What are the benefits of an interim position at ‘Berg?

President Harring and Provost Furge explain why many of the administration currently have interim positions.

967

Currently at Muhlenberg, three administration jobs– the vice president for enrollment management, the chief financial officer (CFO) and the director of student transitions and family programs, are functioning as interim positions. Interim positions are often temporary and objective-focused, meaning that one is hired on a specific condition to solve a certain problem or see a project through to completion. These temporary positions have become increasingly popular in the higher education sphere, as there are fewer people permanently filling jobs. This leaves many key positions open and needing to be occupied by someone for a short-term period. For instance, in 2023, The Chronicle of Higher Education “reported that nearly 80% of campus leaders and their institution had more open positions than one year before. Some 84% confirmed that hiring for administrative and staff positions was more difficult than last year.” 

This raises the question: Why has it become more challenging for the leaders of colleges and universities to keep their staff in permanent positions? Interims are usually brought to campuses in order to address topics such as budget management, academic leadership, human resources, enrollment management and financial aid. Across the U.S. there is a growing shortage of skillful administrators to fill vital positions for colleges and universities. As a result of the shortage, experienced interim leaders are stepping up in order to assist and address the matter in question. 

As of now, Terry Cowdrey is serving as the interim vice president for enrollment management. In regards to the hiring of a new vice president, President Kathleen Harring responds, “The search for this position is in the final stages and we expect to announce the new vice president soon. I am grateful for the faculty, staff and students who are serving on the search committee. Larry Bombach is serving as the interim chief financial officer. We have not determined the timeline for that search.” 

Another position that is awaiting a permanent staff member is the director of student transitions and family programs. Natalie Shaw and John Lukan are currently sharing the position between themselves, on top of their other staff responsibilities. 

Harring further explains how interim positions are beneficial to higher education institutions, stating, “Interim positions are common in higher education, given the way the academic year and academic appointments typically work. In the past when there were vacancies, institutions often assigned additional responsibilities to existing members of the administration. Over the past decade, it has become more common to bring in external professionals to fill interim roles at the senior leadership level. The workload and technical requirements have expanded to the point where bringing in an outside expert in a field such as enrollment management is necessary and also brings new ideas and perspectives to the College. In addition, having an interim also provides a smoother transition for the new leader.”

Provost Furge provided her personal experience with interim positions, as she says, “I was an interim provost at Kalamazoo College before I came to Muhlenberg. And, while I was faculty there for 22 years, there were at different times interim provosts, presidents and [vice presidents] in all the major areas. This is normal practice and provides time for institutions to make the best hiring decisions for permanent roles, particularly in higher education where some ‘hiring cycles’ are more defined than in other industries (e.g. searches, including for faculty, typically launch in summer or fall with hiring completed in winter or early spring for a position/person that won’t even start until typically July 1 of the next year– other industries do not have such a long stretch between search, hiring and start date– it is somewhat unique to the rhythm of education.”

In an article from WTW, the authors share similar ideas with Provost Furge, as they write about how there is a recent trend among colleges and universities to have a president in an interim role. They write that interim positions, specifically for “presidential roles, are becoming a common strategy for institutions aiming to weather the current economic and geopolitical climate… institutions like Columbia University, Cornell University, Emory University and others have appointed interim presidents to navigate these challenges.” They also mention how, “unlike traditional practices when interim roles were stepping stones to permanent appointments, the current trend leans toward appointing interim leaders primarily for stability, not necessarily as long-term candidates.” So, rather than interim positions being used as a ladder for one to eventually secure a permanent job, interim positions are now mainly transient. 

While interim positions may be beneficial for solving specific problems present at a college or university, there are also concerns about these temporary positions being a symbol of instability. As students and staff face the new adjustment, they are also left to question the long-term consequences that provisional jobs can have on the overall campus environment.

+ posts