Home Campus Voices Letter to the Editor: The inherent politics of memorialization

Letter to the Editor: The inherent politics of memorialization

829

Memory is not apolitical, violence does not exist in a vacuum, and there is no honest way to examine and memorialize an event like the attacks on Sept. 11, 2001 and not consider them within the context of the world that preceded and followed them. To say that memory is political is not to say that it is always an inherently partisan action, but that the events that one chooses to remember and place value on the remembering of are socially mediated. They are inseparably the result of the communities in which a person resides, a fact especially true of memories taking place outside of one’s own lifetime, or of a “national remembrance.”

The discussions in Arwen Lutwyche’s ‘26 opinion piece regarding the Young America’s Foundation (YAF) Sept. 11th memorial and Jenny Ryan’s ‘27 response letter felt, on both sides, like reductivist cherry picking of the history and consequences of the Sept. 11 attacks. They were arguments that were both made without the acknowledgement that their position on the memorial might be a result of the individual socialization and values of their authors, and both were (in differing capacities) ignorant of the broader social and historical context surrounding the memorial and leading to the ways in which the principle of “Never Forget” is exercised.

I do not think that “people have truly forgotten” about the Sept. 11 attacks. I also think that it is intentionally disingenuous to posit that acknowledging the lasting consequences of the United States military and political involvement in the Middle East (directly and indirectly), can in any way be examined separately from the events of that day. While I believe there is no right way to remember an event like Sept. 11, there are certainly ways that are obfuscatory of the truth of the matter. It felt like an intentional half-truth when Ryan said that the four-and-a-half million deaths that the Costs of War project calculates have happened in post-9/11 warzones in the 24 years following the attacks “may or may not have been a direct result of that event” and equally so when Lutwyche stated that the only victims of those actions worth memorializing are those in the United States and Iraq; on Sept. 11 alone 102 countries lost their citizens, and during the War on Terror the United States also engaged in decades of violence in, to name a few: Afghanistan, Pakistan, Syria and Yemen. 

The pieces both based their arguments about the justifiability of the memorial’s presence on an arbitrary series of judgements about whose deaths were worth acknowledging and grieving publicly. In Ryan’s letter, she accused Lutwyche of being “unable to disassociate U.S. foreign policy with the 309,472 [Iraqi and American] lives.” It is unclear what the 4.5-4.7 million direct and indirect casualties of the United States’ conflicts in the wake of the attacks would have died from if not the result of United States foreign policy. Even ignoring indirect deaths, the Costs of War project estimates at least 940,000 people have been killed as a direct consequence of United States military action in the Middle East since 2001. To look even more narrowly at solely United States perspective, there is no way to make a substantiated argument that 14,986 U.S. service members, Department of Defense civilians and contractors who would not have physically been in the direct line of fire had it not been for the demands of their nation’s military apparatus somehow did not lose their lives as the result of U.S. foreign policy.

The United States’ modern military involvement in the Middle East dates back to the aftermath of World War II and the Western powers’ series of treaties and land grabs as they divided up the resources (people, territory and crucially: oil) that the region had to offer. It was the United States’ decades of violence in the region that the Sept. 11 attacks were explicitly in response to, something which neither writer mentioned in their piece. Among these actions were the foundation of the nation of Israel. Lutwyche made passing mention of Israel’s genocide of the Palestinain people as only means to introduce the concept of indirect casualties of military engagement, writing, “We have all learned by now, from the ongoing genocide of Palestinians, what the indirect deaths of war are.” The statement reduced two years of indiscriminate violence against the Palestinian people to a data point, as if had it not been for their deaths “we all” would never have understood the idea. The moment was small, but it was an example of a maneuver Lutwyche made throughout their entire piece: bringing up nations’ongoing tragedies seemingly arbitrarily to engage in the same “[animating] their corpses to fight today’s cultural battles” that they accused the memorial of. The dead and displaced of Palestine, Iraq and the Sept. 11 attacks became numbers in service of “[seeing] how the balance shifts” in order to measure who is more deserving of their right to be mourned.

“The authors are both right in pointing out that no memorial can capture the true scale of the Sept. 11 attacks and their aftermath, but that does not make the act of memorialization a waste, or mean that people are wrong to feel strongly moved by the reminder of those deaths”

Was the purpose of the memorial, then, because people had “truly forgotten about the unimaginable loss” or only to “animate [the victims’] corpses?” Ryan’s letter suggested that the United States’ founding principles of “liberty, sacrifice and unity…demand we honor those lost without politicizing their memory.” That depoliticization– which both authors attempted in their respective directions– is in itself an inescapably political act. Lutwyche was justified to say that the 2,977 flags (all American despite the victims’ actual nationalities) were a display towards a specifically American grieving that quietly supported an intentional narrative about the events. After all, YAF is a national conservative organization whose services include facilitating speakers like right-wing demagogue Dennis Prager and Oliver North (of Iran-Contra affair acclaim) visiting college campuses, and whose President Scott Walker stated he would not be opposed to escalating the War on Terror during his 2016 bid for the oval office, relating it to his experiences deploying the national guard against protesters as the governor of Wisconsin. Whether or not the event stated a messaging objective, by implicitly portraying all the victims as American and receiving support and materials from YAF, the memorial worked as a tool towards the reinforcement of the specific narrative of 9/11 as an isolated American tragedy. It was reflective of a larger national strategy by organizations like YAF to uphold the image of the United States’ War on Terror and continual offensive military engagement worldwide as justified actions.

The critical examination of these kinds of intentionally selective memories is incredibly important, and I believe, although Ryan states the founding principles of our nation “demand we honor those lost without politicizing their memory,” that the act of imagining a national memory that exists free from politics and therefore deserves to not be questioned and critiqued at all available opportunities is misinformed at best. At worst (as has happened with the War on Terror), it enables our nation to enact unchecked violence with a body count on the scale of nations. 

The authors are both right in pointing out that no memorial can capture the true scale of the Sept. 11 attacks and their aftermath, but that does not make the act of memorialization a waste, or mean that people are wrong to feel strongly moved by the reminder of those deaths. I believe what it does require, however, is the constant critical examination and contextualization of who we do and do not remember when we talk about remembering, and how we can honor them in ways that truthfully represent the lives of those we say we are mourning. It requires not letting ourselves become blinded by the idea that we might somehow be able to examine tragedy away from our own social worlds.

Ian Graybill ’26

+ posts

It is the policy of The Muhlenberg Weekly to foster relationships with its readership, including through discourse in its Opinion/Editorial section. Therefore, members of the College Community are encouraged to submit Letters to the Editor on any topic of interest to Muhlenberg, in direct reference to an article or otherwise.