
Muhlenberg College’s faculty operate with an incredibly wide range of specializations. One professor in particular, however, occupies a niche unlike any other. Adjunct Professor Vaughn Stoffey spends some of his time on campus teaching guitar and bass. The rest of his time is spent in the legendary technical brutal death metal band Defeated Sanity as their guitarist. While his dual-career seemingly falls on two opposite ends of the spectrum in terms of lifestyle, Stoffey has been able to make the life of an active musician and a teacher coexist, even when actively touring.
Just this past November, Defeated Sanity toured in support of bands Sanguisugabogg, alongside Despised Icon, Corpse Pile and Bayway N.J. Stoffey, while on tour, continued to teach lessons whenever he could make it to campus– on the seemingly sisyphean task of balancing touring and teaching, he shared that “Luckily, the department is very supportive of me going out and doing that stuff, partially because we grossed $100,000 on the tour– it’s not a hobby, it’s a legit source of income and the faculty understand that as a working musician having the income from touring is very important, as is having someone on staff doing these things– it’s sort of practicing what you preach.” He also recognized how his students are impacted by his touring schedule. Stoffey believes, “It’s all about balance and making sure the kids get what they need, like by giving them long scope assignments, things they can sink their teeth on when I’m on the road.”
While currently a death metal musician, and an incredibly technical one at that, Stoffey was already working at Muhlenberg before he joined Defeated Sanity in 2022, an event he refers to as his big break. “I didn’t get into metal until I was older,” he explained. “I had just gotten into it when I started teaching here.” Before his foray into the metal genre, Stoffey played jazz. “I’ve been playing guitar seriously since I was a wee child, but I got really serious about it around 11 or 12. Early on and even now, my biggest influence is Jimmi Hendrix, as well as Black Sabbath and Frank Zappa.”
Stoffey’s metal baptism was nothing short of fate, as Defeated Sanity was the catalyst for his fascination with the genre in the first place, at the time as a newly converted fan. “Defeated Sanity was the first death metal band I ever saw. I was a jazz musician living in New York, and a good friend turned me on to the album “Passages in Deformity”– I hadn’t even really listened to thrash metal or death when I heard Defeated Sanity at his apartment, and coincidentally they were playing that night,” he shared. “After that night, I wanted to defect and play sick music. I didn’t want to play jazz anymore– I wanted to play metal.”
The transition from fan to member was another stroke of fortuitous circumstances. “I reached out to [frontman] Lille and we kept in touch throughout the years. Right around the time they needed a new guitarist, I was changing up my technique and aesthetic to that style of death metal, and I was playing with this band in Texas called Reviled. We played a festival in Chicago, and Lille’s ex-girlfriend, who was still a good friend of his, was there. She saw me play, and she went back and told him, “I think that’s the guy you need.”
“After that, he reached out to me. I had about six weeks to learn the live set– they said if you pull it off, you’re in the band. I knew I had to pull it off. Those opportunities come once in a lifetime– I had to succeed.” And succeed he did; Defeated Sanity’s most recent album, “Chronicles of Lunacy,” the first album to feature Stoffey on guitar, boasts a score of 96/100 on The Metal Archives, tied for the highest scoring release from the band, as well as receiving a 9/10 rating from Metal Injection. For many people, the record was their first exposure to Defeated Sanity, the band who “really flies the flag now for brutal death metal. There’s not a lot of bands from the late 90s still representing the genre like we are now.” For a band that has been around for over 30 years, pushing beyond the label of a legacy band is a certain accomplishment.
On the writing process of the album, Stoffey explained that “Lille is the prime compositional force and has always been. When he propositioned me to join the band, some of the first music he had me play was new music– he had around 80% of the album already written, and the remaining 20% was collaborative.” The making of the album, in a way, was Stoffey’s “test run” with the band.
“One song on the album, ‘Extrinsically Enraged,’ was something I played with him before my audition run– three shows we did in Berlin, London and Iceland all in three days in a row– they told me that ‘if you can nail the shows under these circumstances, you’ll be fine.’ I flew over to Berlin before then just to work with him, on drums and guitar, and he wanted to see how we collaborated compositionally. Even though he’s the spearhead compositionally, he’s very into the idea of being a band, and the collaborative nature of what being in a band means. That remaining 20% was us coming up with music together.”
While Stoffey’s experience with Defeated Sanity has been undoubtedly positive, joining the band when they were already well-established posed the unique challenge of finding a groove that fits into the music the band has already put out without trying to be someone you are not. On creating his own identity, Stoffey early on realized that he should not pretend to be someone he was not. “To a degree, I think that it was partially that the guitarist in the band before me was one of my all time favorites, Christian Kuhn. I think I tried to model my mannerisms and playing after his, but very early on I realized I needed to create my own identity. The new lineup and the new album gave me space to create my own identity within the band and people have responded positively,” Stoffey said. “The first tour I did in the U.S., we were playing, and the drummer pulled me aside, distraught. ‘I don’t know why you’re standing still, looking at your hands, you know what you’re doing.’ And that next night– there’s a video somewhere– I just went apeshit on stage.”
Defeated Sanity, even amongst the technical death metal scene, is notable for the extreme precision and technicality in which their songs are composed and performed. For somebody who is also a professor, Stoffey explained how he manages to perform such staggeringly complex music. “A lot of practice. In Defeated Sanity, we are all pretty militant about the work we put in. I practice in my free time more than ever, three to five hours a day when I’m not here teaching.” However, it is not necessarily the compositions themselves that proved the biggest hurdle to overcome in live performances. “What makes it more challenging is not playing the music, but playing the antics of the stage– the raging, the headbanging– the things that are inexorably linked to the metal tradition. Having to navigate those things while playing incredibly technical music is definitely the hardest part.”
Metal as a genre is intrinsically linked to hardcore music, resulting in a pattern that has emerged in recent years. Death metal bands that have gained the most traction amongst young fans have fallen closer in line with hardcore than old school death metal (i.e. Suffocation, whose record Pierced From Within is cited by Stoffey as one of his favorite albums of all time). Defeated Sanity has remained true to their 90s-style compositions, but recently have paired with hardcore-adjacent acts on their recent tour such as Corpse Pile and (fully hardcore) Bayway N.J. This contrast would seemingly create a wedge in the scene, but Stoffey weighs in on why Defeated Sanity has sought out these bands. “It’s very intentional to tour with other bands that at least in a broad sense aesthetically fit with what we are trying to do. Once you penetrate the texture of brutal death metal, you start seeing a lot of the similarities. Our music is different from those bands, you know, Sanguisugabogg really ignited my interest in hardcore, so I’ve been listening to a lot of Terror and Earth Crisis.”
Sanguisugabogg, the band Defeated Sanity toured in support of in November, recently released the record “Hideous Aftermath.” The first single of the album which has been hailed as a modern death metal classic, “Abhorrent Contraception,” features Defeated Sanity’s vocalist, Josh Welshman. On how the track came to fruition, Stoffey said that “Sanguisugabogg reached out to us- they’re huge Defeated Sanity fans. When we released our first single off the new album, Devin called me the day it came out, and said, “Hey, we would love for you guys to come out and tour with us,” but people in the scene say things like that all the time. Lo and behold, they confirmed, and later reached out to Josh to do the song with him. I think it was intentional and partially to foreshadow us touring with them on their record.”
Defeated Sanity’s most recent tour wrapped up in November. In March, they will begin their first U.S. headlining tour, and Professor Stoffey will be on the road again– not just as Muhlenberg faculty, but as a musician putting out death metal that remains true to the genre’s roots and unwilling to compromise on quality or brutality.

















