Across the aisle: tariffs and tensions

How the U.S. Economy Is Navigating a Trade-Centric Strategy

534

NOTE: This article was written in May of 2025.  

In April 2025, President Donald Trump delivered on a campaign promise by announcing sweeping new tariffs that reignited debates about trade, protectionism, and the global economy. Framing the issue as one of national security and economic sovereignty, Trump invoked emergency powers to impose a universal 10% tariff on all imports, effective April 5. In tandem, he introduced additional “reciprocal” tariffs targeting countries with which the U.S. runs trade deficits— most notably China. As of April, Chinese goods faced very high combined tariffs, though many of the steepest rates have since been paused or capped under a temporary truce with China.

The moves have disrupted trade flows and rattled markets. While Trump and his supporters argue these tariffs will restore fairness to global trade, rebuild American manufacturing, and reduce dependency on foreign supply chains, economists warn of rising consumer prices, strained diplomatic ties, and potential long-term damage to the rules-based international trading order. Companies like Adidas, Walmart and Home Depot have already begun raising retail prices in response to supply chain and import cost pressures.

Amidst this evolving trade landscape, BergVotes asked students from across the political spectrum to weigh in.

The Big Picture: Trump has framed these tariffs as a way to “restore fairness” in global trade and protect American industry. Do you agree with this framing? What does “fair trade” mean to you, and who gets to define it?

College Democrats: 

President Trump has framed his use of tariffs as a way to “restore fairness” in global trade and protect American industry. However, this framing is both misleading and economically damaging. Tariffs under the guise of “fairness” often function not as tools of strategic trade policy, but as instruments of protectionism and political posturing. 

True “fair trade” is not defined unilaterally or through the lens of dominance. It is collaborative, inclusive and grounded in shared global standards that prioritize sustainability, equity and development. A just trade system must support developing economies, promote social responsibility and prioritize climate-conscious innovation, not inflate prices for working families or provoke harmful retaliatory measures from global partners. 

College Republicans:

Yes, this framing is reasonable. From a conservative standpoint, “fair trade” prioritizes reciprocal relationships. If the U.S. allows foreign goods with low tariffs, those countries should do the same for American exports. Tariffs are an effective tool to level the playing field when other nations engage in protectionist practices or manipulate currency. Fair trade means securing American interests first, ensuring domestic workers and industries aren’t undercut by countries with weak labor standards, state subsidies or IP [intellectual property] theft. Defining fairness should ultimately lie with sovereign democratic nations, not unelected international bodies.

Women in Politics: 

We disagree with the way he is going about “restoring” fairness. These tariffs are aggressive, they hurt the consumer and the average American producer (overall NOT protecting American industry). They hurt our allies economically and the bonds we’ve built as well.

Fair trade– technically anyone can define it however they like. Unfortunately, the definition that our president has chosen holds more power than any individual definition or international definition that could be provided. Either way, fair trade (to me) provides everyone with what they need to the extent that other countries are not limited by each individual nation’s pursuits for economic success, resources and profit.

Maybe we agree here with the sentiment of fairness in global trade.

Global Leadership: Some critics argue that these tariffs signal a retreat from America’s leadership in promoting free and open markets. Others say it’s a long-overdue correction to globalization’s excesses. Where do you stand?

College Democrats:

We believe there is a solution which includes a holistic reform of the global trade system–one that fosters transparency, includes marginalized voices, supports sustainable development, avoids weaponizing tariffs for political leverage and safeguarding the livelihoods of Americans. In an increasingly interconnected world, fair trade must mean inclusive trade, shaped not by fear or bravado, but by collective progress and a commitment to justice.

Rather than taking us forward, Trump’s approach reverts to outdated nineteenth century thinking, ignoring decades of economic data, evolving global trade structures and the pressing realities of climate change and technological advancement. The future of trade should not be about isolationism, short-term political wins and the assertion of dominance, it should be about recommitting to a rules-based, multilateral system that balances economic growth with sustainability, labor rights and fairness for all.

College Republicans: 

This is a necessary correction. Free trade is only beneficial when it is fair and reciprocal. For decades, globalization has benefited multinational corporations and foreign competitors while hollowing out American manufacturing and small towns. Tariffs represent a shift toward strategic nationalism– defending American interests and values in a competitive global environment. Global leadership doesn’t mean passive acceptance of unfair trade– it means leading by strength, setting standards and protecting citizens.

