Home Campus Voices Letter to the Editor

Letter to the Editor

1082

To whom it may concern, 

Like many Muhlenberg students, I am appalled by the recent Weekly article “A conservative’s response to ICE.” This is not because I am a liberal, although I am, or because I believe that conservative viewpoints are inherently bad. In fact, I appreciate the author calling out the Donald Trump administration for its lack of empathy and professionalism regarding people’s concerns about Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). However, recommending empathy and understanding in one breath and excusing state-sanctioned terrorism in another is hypocritical. Multiple aspects of the article angered me, and I feel they deserve a response. 

First, the article stated that “Immigration laws and enforcement throughout the rapid expansion of the United States were crucial for limiting/stopping terrorism, crime and other inhumane acts.” Anyone who studies American history will tell you that this is a massive oversimplification. While immigration laws have always intended to stop crime, they have been rooted in the racist notion that immigrants are more likely to commit crimes than natural-born Americans since the very beginning. 

Our nation’s first immigration law was the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, which banned all Chinese people from immigrating to the United States, regardless of their criminal status. Soon after, the United States began regulating immigration through quotas. These quotas were deadly. Anne Frank’s family attempted to immigrate to the United States before the Holocaust, but were denied, as the quotas for German citizens had already been filled. In another heartbreaking instance, the United States prevented a boat of Jewish refugees from entering the country, leading a third of its passengers to be killed in the Holocaust. 

By 1941, the country went as far as to ban people from German-occupied countries from applying for immigration visas at all, citing national security concerns. It is not a far stretch to say that our government valuing theoretical concerns about crime over actual human lives led to the deaths of thousands, or possibly even millions, of innocent people. After the Holocaust, we promised “Never to Forget,” yet it seems we have forgotten. The vast majority of undocumented immigrants are not criminals. They are working people, so desperate to protect their families from violence that they’ll risk their own safety to do so. This is not to say that no one enters the country illegally for nefarious purposes. The horrific deaths of Jocelyn Nungaray, Laken Riley, Rachel Morin and Mollie Tibbets, among others, are a sobering reminder of this. However, we can’t assume that only criminals will forgo entering “the right way” when the immigration court backlog is so long that many languish at the border for years while waiting to be granted asylum. The way to ensure that people enter the country legally is not through the fear-mongering that has defined the Trump administration; it is by making immigration courts more accessible and efficient. 

Secondly, I am angry that the article stated that it is “debatable that ICE has been using overly aggressive tactics to round up people who immigrated here illegally.” It is not debatable. It is a fact. According to the Law Enforcement Immigration Task Force, “Many violations of immigration law, such as unlawful presence or overstaying one’s visa, are not criminal offenses, but civil offenses,” while “illegal entry is a misdemeanor punishable by a fine or imprisonment of up to six months on the first instance.” There is no need for violent, humiliating raids to capture people accused of civil offenses and misdemeanors. The accused crime simply does not match the punishment. I say “accused crime” for a reason. According to the American Immigration Council, “Arrests of people with no criminal record surged by 2,450 percent in Trump’s first year, driven by increases in tactics like ‘at-large’ arrests, roving patrols, worksite raids, and re-arrests of people attending immigration court hearings or ICE check-ins. The percent of people arrested by ICE and held in detention with no criminal record rose from 6 percent in January to 41 percent by December.” 

The Constitution states that “no state may deprive any person of life, liberty or property, without due process of law.” Not “any citizen,” not “any legal resident.” No person, regardless of immigration status, can have their fundamental rights removed without due process. That is what I, and other like-minded individuals, are protesting for. We are not saying that all immigrants are faultless individuals, or that all deportations are unnecessary, just that all immigrants deserve due process. 

Third, I am outraged that the article excused the horrific murders of Renee Good and Alex Pretti. The author questions, “Could ICE’s aggressive nature be justified when there are thousands of people breaking the law and being noncompliant?” My answer to that is a definitive no. It doesn’t matter that Alex Pretti kicked an ICE vehicle, or that the officer who murdered Renee Good was injured on the job last year. It is a law enforcement officer’s responsibility to not let their past experiences cloud their judgment. No matter how you feel about ICE as an institution, it’s an undeniable fact that the officers who killed Pretti and Good failed to do this. They acted recklessly, and death was the result. The author likely agrees with me when I say that human life is precious, so why is she excusing the actions of those who took it? 

It saddens me to see people in my community express more compassion for murderous officers than for those who protest them. It saddens me to know that some believe undocumented immigrants, regardless of their criminal status, deserve to be detained, separated from their families, denied healthy food and medical care and sent to countries where their lives will be at risk. Lastly, I am disheartened that some believe there are exceptions to our Declaration of Independence, which states that all people have the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. As Muhlenberg students and American citizens, we must object. 

Maddie Tillem

+ posts

It is the policy of The Muhlenberg Weekly to foster relationships with its readership, including through discourse in its Opinion/Editorial section. Therefore, members of the College Community are encouraged to submit Letters to the Editor on any topic of interest to Muhlenberg, in direct reference to an article or otherwise.