“We thought things would get better.”
That’s how one longtime dining worker summed up the months since Sodexo employees at Muhlenberg voted to unionize– a historic organizing effort that workers fought for over a year to achieve. The vote, toward the end of 2024, brought hope for better pay, more predictable schedules and access to better benefits.
“People expected everything to get better overnight,” said Evan Hallman, a supervisor at the Wood Dining Commons and union vice president. “But this first year…it’s a marathon, not a sprint.”
Last spring, dining staff at Muhlenberg negotiated their first-ever union contract after a slow, sometimes tense bargaining process. Workers pushed for the union because of low pay compared to other Sodexo accounts, inconsistent scheduling and feeling disrespected. “There were forceful personalities,” Hallman said delicately. “Some people felt talked down to.”
The union win felt historic. But months later, workers say daily life has become more complicated than the victory celebrations suggested.
After a series of protests last year, the dining hall workers finally voted to unionize in December. Usually, these wins have been followed by slow-moving contract negotiations, institutional cost-cutting and complex labor-management dynamics– especially in higher education, where declining enrollment has tightened budgets.
At Muhlenberg, that pressure is especially evident.
According to Jane Schubert, executive director of college operations, total student enrollment has dropped over the last five years, mirroring trends at many Northeast colleges. “This, along with rising costs, has had an impact on the operating budget,” Schubert said. The College, she added, is working to “provide the best possible experience while limiting increases in tuition, room, board and fees.”
That budget pressure directly affects dining. While some dining program costs such as utilities remain fixed regardless of enrollment, others fluctuate with the number of students served. “Reduced enrollment tends to increase the dining program’s cost as a percentage of the operating budget,” Schubert explained.
Hallman puts it more bluntly, stating, “Muhlenberg told Sodexo, ‘We want you to reduce hours.’ That’s not Sodexo making that call. That’s the College.”
The union vote and the budget cuts happened to arrive at the same time– a coincidence that made the situation look retaliatory even when it wasn’t. “People want a boogeyman,” Hallman said. “But it’s not like that. Everyone is looking out for their own needs. Nothing happens in a vacuum.”
Hallman’s own introduction to the union was abrupt: a knock at his door, one coworker, one union organizer and a pitch he initially mistook for political canvassing. “I thought they were here about the presidential election,” he joked. Instead, he quickly became a bridge between workers and management– someone who understood both sides, someone both groups trusted.
But this semester, the biggest issue he deals with isn’t ideological, it’s hours.
Many workers say schedules have been cut and shifts have disappeared. Furthermore, many part-time workers are struggling to meet the minimum number of hours required for benefits like health insurance.
Hallman doesn’t mince words: “We’re fighting and scraping for every hour we can get back.”
He himself supervises multiple teams that suddenly have to stretch themselves thin. “Break coverage used to be easy. I used to have two or three extra people, but now there’s no wiggle room. Everything is rigid and tight,” he said.
“We’re fighting and scraping for every hour we can get back.” – Evan Hallman
Workers have been describing the same thing from the other side of the counter. Some have taken on multiple roles at once. Others say they now perform tasks alone that were previously split between several employees. “People are doing one, two, sometimes three jobs that used to be separate positions,” Hallman explained.
“We’re doing the same amount of work with fewer people,” another anonymous worker said. “On some days, it feels like we’re scrambling all the time.”
In response to questions around reductions in hours and staffing, a Sodexo spokesperson highlighted that “staffing levels are always matched to the number of customers served and we are appropriately staffed for the students, staff and faculty we are serving each day on campus. We are proud of the employment opportunities we provide, with competitive wages, training and support to ensure our employees thrive in their positions.”
The spokesperson also said that they remained committed to maintaining a supportive environment, and as such, “support their right to decide to be union members.” Accordingly, they believe that recent changes have been a “testament to our team that they have fully embraced the challenge– and the results have been positive.”
Hallman acknowledged that this has been true for some workers– especially those who have been moved into full-time roles. But for others, he said, the transition has been difficult.
When the union contract went into effect, Sodexo required staff to “rebid” or reapply for their jobs– a standard process in unionized accounts, but one that still came as a shock. Some workers lost their previous positions. Others were moved into roles they hadn’t expected or didn’t want.
“We had people whose jobs were eliminated entirely,” Hallman said. “Pasta station, Simple Servings, extra deli shifts. Anywhere Sodexo could shave off labor, they did.” He doesn’t blame the local Sodexo managers. “They’ve been dealt a rough hand,” he said. “They’re told what the budget is, and then they’re told to make it work.”
That balancing act has left Hallman feeling caught in the middle– the person workers turn to for answers and support, and the person managers come to for guidance. Surprisingly, he says it has strengthened relationships rather than strained them. “My philosophy has always been, ‘Never ask an employee to do something you wouldn’t do.’ People see me working alongside them. That earns respect.”
Progress has been uneven. Though the union succeeded in pushing Sodexo to restore some hours– bringing back the evening deli shift, adding dish-room coverage, and shifting schedules– Hallman said these gains only partly address a deeper issue.
“There was a point when the district manager and district chef came in because students were complaining,” he said. “And they realized– this isn’t a food problem. This is a labor shortage problem.”
“In some places, they’ve cut too much. Some weeks, we’re just struggling to get by because there aren’t enough hands to do all the work.” – Evan HAllman
For Hallman, that realization underscores the limits of the current model. “You can’t get blood from a stone,” he said. “In some places, they’ve cut too much. Some weeks, we’re just struggling to get by because there aren’t enough hands to do all the work.”
Even as the union works to regain hours, workers still feel squeezed– especially when union dues are deducted from paychecks. “It’s tough,” Hallman said. “I want to tell people, ‘Your raise more than covers the dues.’ But that doesn’t take into account the hour cuts.”
Instead, he listens. He helps workers find extra shifts posted on an internal board. He passes concerns to Sodexo or union representatives. “But we can’t fix problems we don’t know about,” he said.
Photo by Kira Bretsky ’27.
Kabir Burman '27 is an international student from India double majoring in media & communication and political science. He is constantly looking for new ways to bring you the stories that matter and feature different perspectives. If you can't find him in the newsroom, you'll find him playing the piano, taking a nap, or planning his next trip to NYC!



















