Regarding past submissions about the 9/11 article, I have concerns about the fact that this is a highly nuanced issue and there is far more required context than provided in the publications.
Two editions ago, The Muhlenberg Weekly published an article by Arwen Lutwyche ‘26 entitled, “It’s 2025, and the 9/11 festivities are back.” In the article, Lutwyche brusquely and directly expresses their feelings and thoughts on U.S. actions in the Middle East post 9/11, focusing on the civilian death toll in Iraq as a result of the American invasion of the country. Lutwyche goes on to discuss the unadmirable actions of America in the Middle East in the twenty-first century, a fair point.
However, it is clear, to me at least, that while writing the article, Lutwyche was not shy of ruffling feathers. I think specifically of two lines in the article when Lutwyche was discussing WWII, Iraq war and foreign policy, which I will be taking out of the broader context, so I recommend everyone go read the larger context itself: “Ignore that the U.S. stayed out of both wars as long as it could. Pretend [the United States]were heroes whose boat just arrived late,” and “they [Americans] animate their corpses to fight today’s cultural battles through performative patriotism.” Now, many people got offended and hurt by these comments, specifically, I myself was no fan of the insinuation that America’s involvement in World War I and World War II was for any reason other than the preservation of global freedom and liberty, which is what I personally believe they were both unquestionably about. Furthermore, the line regarding the reanimation of 9/11 victims may be an analysis of Americans’ tendencies to claim to speak on behalf of the victims of 9/11 and cite them in political disputes, yes, but I believe Lutwyche did so in such a way that was poorly worded and, like Jenny Ryan ‘27 said, condescending. In an article that focused on something as eminent as the unnecessary and colonial conflicts in the Middle East, I feel as though Lutwyche undermined their own objective by getting off topic and citing unrelated events, such as America’s involvement in WWII, for the sake of nothing more than shock value and phallic jokes.
“This freedom that makes America so great allows writers to offend others by having access to freedom of speech and freedom of the press, the same rights that other writers have when they write divisive articles that spark backlash, as seen in prior publications of The Weekly.”
This prompted a response from Ryan. In a Letter to the Editor, Ryan expressed that she was rather upset and offended by Lutwyche’s word choice- fair. However, in Ryan’s opening paragraph, she states the following: “I am concerned and questioning as to why this was an acceptable piece of writing… also wondering what the process of editorial review and approval was that allowed such a divisive piece to be published?” The thing that allowed the divisive piece by Lutwyche to be published was the same thing that has allowed for every other divisive take that The Weekly has published, ranging from opinion pieces about our colleges’ handling of the firing of Maura Finkelstein to reflections on the assasination of Charlie Kirk. Ryan answers this very question in her final paragraph, stating that, “the tremendous blessing of living in the United States, [is that it is] a free and prosperous nation.” This freedom that makes America so great allows writers to offend others by having access to freedom of speech and freedom of the press, the same rights that other writers have when they write divisive articles that spark backlash, as seen in prior publications of The Weekly.
Finally, Ryan states, “Not only is the author unable to disassociate U.S. foreign policy with the 309,472 lives…” We can never separate foreign policy from the deaths that go along with it. Our foreign policy during WWII was pretty good- defend global freedom and stop the rise of fascism and nazism. Our policy in Iraq was built on the lies of Dick Cheney and George W. Bush; our policy in Iraq resulted in 300,000 unnecessary deaths due to purposely falsified information from a Republican administration. Moreover, after all this, we continue to arm and fund Israel as our closest ally in the region, even after its government was allowed to carry out what the United Nations itself determined has been a genocide against innocent Palestinian people. We are responsible for our actions and our allies’ actions everywhere around the world, and suggesting that we can pick and choose what we claim responsibility for based on the results is as un-American as it can get.
Seth Buckwalter ’28
It is the policy of The Muhlenberg Weekly to foster relationships with its readership, including through discourse in its Opinion/Editorial section. Therefore, members of the College Community are encouraged to submit Letters to the Editor on any topic of interest to Muhlenberg, in direct reference to an article or otherwise.


