Women in Politics: 

Through an objective and definition based analysis, President Trump is a conservative with populist ideologies. The definition of populism is “a political approach that strives to appeal to ordinary people who feel that their concerns are disregarded by established elite groups” (Oxford Languages Dictionary).  We can see a direct correlation to this idea to one of Trump’s past campaigning ideas of “draining the D.C. [District of Colombia] swamp” meaning getting rid of the political elites that are in our capitol building deciding the lives of everyday American people. Anti-international and anti-trade are common aspects of what populist leaders believe in so they are focused on an isolationist viewpoint. This will cause the support of international trade to decrease within the American electorate that voted for President Trump in this case. It may look to the more global world that America is taking a step back but really populists think they are standing up to the norms we have decided on for such an interconnected world. Tariffs do not signal a retreat of leadership from America as the “America First” ideal is promoting building a stronger America from within rather than having to rely on other countries for what Americans need. 

Geopolitics & Trade: In today’s interconnected world, trade is deeply intertwined with foreign policy. How do you think these tariffs affect America’s diplomatic standing, particularly with allies like Canada, Mexico and members of the European Union (EU)?

College Democrats:

Implementing tariffs on allies such as Canada, Mexico or the EU is harmful to our diplomatic standing, not only as a trade partner but also as a secure ally. The use of tariffs as a tool of diplomacy puts a strain on these important ties and undermines the trust we have formed with these crucial allies. It promotes an idea of economic nationalism and pushes us closer to isolationism which is detrimental to our world standing. Rather than fostering collaboration, these policies risk isolating the United States and limiting its ability to forge global coalitions on pivotal political issues.  They could also lead our allies to seek alternative trade partnerships with competitors like China. A more sustainable approach would therefore prioritize the restoration of trade relationships through diplomatic engagement, equitable trade agreements and a shared sense of accountability. This would allow us to maintain and strengthen our existing alliances. 

College Republicans: 

From a conservative perspective, trade is more of a tool of national interests, not an end in itself. Tariffs, especially those rooted in economic security and reciprocity such as steel and aluminum tariffs, China trade war tariffs, Canadian softwood lumber tariffs and retaliatory tariffs on EU Over Airbus Subsidies, are examples not of a retreat from diplomacy but a recalibration of it. They send a clear message: America will no longer tolerate being taken advantage of in lopsided trade relationships, even with allies like Germany, with whom we had a $68.9 billion trade deficit in 2022.

As Republicans, we argue that reciprocity is foundational to strong alliances. True partners should respect mutually beneficial trade, not rely on the U.S. to absorb deficits while their industries thrive under protectionist policies. Tariffs are a way to restore balance and bring allies back to the negotiating table.

Women in Politics: 

Given how harsh and reactionary President Trump has been with tariffs, it is no surprise that allying countries are on the defensive, pulling away from American dependency and relations. As an example, Mexico acknowledged the difficulty of the recently established tariff directed trade order. However, unlike other countries, they also recognize the advantage they have as their free trade agreement with the U.S. remains standing despite other setbacks. While Mexico doesn’t face the worst of Trump’s economic attacks, the preservation of this agreement is not guaranteed and they are beginning to feel the impacts of tariffs implemented elsewhere (Sánchez et al., 2025). In comparison, many European and Asian countries are rethinking their security dependence on the U.S. as they try to shield themselves from the unpredictability of present day American trade (Puri, 2025). While this may initially present as a win for the Trump administration and their “America First” policy, it does not positively impact the U.S. economy as they would have otherwise hoped. With less dependence on America, other countries are promoting internal purchasing meaning the U.S. is losing international buyers that normally fuel domestic markets. Not only that, as European countries withdraw economically, their actions represent diminished trust in America indicating further American isolationism, decreased international support and therefore lessened faith in the power of American diplomacy.

Canada on the other hand, historically one of our closest allies, has openly criticized the Trump administration for its relentless and harsh trade policies from the start, calling the tariffs “unjustified” and immediately responding with a reciprocal 25% retaliatory tariff (Government of Canada, 2025). Previous Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said that, in this unnecessary trade war, there will be no winners as the wellbeing of millions of people are at stake. Regardless, Canada will stand firm and fight for its own economy, particularly because some view these policies as an attack on the country and a means of weakening the Canadian economy in order to eventually annex the country as the fifty-first State of America (Drenon et al., 2025). This perception not only gives rise to distrust in the American economy, but also a distancing from U.S.-Canadian relations that have remained peaceful for decades. While Trump has put a temporary pause on some international tariffs, lingering tensions and distrust are bound to keep wary allies at arms length. Trump has made his “America First” policies clear, forcing countries to take his words seriously– including those threats that go beyond economic policy changes.

+ posts

Kabir Burman '27 is an international student from India double majoring in media & communication and political science. He is constantly looking for new ways to bring you the stories that matter and feature different perspectives. If you can't find him in the newsroom, you'll find him playing the piano, taking a nap, or planning his next trip to NYC!