking. Then I envision myself empty of careful thought and simply speaking. I think it is a beautiful, messy thing.
Before speaking there can be everything and afterwards nothing. A different face in the mirror, with the sunlight peering through. Before speaking you were alive in some sense, stagnant, there, a blade of grass being pushed around by wind and then to speak is to have died but why does my nakedness equate to a surrender?
“Because I wanted you to know.”
Spoken by Elio, it was a giving in, the head falling, the youthfulness of this line’s delivery. I imagine a harness dropped from the heart. We don’t see Elio’s face, and I don’t have to. I feel it, and when he repeats it anew in this probing way, a sort of disbelief, a reaction towards an upheaval. Then again, he says it, in this slow, winding down sort of delivery that is shocked at the rawness of the desire present in each syllable. This line holds the most basic truth. Listening to it, I smile. That we can be this honest, that we can be this vulnerable.
It may be as simple as that, leading with your heart, caring or not caring about what the utterance will do to the rest of you, how now, you are the person who spoke.
If I said I would rather speak. Regret could visit me as I wake and as I work. But it will flutter away. To speak is marking myself in the Earth, in the discourse between two people.
The answer may be overt; that in speaking you are living, submitting to the unforgiving manner in which the flowers grow, the birds migrate, the way in which the sea weaves to swallow your body on a day you aim to forget. That speaking is your way of trying as a human, that desperation is in all of us, that in simply surviving we are exerting some sort of selfishness. It should be simple then, to speak, to say anything.
Your heart may not be able to discern what is better, speaking or dying, it may not care at all.
The question doesn’t pose dying in the literal sense, dying here is losing what it means to be human. It’s losing courage, it’s letting it all slip away for some measure of dignity that somehow equates to being alive. But to live is to stretch your limbs towards someone else, to feel your lips move in the pursuit of salvation, to have all that is there between two souls out and there, a tangible thing. Or not.
Dying is to have lived in the comfort between one end of your lips to the other, to reside within a stagnancy that equals survival. I didn’t show myself so I can remain living. Steady, steady, steady. I was once nothing at all.
If I said I would rather die. I will go on surviving. With all of it in a basket tucked away, a free spirit, connected to nothing.
Amal ‘28 is a double major in English + Creative Writing and Public Health. She loves to spend her free time writing, reading, and taking walks!



















