
The story of the 2025 Muhlenberg softball team begins far before official practices began on Feb. 1; it begins on May 1, 2024, in Gettysburg Pa. The 4th seed Mules lost 0-7 to Gettysburg in the Centennial Conference Championship. The Mules have come back stronger with a freshman class of ten recruits, all of whom are ready to contribute, senior leaders hoping to go out on top and relentless out-of-season preparation.
From the start of the school year, the Mules focused on one of the keys to all college athletics: mental strength. According to Kaitlyn Buurman ‘25, the entire team engaged via Zoom in a sports performance program called Anti Fragility about every other week for an hour and a half. “We talked about different strategies on and off the field regarding mental toughness, performance and healthy mechanisms,” said Buurman. While the words spoken were undoubtedly important in that moment, they have noticed a sense of positivity and mental fortitude that has carried from September and helped them early on in their campaign: “Now that we are in season a lot of that work has translated into our play,” Buurman explained.
Kaya Mahy ‘25 reinforced that the team strongly supports each other which is abiding by a word called Mudita. Mudita represents joy for the other Mules and empathy. “For softball, there can only be ten people in the game at a time so there’s a lot of time where you need to have that Mudita and know that it’s someone else’s turn right now, and they might do well. Even though it wasn’t you, it was for the greater good of the team so be happy for them, and we have a lot of that,” said Mahy.
Another unique aspect of this year’s softball team is their outstanding presence in the classroom and as intellectual participants in the Muhlenberg community. It would be remiss not to mention their overall admirable behavior and kindness towards their peers. Head Coach Sarah Leavenworth says that is a part of their own culture. “We speak kindly to each other and we look out for each other and the seniors have set that precedent from the first day.” Each member of the softball team must balance the challenging task of being a member of a championship-caliber team and attending an academically rigorous college. Coach Leavenworth praised the team’s abilities by first making a joke: “This is not a cult.”
“We are presidents of clubs, we are members of organizations, we do internships, we study abroad, we maintain a 3.6 team GPA [Grade Point Average] and we do softball,” said Leavenworth. For example, Buurman and Dani Roban ‘25 are co-presidents of Head in the Game, a student-athlete mental health-focused club and Mahy is the secretary. Justine Bergara ‘25 is the head of the Women in Business club and Skyla Campisi ‘27 is the co-founder of the Women in Politics club. Coach Leavenworth revealed that when a recruit was visiting they coincidentally saw a senior mentoring a freshman who was studying. Indeed, the team is full of well-rounded student-athletes who care about academics and their role in their community but it’s important not to forget that they are still hungry athletes. Coach Leavenworth described the team as fun but competitive. “They’re having fun but they’re also pretty darn serious about softball,” she said.
After three weeks of official training, the Mules faced Kean in a double-header on Feb. 25. The Mules did some scrimmages by splitting their team into two, practiced throwing and catching and did some live at-bats with pitching in the Dietrich Field House. This work alongside all the other hours of work put into the team led the Mules to success against a young but tough Kean squad. The Mules won 11-3 in game one. Coach Leavenworth went with the power lineup and they came through in a big way, producing 11 runs. 11 runs scored on 12 hits including two home runs. Coach Leavenworth tried her speed lineup in game two and the Mules won again in a tight contest. It was the Mule’s speed that helped in the clutch. The game was tied four to four as Ava Starlazzi ‘28 ran for an infield hit and then when the Kean player’s throw went awry, she went to second base. Then, Mahy hit a single to bring in the go-ahead run. The Mules swept a doubleheader to open the season for the first time since 2006.
Buurman said there were lessons to be learned from both games. She said in the first game “not letting up” was crucial to preventing any Kean comeback. Buurman believes that anything can happen, especially as the Mules go on to play ranked opponents, so it was important to set the standard in this game and not relax with the lead. In the second game, Buurman emphasized that “maintaining a high energy level” would have possibly allowed for a smoother win and is certainly an area to improve in. Coach Leavenworth liked “the pressure” that was put on the freshman in game two because she believed it would help them mature as players.
Before the game against the Stockton Ospreys, Coach Leavenworth gave Stockton their due credit: “They were very competitive in a very competitive conference last year so it’s going to be a tough weekend.” Coach Leavenworth also provided the information that Stockton has a large group of freshmen but also has their five best players returning, including star pitcher, Narina Tramp.
On March 1, the Mules traveled down to southern N.J. to play a tough Stockton squad. The Mules suffered a 2-11 defeat in the first game of the doubleheader and a 2-7 loss in the second game to the talented Ospreys. Coach’s words rang true as the Mules fell victim to good pitching and offensive production which they couldn’t match.
“We didn’t let things outside of our control get to us. Stockton’s a good team and good teams are going to hit the ball hard and do all those good things that good teams do and we kept our heads up from start to finish,” Mahy reflected. Mahy believes that handling the loss, especially in game one, being the Mules’ first loss of the season will set a good precedent for when the Mules go to battle against other regionally ranked opponents. The Mules got base runners in both games but couldn’t bring them home. Mahy said that situational hitting was re-examined during the practice one day after the doubleheader.
“The Muhlenberg softball team opened their season with a sweep over Kean, while unfortunately being swept by Stockton a few days later”
Mahy viewed the Mule’s batting approaches against Stockton as another issue. “We saw the score and we felt that everything was riding on this at bat because there is so much more work to be done to win,” Mahy continued saying, “I think that pressure didn’t fuel us but instead we got more timid in our approach.”
On a more positive note, when the Mules were asked about the stadium set to be completed in late March or early April, they were ecstatic. The stadium will be located in between Scotty Wood Stadium and the soccer field officially called Varsity Field. All three players interviewed: Buurman, Mahy and Svenningson all felt that it would make softball more present in the Muhlenberg community. “Even though I’ll be gone, the idea of having a field on campus is huge for the softball program so it’s exciting,” said Mahy. “We do struggle with having an off-campus field and all away games, but the field is in a prime location and we have games during the week at three and five so people can stand and watch for a second before heading to their dorms.” Mahy remembered doing the same short, stop-by style viewership with soccer games and she never imagined it could become a reality for the Mule’s softball as well. “I’m honored,” said Buurman, “I came in as a freshman and I didn’t really think that we would ever have this opportunity so the fact that it’s all really happening and you can see it is so cool, I can’t even put it in words.”
Coach Leavenworth noted the logistical issues with playing at Cedar Creek Park and how logistics will be much easier having a facility on campus. “Just the time that saves us, not driving back and forth, packing stuff and unpacking stuff. By the time you set everything up and you hit traffic it takes a while. And for people coming late to practice, instead of needing a ride, they can just go to the locker room,” said Coach Leavenworth.
The Mules are smart, supportive and, yes, really good at softball. They look to build on wins and learn lessons from losses early in the season in pursuit of the result of the ’22 team – to be Centennial Conference champions.

















